Topic

Spinnshelter Questions

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
PostedOct 8, 2009 at 3:02 pm

After seeing the SpinnShelter talked about here, (including the BPL review)I went to Gossamergear's website and read up on it. I also watched the youtube videos that showed it being pitched.

My concern is that the front and rear doors are held shut by velcro strips. In use, is the velcro up to the task of keeping the doors closed? I'm concerned that a good gust would cause it to fail.

Also, everyone talks about the low weight of this shelter, but nobody has mentioned how small it packs up. I'm a big fan of keeping essential gear on my person, so I'd like to know if the SpinnShelter would fit into a cargo pocket.

Finally, does Gossamer Gear offer any custom work?

Thanks.

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedOct 8, 2009 at 3:23 pm

I have the older white version not the newer gray version in the video with the new foot end. Now most of my camping is done in the east and in wooded areas so I haven’t tested it in super high winds, but the Velcro seems plenty strong to keep the door shut. I can’t imagine a situation where you would be using a 10oz shelter that you would face a wind strong enough to blow it open. In Mark Verber’s review of the shelter I know he had it in measured 35 mph winds and it held up fine. I was on the AT in north Georgia when we had 7 inches of rain in 48 hours and there was no misting from the canopy, the SpinnShelter did great.

The stuff sack that they send with it is rather large, which I like because I am always trying to fill up space in the summer and it can still be compressed more in the winter when I am trying to cram more gear into my pack. The stuff sack is a 8×11 envelope style stuff sack but I think you could easily compress it enough to fit in a cargo pocket of my REI Sierra Convertible Pants.

Gossamer Gear subcontracts the sewing of their gear to a company in Seattle so I don’t think they do custom work. They do however have great customer service and make great products. I have a SpinnShelter and Mariposia Plus from them and have emailed Grant several times and have always gotten a helpful, knowledgeable and quick response. If you want a custom solution the MLD Patrol Shelter is somewhat similar and they will do custom work, Alpinlight will do custom work from time to time, and they have a new tarp coming out that is somewhat similar, and of course Tim Marshall on this forum does custom work of all types.

PostedOct 8, 2009 at 4:50 pm

I've been using my SpinnShelter since the first white iteration, for the past five years. Even now it is the shelter I most often turn to for my alpine walks, where wind is a big concern. It is more versatile than my The One, lighter, allows me to use one trekking pole rather than two (I use a cut down tent pole for the rear, fixed at just the right height), and if tightly folded up, can fit into a cargo pocket. I like that it doesn't stretch in the rain and can battened down when the wind really blows. The headroom is too low in storm mode, but most of the time I pitch it with the doors rolled back, like a regular catenary tarp, and pitch it high, so I get the headroom I need and lots of air flow. Other people complain about the weakness of the spinnaker cloth, but I've not had any problems so far. I also don't find the material that noisy when pitched taut, especially in the rain when the moisture dampens any tendency for the material to crackle. The shelter is VERY long, so anyone worried about finding shelters for very tall people, this is one to seriously consider. Sometimes I find it much too long for me, but at the same time this length allows me to burrow back from the entrance and feel more protected from storms. I hear the new grey spinnaker cloth is much stronger than the one I have, so you can even more confidence with it.

THe velcro doors have been no problem in winds at all. Remember that the ends of the door flaps are also staked down so in winds the stress is on the cloth and stakes rather than the velcro. The velcro merely keep the edges of the doors secure.

One of my favorite shelters, and that over a long span of use alongside other shelters, and it still ranks at the top.

PostedOct 8, 2009 at 5:08 pm

"One of my favorite shelters, and that over a long span of use alongside other shelters, and it still ranks at the top."

Better than the Akto? Muhhahhahhahhah

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedOct 8, 2009 at 7:09 pm

+1 all of Miguel comments. In strong winds I loop both sides of the front/back doors over the stake so the velco is just helping to keeping the sides together. Yes, it could fit in a big cargo pocket. I measured winds 35mph winds on the trip that the snapshot of the spinnshelter was taken. I have measure 50mph on a different trip.

The reason I switched from the spinnshelter to the one is that with the mild california weather I wanted a bit more space that was bugfree.

