Topic

WM Tamarak Vs. MB Thermal Sheet

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Matt B BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 8:43 am

I posted this in the winter hike forum and i think it is better suited here.

I purchased this summer a WM Megalite for use as a 2-3 season bag. Now of course as the cold weather sets in i am interested in doing some colder weather backpacking.
Has anyone used the WM Megalite bag or similar and added a 30-50 degree inner bag?
I am looking to go in late November early December in the white mountains in NH.
I would love to just go get a WM Puma at -25 but the cost is steep and its versatility is limited.
The cost of the Tamarak and Thermal Sheet are both $200 or less.
Also would adding a lightweight water proof sleeping bag cover increase temperature rating?
The sleeping bag cover seems like a good idea anyway for that time of year in the white mountains.

WM Megalite 30' – 25oz
WM Tamarak 30' – 15oz
Montbell thermal sheet 50' – 13.4oz
Montbell Sleeping bag cover – 8.3oz

I would appreciate any help or suggestions.

Thanks,

Matt.

Matt B BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 9:03 am

I should also add that i will be in a tent so not too exposed to the harsher weather.

PostedOct 10, 2009 at 9:26 am

Hi Matt.
Sizing may be an issue with the MB. I'm 5'10" and it is slightly too short for me when zipped up. I use it unzipped as a warm weather quilt so this isn't an issue for me.
It is something to consider for your set-up maybe?

Bruce Tolley BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 9:40 am

Does your 30 degree bag have a baffle along the zipper and a draft collar around your shoulders? These features become important when the temperature inside your tent drops into the teens.

Wearing synthetic insulation like Integral Designs PLQ jacket and pants or the BPL tops and bottoms might give you more flexibility if there is enough room inside the bag to avoid compressing the insulation.

I would avoid a waterproof top on your bivvy. I have tried bivies with Conduit and Goretex tops in the Sierras and they just seems to collect and condense water vapor especially on a multi-night trip. If you already own the MB, try it out. Preferably, you might look at a bivy with a highly breathable DWR top layer like what Mountain Laurel Designs, OWare, and BPL sell.

Matt B BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 9:46 am

Hi Mike,
I was thinking with the Montbell Thermal sheet at 5'10 inside my WM megalite 6'6, i am 5'11 so maybe with a lightweight down jacket too it gives me more flexibilty with a range of temperatures.
The down jacket i have is super light and would have with me anyway. (North Face Mt. Fuji Down jacket)

Matt.

Matt B BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 9:55 am

Bruce,
Yes it does have the baffle and draft collar.
But I havent used it in anything near the 30 degree rating yet.
Also I havent purchased the MB or the Tamarak yet. Getting my pack/ base weight down in weight this summer has cost a little more than i would have liked.
The lightweight bivvy seams to have a lot of mixed results from people. The moisture control being the hot topic.

Bruce Tolley BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 11:12 am

If saving $ and re-use of your existing kit are the number 1 goals, you could:

Try out your warmest kit in your back yard on the coldest night the end of November or the first week of December. If you are not warm enough
1) go to REI and rent a winter bag
or
2) go to REI and buy a winter bag with one of the 20% off coupons. The zero degree Marmot and Mountain Hardware bags are quite fine as winter bags. If you do not like the bag,return it after your outing.
or
3) Buy a silk liner and borrow a winter bag from a buddy

Boozer BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 11:19 am

Are you thinking of the Tamarak as a inner bag with the Megalite or as a top quilt drapped over it? What temp are you planning on getting down to with this combo? I happen to have all 3 of the bags you mention. (6' Mega, Tamarak & the older style MB Thermal Sheet)

BTW the Megalite has a top collar. This is not a full draft collar. There is a big difference between the two when the temp drops.

Matt B BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 12:05 pm

Yes i was thinking of using the Tamarak as an inner bag with the Megalite, or the MB Thermal sheet inside the Megalite.
The temperature range i hope to be comfortable in is between 5 and 25 degrees Fahrenheit.
Have you used this setup for colder seasons?
If it works then the purchase of the inner bag can be justified as an extra summer quilt/ bag for backup or for my wife to use.

I hadn't really considered the Rent/ borrow a winter bag idea, its not my favorite idea. I hate borrowing stuff. And renting a sleeping bag sounds as appealing as renting underwear for the trip.
I am browsing the web to see if there are any great deals on cold weather bags. I missed EMS's sale last week 20% off Everything including WM bags.

But the inner bag idea is where i am leaning, i think the tamarak with its 30 degree rating could be the way to go. And it weighs only 19 ounces.

Boozer BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 1:10 pm

The Tamarak is just too lofty to be an inner for the Megalite in my opinion (I just did it). You are going to compress the down far too much. Not to mention you have 18+ inches of bag without a liner requiring a jacket that would also overlap with the Tamarak.

The MB Thermal sheet is going to be a much better fit. As said I have the older black and purple model.

Matt B BPL Member
PostedOct 10, 2009 at 1:28 pm

Ok i think thats the way i will go..
Plus its a little cheaper than the tamarak.
worst case scenario if i doesnt work out i will have a great back up quilt for very warm nights in summer.

What temperature were you using the tamarak/ megalite in?

Thanks for your input.

Matt B BPL Member
PostedOct 12, 2009 at 3:52 pm

Well thanks for all the help but…..
i caved under the pressure of too many possibilities of it not working out and i found a "brand New" 2006 WM Puma SDL on sale at Bentgate.com
Gives me a little insurance against mother nature. And will give me an opportunity to try out some of the more colder months we will surely get.

On a side note: They still have 2 Bags left. (as of 10/12/09)

Matt.

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...