Topic

Lost again

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
Troy Ammons BPL Member
PostedOct 14, 2009 at 7:42 am

Mostly thinking outloud.

I just returned a MB #1 spiral due to underfill in the chest area and I dont care for the short zip. Only went to my knees.

So I have been rethinking my entire sleeping bag setup again.

I really want a layered setup, IE a down quilt inside a synthetic sleeping bag

or a synthetic overquilt over a down bag. I think this would be more comfortable and lighter.

Synthetic on the outside to better deal with frozen condensation on the outer layer.

What ever it is I really like the MB SS bags.

I want a 0dF combined rating.

I am tall and take a long and want the entire weight for both at or under 3#.

I can exchange for a golite ultra 20 quilt or any MB bag.

If I go ultra 20 inside a MB #5 sythetic, that would put me at about 3.6# which is too heavy, but the golite ultra 20 looks like a nice quilt.

The other option would be a montbell #1, #2 or #3 with a MYOG climasheild overquilt.

A SS #1 with a 2.5oz XP overquilt would take me to 0dF and weigh about 3.3# which is still more than I would like.

2.5xp would make a nice summer quilt though.

If I could live with a short zip, I could go with a MB #3 30dF spiral and a 3.7 oz XP overquilt. That would weigh about 2# 2oz but not sure if a 3.7 oz quilt would extend it to 0dF. A 3.7 oz XP quilt is probably too hot for summer.

If I went back to a #1 spiral with a 2.5 oz quilt that would put me at 3#1oz.

Thanks for reading my babble.

Any suggetions would be appreciated.

Lori P BPL Member
PostedOct 14, 2009 at 8:14 am

… the down will compress on the inside, particularly if the synthetic bag/quilt does not have sufficient girth for you and the down quilt.

A review of the Golite Quilt: http://www.backpackgeartest.org/reviews/Sleep%20Gear/Quilts%20and%20Blankets/GoLite%20Ultra%2020/Owner%20Review%20by%20Ray%20Estrella/

I don't see how the quilt can possibly have 5" loft. My Jacks R Better has 2.5 – 3" loft, for the same weight. Also, I know from experience that the Jacks R Better quilt is warm into the mid20F temps.

Troy Ammons BPL Member
PostedOct 14, 2009 at 10:07 am

The 5" is for 2 layers. Thats a typical method of measuring bags. IE I have a -40 bag that has 10" of loft but only 6" on top.

That would mean the golite quilt is 2.5" for one layer, but from what I understand its more like 2".

That is true. An over quilt would compress a down innner bag or quilt if it is strapped, but my idea for very cold weather is to fasten the over synthetic quilt to my bivy top and not really use straps. Set up like that a 2.5XP quilt with 1oz nylon should not compress to a degree that it would make a difference.

I had thought about a montbell SS synthetic over bag with a down quilt inside, but those MB SS synth bags are heavy.

Then again I could just buy a MB #0 0dF rated and be done. I just wanted something more versitile for a AT thru.

I guess I could also do a quilt over a quilt too.

A 5 oz XP inner quilt would have a rating of about 25-30dF.
A 2.5 oz XP quilt would extend that to about 15dF and is perfect for summer. Insulated layers another 10dF, so maybe that would work.

The combined weight of those two quilts would be about 2#-2oz.

If I did a 2.5 xp quilt over a golite ultra 20 that would weigh about 2# 2oz also.

3.1" total loft if the golite is actually 2.5" and the over quilt does not compress the golite. That Should be good for roughly 5dF.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 1:36 am

MEC sells "hybrid" mummy bags which are a layer of down underneath a layer of synthetic, and only synthetic on the bottom layer (better for loft compression?), hood (condensation), and footbox (I guess for rubbing against wet tent walls).

Seems like a great idea although they use 575 duck down and probably not the lightest fabrics around. Weighs 1600g for -12C bag.
Still, could possibly be lighter than the equivalent of two separate layers because only one shell is needed for the whole setup.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 1:36 am

MEC sells "hybrid" mummy bags which are a layer of down underneath a layer of synthetic, and only synthetic on the bottom layer (better for loft compression?), hood (condensation), and footbox (I guess for rubbing against wet tent walls).

Seems like a great idea although they use 575 duck down and probably not the lightest fabrics around. Weighs 1600g for -12C bag.

Ben Smith BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 3:27 am

Western Mountaineering sells the Antelope GWS (Gore-Tex WindStopper) which is a 5 degree bag that weighs 2 lb 15 oz in the long version. I would definitely trust it to 0 degrees with a baselayer, and it is fully waterproof…

CW BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 3:40 am

The WM bags are not fully waterproof. The fabric might be but they aren't seam sealed and don't use waterproof zippers so water can get still get in.

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 8:16 am

I know it's not a layered system, but it doesn't need to be… go for an Antelope in MicroFiber, the long weighs 2# 9oz, and it's every bit a 0*F bag. For warmer weather just shift the down underneath. Yes, I've done that, and it works great. The disadvantage is that you'd never carry less than the 2.5# or less bulk. Just saying, if you want to uncomplicate things, and get a great system that weighs next to nothing for zero temps…

Troy Ammons BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 8:26 am

and the weight is not bad.

Right now I have a credit with Prolite and they dont sell WM bags.

I will have to think about it some more.

Right now I am almost ready to pull the trigger on a golite ultra 20, and build a CLimasheild over quilt for summer. I have a ton of 1oz ripstop from walmart. All I need is the insulation. The only time I would need both on the AT would be winter.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 6:38 pm

Nunatak makes their Expedition with a differential cut and cut a bit roomier than their other quilts so that it can be used over their Alpinist to take the system real low.

You could probably have them do this with one of the warmer quilts too to fit what you are looking for.

Troy Ammons BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 7:07 pm

Thanks and that would be nice but very expensive.

Reason for the golite ultra 20 is I have a credit at prolite.

I already have about 18 yards of 1 oz ripstop so the XP insul will cost between $30 and $45 depending on the weight.

When I get the golite, I am going to measure it and build the overquilt to fit.

PostedOct 15, 2009 at 8:31 pm

Keep us updated.

That is pretty cool. I wish I were handy like that. I can barely sew a button on.

You definitely are on the same track I am heading.

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedOct 15, 2009 at 10:06 pm

Why not just add some down to the Ultra 20? I did that to some Luxurylite bags I had, wasn't very hard. I haven't tried to take my Ultra 20 apart though.

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
Loading...