Topic

Need help finding a bomber daypack.

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
Dave . BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 9:26 am

I'm looking for a daypack that I can use for (1) day hiking (2) cragging and climbing and (3) commuting to work on my bike.

I don't care about weight. In fact I expect the pack to be heavy and it needs to be able to stand up to lots of bushwhacking and cragging.

Ideally it would have the following attributes:

– Fit long torso (23")
– 30 – 35 L
– Carries weight well (think rack and rope)
– Natural/subdued colors (olive drab etc.)

Any suggestions?

As a point of reference, I'm considering this pack:

http://www.tadgear.com/shop.php?id=508

But it's a little short in terms of torso length.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 9:53 am

Mystery Ranch. Think Dana. Now making military/tactical packs, some recreational. Bomber. 5-pound bomber for the "3 day assault."

The Kestrels are quite nice packs, good frame, awesome value. Pretty durable. Comes in a green, but more of an avocado/tan combo. 2 torso lengths, both adjustable, m/l size for over 19" torso w/about 4+ inches of adjustment.

But I think you're more in the Mystery Ranch market right now.

Lori P BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 9:58 am

Over at backpacker.com there's a video of someone dragging a bunch of packs behind a truck at 60 mph… Granite Gear was the winner over a bunch of name brands, survived with a torn lid.

I like my Granite Gear backpack and have considered getting one of the Vapor series for a long dayhike/1-2 night pack.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 10:05 am

One note about MR – they understate their weight by about 15%.

Don't ask me how I know this.

Nathan Baker BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 10:36 am

What about one of Cilogear's work sacks?

Edit: NM, I missed the 23" torso requirment. Cilo only goes up to 22"

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 11:09 am

Try Grivel, I use their 35+5 and love it- best looking pack I've ever owned and super comfortable. I use it as a day pack, over night and several day pack, and commuter work pack.
cheers,
fred

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 11:47 am

Another vote for the Osprey Kestrel. Pretty tough and carry weight very well. Also very compressible.
Note: the 28 does not have a frame, just the 23, 38, & 48.

My guess is that MR packs would be tougher though.

Dave . BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 1:12 pm

Very helpful so far. Thanks for the responses.

Mystery Ranch has definitely caught my attention. I'm not sure they look suited to climbing, but day hiking and commuting looks like it would not be a problem.

A couple responses:

– I have a Cilogear 60L and like it for winter and high volume climbing loads, but I wouldn't describe the pack as bomber. It is very, very, very tough…for what it is. But I think Cilogear stuff is best thought of as durable alpine climbing packs, especially given their light weight. They aren't particularly suited to the abrasion that is inevitable in cragging and 'shwhacking.

– I've seen and tried out some Podsacs. They seem very similar to Cilogear to me, but I wasn't able to check them out in great detail. Both Cilo and Pod packs tend to be brightly colored too, which is a bummer.

– I've had my eye on a Kestrel for a while. The Osprey Aether fits me like glove, so I have high hopes for this pack. I'll try it on when my local shop gets it in stock.

– I use Granite Gear stuff for most of my backpacking. The long torso sizes of the vapor suspension and (in the older models at least) drab colors are great. They carry weight pretty well too. But you can't climb with them and they aren't nearly durable enough for cragging or Adirondacks 'shwacking. The suspensions isn't very good for carrying a heavy rack either. So, despite the great fit, I passed on Granite Gear daypacks. (I had the Vapor Day previously…fit perfectly, but the frame collapsed under the weight of a rack and climbing gear, so I sold it.)

– Grivel I'd have to order from overseas without trying on first…

As you can tell, I'm really fussy about packs. More so than most other gear. But I have scoliosis and get muscle spasms when I use packs that don't fit right. I routinely wish that I were a couple inches shorter – finding a pack would be much easier.

As it is, I don't know that I'll be able to find one pack that does it all. I might go with the MR or Kestrel for hiking, commuting, and summer cragging and then get a Cold Cold World pack for bigger/heavier climbing loads. I hate having too much gear, but don't see much to be done about it here…

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 2:54 pm

I'm pretty fussy about packs, too. My latest daypack is the Kestrel 32 in the m/l size. It fits my long torso very well. I like the panel loading feature, since for day use I need to get in and get gear all day long. It has enough suspension to carry my camera gear, and the side compression straps will hold my tripod. Nice little pack.

Jeff Jeff BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 3:31 pm

I can't tell you what to get, but I can say that both of my Ospreys have been crap. Broke the frame on both of them and tore up the fabric on the first one. Comfy though….

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 4:36 pm

I had a similar dilemma earlier this year!

So the biggest recommendation I have:

Cold Cold World Ozone

PackOzone frontOzone back

I have used it to carry my gear:

-Cragging
-Mini Haul bag for wall usage (Survives granite offwidths and chimneys quite well)
-Summer alpine usage

The pack rides high, and uses a webbing belt which is great in conjunction with a harness.

The pack is TOUGH, made out of 1000 Cordura, it's not the lightest thing in the world (light enough 2lbs), but for a rock climbing pack it is absolutely bombproof.

It has enough space to carry a rope and a full sized trad rack (2300 c.i). The top lid is sized perfectly for a guide book(s), plus it has a 3 point harness for hauling.

The best part, Randy the owner of Cold Cold World can customize the pack any way you want it to. I asked for a removable lid, tie out points for a bungie system, and a storm collar.

It's absolutely a gem, and fantastic pack.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 4:56 pm

Why the Kestrel over the more climbing oriented and more bombproof new Mutant?

