Topic

Ti Pot: .6L or 1.3L?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
Herb Tassin BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 1:48 pm

Need to buy a Ti pot. Seems like the magic number for two adults is four cups (for 2 ProPaks), or a 1.3L pot.

Any thoughts on which is quicker/more efficient? Rather than boiling 4 cups in a 1.3L pot, is their any advantage in speed or fuel efficiency to be gained by boiling 2 cups twice in a .6L pot? If there is, is any incremental advantage outweighed by the inconvenience factor?

Thanks!

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 1:54 pm

The problem with putting 2 cups in a 0.6 L pot is when it boils – over. Really, 1.5 cups is the most you can safely put in a 0.6 L pot. Go for the 1.3 L (or 1.5 L) pot every time.

Cheers

Herb Tassin BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 2:00 pm

Thanks, Roger. You rock!

Is there enough capacity on the 1.3L to safely boil and pour 4 cups, or do you recommend a 1.5?

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 2:15 pm

Depends… are you just boiling water, then dumping it into packages? Or would you be adding food to the boiling water in the pot? If you're just boiling and dumping, 1.3L is fine. If you're cooking in the pot, I'd aim north of 1.5L to 2L territory. Opinions differ, but personally I find it a lot easier to just wipe out a pot than to deal with a slimy bag. If you're a "bagger," and a 1.3L is where you're at, Evernew's 1.3L UL Ti is a good bet. If you're a, um, "potter," then you might check out a MSR Ti pot, or an AGG aluminum, or…

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 5:09 pm

As Brad said.

I use an MSR 1.5 L Ti pot, but that is because I have one. Certainly, cooking in the pot takes volume!

Cheers

Mary D BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 5:56 pm

As others have said, it depends on your cooking style.

Washing dishes is one of my most hated chores, so I just boil water and do freezer bag cooking (hooray for Sarbar!). (That slimy freezer bag is great for your garbage, which in my case includes used TP, since I can't function without it.) For just boiling water, if you're always solo, the smaller Ti pot is great. If you often go out with another person and use a single pot and stove for both of you, then get the larger pot. This would also work if you rehydrate your meals in the pot with a cozy rather than using the freezer bag. but don't use the stove after the water boils. (Of course you have both a dirty plastic bag and a dirty pot with this method.)

If you actually want to cook in the pot, I wouldn't recommend a Ti pot at all. It gets hot spots over your stove flame and doesn't distribute the heat to the rest of the pot. (I can hold the top of a pot of boiling water in my Ti pot with my bare hands.) You'll invariably spend a lot of time scouring off burned spots afterwards. I'm sure there are some here who cook successfully with Ti, but I haven't been able to. I'd want anodized or coated aluminum for real cooking. Remember also, if you're going to cook items in the pot, you need a bigger pot. For example, cooking pasta involves rapidly boiling water (which expands a lot) plus foam from the starch in the pasta. You really don't want your pot to boil over and create a big mess, which is what will happen if you try to do real cooking in a tiny pot.

Even with just boiling water, I'd use the bigger pot if you want 4 cups of boiling water at one time. I don't know about the fuel, but boiling water twice takes more fussing. If you want boiling water at different times, instead of all at once, so that you have to reheat the water, I would guess that there wouldn't be much difference in fuel usage for boiling smaller amounts of water from scratch twice in the small pot or reheating larger amounts 2-3 times in a larger pot. Please note that my guess is not based on any empirical evidence!

PostedOct 17, 2009 at 6:04 pm

I only carry my 550ml pot. Even for two! I've had no problems with dozens of two cup boils.

Jack

James Naphas BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 8:20 pm

The 1.3 is a bit of overkill for two; you rarely need that much capacity. A .6 is more of a solo item, IMHO, at least if you're boiling water for both food and a hot drink. A .9L, such as the ones from evernew or REI, OTOH, works really well for two, and saves you a couple of ounces vs. the 1.3.

I believe that warming up 1L or so at one time will take less fuel than doing .5 twice.

Herb Tassin BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 8:21 pm

Thank you, Mary, for such a detailed response. I'm sure I'll want to do some cooking, so I may be better off with an aluminum pot. I bought the GSI Dualist kit, but that was before I discovered BPL several weeks ago, so I was trying to determine whether a better option existed.

My 1.8L GSI pot with lid weighs 9.7 oz., vs. 8.5 oz. for the 1.9L AGG Ti Pot with lid, and I can live with 1.2 oz. Plus the Dualist comes with four of the GSI bowls that Roger gave such a good review. And that "sink" bag might come in handy. The sporks suck, but I've aready ordered a couple of BPL Long handled Ti spoons so I'm set.

Grand Canyon here I come!

PostedOct 17, 2009 at 8:29 pm

From my testing, my alcohol stove uses about 50% more fuel to boil a liter (4 cups) instead of a pint (2 cups). My stove takes about 20g of fuel to boil the pint and 30g to boil the liter. Unless I'm grossly mistaken, you're much better off to do it all in once batch….and it'll take much less time.

It doesn't take very much cooking in a larger pot to overcome the weight disadvantage, if taking a smaller pot means boiling two batches of water.

PostedOct 17, 2009 at 8:44 pm

Since my experience differs drastically from some of the advice offered, here I go.

On long distance hikes, when my appetite is large, I find my .83 liter pot to be too small. For normal hikes, it's the right size. Also, for normal hikes my 1.3 liter pot is serviceable for two, if I'm hiking with a female friend or other small eater. But if it's two big eaters, 1.3 liters is too small. I used a 1.3 liter pot for most of the PCT, sometimes even eating the whole pot myself. While I was fine with the calories, the effort and time taken to eat 1.3 liters of beans and rice was too much!