–mark

PostedOct 9, 2009 at 8:45 am

Thanks for all of the input, guys.

Brad, you said “I can’t imagine a situation where you would be using a 10oz shelter that you would face a wind strong enough to blow it open.” My intention here is to be able to carry this as an emergency shelter for day hikes when I might be “caught out” or times when I choose an impromptu overnight bivy, rather than hiking back to my established camp.

Do any of you have any pictures of the SpinnShelter folded up, maybe next to something else for size comparison?

Another question – Are there exterior attachment points for suspending the shelter from a tree or improvised bipod?

Modifications: I was thinking of adding Velcro around the bottom to attach about a foot of mesh, as well as mesh triangles for the ends. That way, I could have bug protection without having to carry a whole bug tent. What do you think?

Thanks again.

Rog Tallbloke BPL Member
PostedOct 9, 2009 at 9:09 am

Glad to hear Brad is getting good use out of the spinnshelter. I can confirm it is long enough for very tall hikers too.

There are external brass eyelets on webbing tapes for rigging the tent. I pitched it using two carbon fibre golf club shafts at the front as an A frame, jointed with a plastic 'elbow'. That worked fine too, and gave better access.

It's low, so sheds the wind well.

I think velcro all the way round the bottom would be heavy, probably better just to stich the nanoseeum on permanently and just roll it up and tape it out of the way out of bug season. My other idea was to get a continuous roll of ziploc type seal and glue it to mesh and tent edge. Maybe a bit fiddly though.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedOct 9, 2009 at 3:27 pm

> adding Velcro around the bottom to attach about a foot of mesh

I would bet this would add 6oz or more… nearly doubling the weight of the spinnshelter. If you are doing to do the netting save a bit of weight and ship the velco… especially since velco's hooks have a tendency to do bad things to nano mesh. Go with a bug bivy or have bug resistant clothing and a headnet.

–Mark

PostedOct 9, 2009 at 6:37 pm

Better than the Akto? Muhhahhahhahhah

Oh man, do you have to bring up my Alps trip dilemma again! (@J@)

Actually I've hardly used the Akto for the past three years. After the shelters I've been mostly using (the SpinnShelter, the One, and the Terra Nova Laser Competition) it just seems way too heavy and bulky. I'm now considering the Duomid and I have a feeling that, for once, I will have found the shelter that I will stay with with that. Just like the SpinnShelter is the one I always return to these days, the Duomid is just as simple, but has the room and orientation that I prefer in the One and the Laser Comp.

In winter in the snow in the higher mountains I will most likely use the Akto, though.

PostedOct 9, 2009 at 7:23 pm

I feel the same way although will say that out of all the shelters I have ever used, the Akto is the only one that I KNOW will not fail out 'there.'

But then I come back to the weight and space per lb and then get enticed by the Duomid.

I would like to see Hilleberg come out with a single person version of the Rajd but with venilated ends (like the Akto) with a mesh backing and a fully mesh backed door.

Dare to dream.

PostedOct 9, 2009 at 9:13 pm

I own the Spinn twin and it is excelent. However if you want something for emergencies just bring an emergency bivy such as one sold by bpl. I have used a emergency blanket after my down bag got wet, the conditions were frezing about 30 degrees and I was warm. So use a emergency bivy it will keep you alive even though you will be soaked wiht sweat in the morning.

Go wiht the emergency bivy.

PostedOct 10, 2009 at 1:18 am

The shelter already has velcro on the ends, so I'm only talking about adding it along the sides. There wouldn't have to be much to hold the mesh in place, maybe just a quarter inch width. This still may end up being too heavy, but I can't see it being as heavy as carrying a seperate bug tent or permenantly sewing the mesh to the shelter. Alternately, maybe velcro "dots" could be attached every foot or so as long as the attachment was taught enough to keep the critters out.

Timothy, I currently carry an AMK Emergency Bivvy, coupled with a SilTarp. I prefer the Emergency Bivvy to AMK's more expensive ThermoLite. I spent one night in the Thermolite in the mid-twenties and was miserable!

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Loading...