Alas, the NeoAir did not work out for me, so I continue looking for a cushier mattress. So far I've held the line to one pound, but in the interest of comfort, I'm now willing to add half a pound. So for those of your who have used both, which of these will keep your warmer? At what point do you need to add a thinlite? I'm interested only in the 72" versions of either.
Topic
Ether Thermo 6 vs. Insulated Air Core
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
My family has the previous version of the ether and the ba insulated air core. The thermo seemed slightly warmer… but also lumpier (6 rather than 8 tubes). I prefer the BA, my daughter prefers the Thermo. I would recommend both. Thermo might be a bit more durable. I have holed the BA but not the thermo. Then again, the BA has been on a significantly larger number of trips holding up more weight.
–mark
I was fine on my Max Thermo, and my son was fine on his Ether Thermo 6 at 23 degrees. The ground was not frozen, and it was still getting into the 50s during the day, which probably effected the performance. I really like the POE products, no leaks in 4 years. Haven't used the BA.
I emailed the guys at POE a few years back regarding the warmth of the ether to the BA. they said theirs was warmer due to the baffle construction restricting air movement more effectively than the BA.
I use the BA mummy shaped, 21 oz. I would need more insulation around 30* using a topbag or quilt.
If you are looking to go really cold, you may consider a DAM. Stephenson Warmlite makes a really light DAM at either 19 or 23oz for the 2 middle sizes and would be warmer than either BA or POE.
http://www.warmlite.com/bags.htm
I have the BA insul mat and I will second the 30 degree mark. Fine until then, much below that, heat sucking sounds require a closed cell of some type for me.
Based on your comments and a customer review I found at REI.com, it seems that the Ether Thermo has a bit of an edge in thermal performance. I managed to buy one online from REI before they sold out. But Mark's comment about the greater comfort of eight chambers vs. six is also a consideration. The Ether Thermo should arrive before the current REI sale is over, though. So if the Ether Thermo proves to be not comfortable enough, I'll still have time to switch for a Insulated Air Core. Thanks to all who responded.
Become a member to post in the forums.