Dave . BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 5:28 pm

David – I've never seen the Mutant. No shops around here carry it yet. That said, it's an alpine pack. And if I were to buy a 40L alpine pack, I'd take a Cilogear over an Osprey any day. There's just no contest.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 6:25 pm

I have one. It is a killer winter/mountaineering/climbing pack. I plan to write a review of it once I can get enough use/data but it is a sweet pack. (Probably next spring.)

I like Osprey anyway, probably my favorite brand the past three years or so. But I think the Kestrel series would be too delicate for what you want. The Variant series would be better if you are hesitant about the Mutant. They have haul loops and materials made to resist abrasion.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 6:40 pm

Funny, I have read some not so flattering things about Cliogear.

Ray – look forward to the review!

The Mutant was developed in Europe by Mountaineers and yes David, it is an Alpine pack, but you are looking for 'Bomber' and generally speaking, alpine packs have very robust materials by necessity. The compression on the pack looks exceptional. Maybe Ray can comment.

In any event – have fun shopping. I know I always do.

Dave . BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 6:59 pm

David – I had an absolutely terrible time dealing with Cilogear (during their move to Portland), but the pack itself is great.

Alpine/Cragging – I don't know… For me, the ice axe/crampons stuff is overkill for cragging. I've found that alpine packs are sometimes not all that durable. Ice and snow don't have the same abrasive potential as rock and, too often, alpine packs trade weight for durability. This makes sense for alpine applications, but I just want something that is bulletproof and that I don't need to protect at all.

Shopping – It's funny. I *hate* shopping. I hate thinking about gear. I just want something that works. And I don't want to own more crap than absolutely necessary. ;)

Ray – I can't wait that long, man. Can you give me a feel for what you think so far. How do you use the mutant?

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 7:16 pm

I want a pack for a similar purpose, and I think the Snugpak Sleekaforce 35 is almost ideal. I don’t know what size torso it will fit, but I’d imagine it is well balanced if packed well. It’s subdued tan or olive, with an integrated British DPM rain cover. And your final criteria of 30-35 liters–it’s right at the top of the range. It isn’t terribly expensive if you look around. Another nice benefit is that it doesn’t have the MOLLE attachments which screams modern military. This hints more of a vintage partisan…

Snugpak Sleekaforce 35

I know a few Gents that have and like the Maxpedition packs as well:

Maxpedition Gearslinger

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 7:48 pm

Most of the Podsaca i've seen are black, not brightly coloured. Have a look on the link i posted. They are made from a mixture of Dyneema and Cordurs, so should be pretty durable. I know a few guys who regularly haul them up and down rock faces, and they describe them as almost indestructable.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 8:10 pm

David(s),

I had started to post about Cilo then discarded it. Now I will go ahead. My climber ex-wife tested the Cilo B, she said it was the most uncomfortable pack she has ever carried. I was not impressed with it one bit, and I love trick stuff. The foam is rock hard. On one trip that she insisted on carrying the lion’s share to truly test it (I carried lunch and my rack) she had bruises from the straps and the lower lumbar/back pad. She stopped part way to have me feel at the back to see what was pressing so hard, she was sure it was a fold of material or something she had introduced. Nope. She sold it as soon as the test was over and went back to her Lowe climbing pack. She really wants a Variant right now.

The climbing packs are made to be pulled up rock faces. This means that they need to be very durable. And snow and ice can be extremely abrasive. I have seen people with major road rash from a short slide when wearing only a t-shirt. Depending on the temps and humidity level snow can be like sand.

I got the Mutant just after the season to use it, and with the split I am not doing the rock climbing any longer. (It was Jenn’s thing, I learned it for her.) But I will use it for my normal winter stuff and mountaineering, which I plan to do more of again. So I can’t tell you a lot except that it is very light for a mountaineering specific pack. As that is the focus it does not have any of the mesh backs of all the 3-season packs from them. (Thank goodness. Those are nice when it is hot. They are snow collectors in winter.)

One thing that should be known up front, the Mutant is more of a minimalist pack than the Variant series. I am in MN right now and the pack is in CA, and I don’t have any pics in my Futures folder yet for you.

I actually had to get mine from Europe as I tried to get it last winter once I read about it after getting clued in by a friend. But by the time I got it the season was past. So it may be interesting to see if there are any changes in the US version. (It is funny, the manual has all these funky measurements and weights… ;-)

Dave . BPL Member
PostedOct 16, 2009 at 8:11 am

Good points all around. I'd probably do best to keep an open mind here…

I'll check out the Podsacs again next time I'm in New Paltz and I'll see about checking out a Mutant.

I guess Snugpack goes on the list too.

Also, Nat, thanks for posting about the Cold Cold World pack. I had not realized they were so customizable.

Ray, for what it's worth, I've found my CiloGear pack pretyy comfortable. I don't expect it to be as comfy as a Vapor Trail, but it hasn't bruised me yet either!

PostedOct 16, 2009 at 3:58 pm

I've been using the old AK30 for the last 3 years for rock, ice and alpine routes. It is an amazing pack. 700g, simple yet very durable fabric. They use a kevlar weave. Their new AK30 will be waterproof for just a little weight penality. To me, it is worth the pita to get it shiped to North America.

Aslo, CiloGear makles some packs with Dyneema (Spetcra ish fabric). They are pricy but if light and durable is what you need…
Cheers
Pierre

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
Loading...