For long distance hikes, my ideal pot size would be exactly one liter. For normal hikes, .83 is just about perfect. So, if I were to buy again, I'd buy a one liter pot and a two liter pot. Two liters is a little much for myself and a girlfriend on a normal hike but c'est la vie. At this point what works really well for a girlfriend and I, on a hike where we both want the calories but aren't going nuts, is to bring both the .83 liter pot and the 1.3 liter pot. In the small pot, we cook vegetables and the 1.3 liter pot we cook starches. Then they get mixed together to create about exactly 1.3 liters of food (which would overflow the single 1.3 liter pot). And we thus also have two pots to eat out of.

And heck no, I'm not buying again! I have eleven high quality camping pots already. Just no Ti 1 and two liter pots…

Obviously, I like to cook in my pots. .55 liters for two people is just batty to me.
Isn't it amazing how we can overthink these things?

Herb Tassin BPL Member
PostedOct 17, 2009 at 9:08 pm

Thanks for the feedback, Jack and James.

Thanks, Dan, for verifying what I suspected. Great to know!

Thanks for the great info, Jack H. Think I'll keep the 1.8L, and get something smaller if I start to do solo stuff, and have a larger and smaller pair like you suggest. Now to come up with a trail-workable Jambalaya recipe!

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 4:18 am

I would look into the new hardanodized pots for the new Trangia UL series, made of extra thin aluminium. These are well made, long lasting, very light (no heavier than titanium), and they do not really stick (there are also heavier true non stick versions, however). They are really good to cook in. They come with the Trangia 25 and 27 stoves, but are also available separately. Cooking pots exist in 1, 1.5 and 1.75 liter, and frying pans/lids in 18 and 22 cm diameter. See: http://www.trangia.se/english/3652.directions_for_use.html click on weight table for models, sizes and weights. An 18 cm frying pan plus a 1.5 liter pot would be 192 grams (plus gripper). With the 1.75 liter pot the combo would be 198 grams, but I am not sure if the frying pan will fit as a lid onto the 1.75 liter pot. You could ask them.

Herb Tassin BPL Member
PostedOct 18, 2009 at 8:42 am

Cool looking stuff. Thanks, Willem. Read about, but hadn't seen the stoves before. Thanks for sending that my way.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 10:58 am

The Trangia stoves are very good, and very convenient to use. However, unlike the Trangia UL pots and pans, the stove bit is heavy by UL standards: the windscreen is very efficient, but unnecessarily heavy, and the actual burner is similarly good but heavy.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 11:41 am

Willem, do you have the dimensions of the 1.5 pot…will it fit inside a MSR 1.5L titanium pot or vice versa?

Bailey

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 11:55 am

Keep in mind that buying a pot that is borderline too small is not a good way to save weight. The goal of saving weight is to make your outdoors experience more enjoyable. Saving 1 oz but having to cook in a pot that constantly threatening to overflow is not going to enhance your enjoyment out there.

It's better to save weight through materials (ie. Ti vs. Aluminum) or technique (ie. freezer bag meals don't require as large of a pot) if these trade-offs work for you.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 12:07 pm

Aside from agreeing with Jack that 600ml/1.3 litre is way to small for us, I would add that there is fuel efficiency to be gained by doing one boil in a larger diameter pot rather than two smaller boils. It's also more sociable if the person you are with is your partner and you wish to eat you meal at the same time…

So the answer depends on how much you boil, how you *cook*, and who you are sharing a meal with.

Oh, and anodised aluminium is really great stuff if you are into pot cooking. The gear from AGG is fabulous.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 12:19 pm

The Trangia dimensions are on the Trangia weight table that I linked to earlier. I don't have the dimensions for the MSR 1.5. litre pot, but I would think that if the content is the same, it is unlikely that one will fit inside the other. I have both the 1.5 and 1.75 litre pots, so I am happy to get them out and provide even more detailed information. As for the weights, th einteresting thing is that these pots are as light or even lighter than most Ti pots. I can testify from personal experience that they hardly ever stick, and cook very well.

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 3:06 pm

My MSR 1.5L titanium pot has a ~6 1/8" diameter so if a Trangia 1.5L pot can slide into it, or vice versa, GREAT!. Height of the pots don't matter to me.

Bailey

PostedOct 18, 2009 at 4:28 pm

I'm about to get my first fuel stove — not looking forward to it but need to burn petrol and other fine fuels. I'm going with the MSR Whipserlite Internationale. From the photos, it looks as if my Snowpeak Titanium Solo (830mL/28 fl oz) (which I always need to fill 3 times per session anyway) would not be very stable on this stove. So pot height (and hence diameter) DOES matter to me. I'm about to get a 1.5 ish L ti pot for solo travel. Probably the MSR because I would hope (not assume!) that that they design their pots with their stoves in mind.) Thank you for your posts re: pot size/shape efficiency.

IMO, a 600mL put would not be very versatile. You're going to be leaving some room in the pot when boiling and even more room if you are doing actual cooking.

Hikin’ Jim BPL Member
PostedOct 19, 2009 at 10:12 pm

FWIW, the pot sizes I've used, all with equally good success, on my Whisperlite are:
5" x 2.5" (~1.0L)
5.75" x 3" (~1.5L)
7.5" x 4.75" (~2.5L)

PostedOct 20, 2009 at 7:58 am

Do not forget that when figuring out capacity, work in other water you might need. So if you need 4 cups to just prepare dinner, what about hot drinks? Do you like them? Then add in more volume or a second boil.
When it is two of us I carry a 2L often. That way I can boil dinner water, hot drinks and wash up water at night (for washing hands and faces, brushing teeth and rinsing out cups and spoons….)

Viewing 24 posts - 1 through 24 (of 24 total)
Loading...