Very helpful so far. Thanks for the responses.
Mystery Ranch has definitely caught my attention. I'm not sure they look suited to climbing, but day hiking and commuting looks like it would not be a problem.
A couple responses:
– I have a Cilogear 60L and like it for winter and high volume climbing loads, but I wouldn't describe the pack as bomber. It is very, very, very tough…for what it is. But I think Cilogear stuff is best thought of as durable alpine climbing packs, especially given their light weight. They aren't particularly suited to the abrasion that is inevitable in cragging and 'shwhacking.
– I've seen and tried out some Podsacs. They seem very similar to Cilogear to me, but I wasn't able to check them out in great detail. Both Cilo and Pod packs tend to be brightly colored too, which is a bummer.
– I've had my eye on a Kestrel for a while. The Osprey Aether fits me like glove, so I have high hopes for this pack. I'll try it on when my local shop gets it in stock.
– I use Granite Gear stuff for most of my backpacking. The long torso sizes of the vapor suspension and (in the older models at least) drab colors are great. They carry weight pretty well too. But you can't climb with them and they aren't nearly durable enough for cragging or Adirondacks 'shwacking. The suspensions isn't very good for carrying a heavy rack either. So, despite the great fit, I passed on Granite Gear daypacks. (I had the Vapor Day previously…fit perfectly, but the frame collapsed under the weight of a rack and climbing gear, so I sold it.)
– Grivel I'd have to order from overseas without trying on first…
As you can tell, I'm really fussy about packs. More so than most other gear. But I have scoliosis and get muscle spasms when I use packs that don't fit right. I routinely wish that I were a couple inches shorter – finding a pack would be much easier.
As it is, I don't know that I'll be able to find one pack that does it all. I might go with the MR or Kestrel for hiking, commuting, and summer cragging and then get a Cold Cold World pack for bigger/heavier climbing loads. I hate having too much gear, but don't see much to be done about it here…