It is all one to me which tent you choose, but, I would be guided by comments from those who have actually USED the tents/gear in question, rather than remarks from those who have …read… about certain aspects of said gear.
I have found Toddtex to work fairly well in quite wet conditions and so does Tegraltex, however, my experience with eVENT has led me to use it anytime I can, in preference to any other fabric of it's type. It is SO good in even severe B.C. coastal rain, that I was just amazed when I first saw my buddie's jacket, compared to my highend GT parka.
My local gear shop called me a month ago to offer me the first I.D. Wedge they had received to test and then buy, if I liked it. I declined as I have all the tentage/shelters I need and do not want another costly one I really will seldom use. I prefer the "Mega Sola" design to the "Wedge", which seems to require the optional vestibule in serious rain and thus the weight is the same…I asked Evan to make the MS in eVENT about 3 years ago, but, he refused and so my "ideal" shelter is not available.
The "Wedge" would be a good snow-wind rig, but, I consider either the BD-I-Tent or I.D. MKI-XL far superior for any major camping trips as the tiny shelters get pretty claustrophobic in short order. Each to his own, try to test them all.