I'm 5'9" 185 pounds and find the 59 inch girth bags too confining. I've used a WM Hooded Aspen (now known as the Sycamore MF) for ten years on the PCT. It is a 62 inch shoulder girth semi-rectangular bag rated to 25°, and I've had it well into the 'teens with no problems.
Plenty of room for this side-sleeping, constantly-rolling hiker. I've never been cold, with or without a 140 weight base layer. I always wear a wool cap, which allows me to leave the hood off most of the time, making rolling over easier. The microfiber shell really cuts off the wind, meaning less convective heat loss, hence I rarely need the base layers; they're mostly for keeping the liner cleaner during long hikes.
Generally speaking, the colder the temperature rating on a bag, the greater the girth, to allow room for additional layers without compressing the insulation on same. I can wear my Patagonia Micropuff pullover or parka in my bag without it feeling compressed. It has never been cold enough for me to need that much insulating power (yet).