Topic

Black Diamond I-tent or Integral Designs M1 XL

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
PostedOct 6, 2009 at 8:56 pm

I'm in the market for an alpine winter tent. I plan to use it for big wall, light mountaineering, to snowshoeing trips.

Any experiences with Black Diamonds I-tent, or ID M1XL?

Not too concerned about space, my sf and I are both about 5'8 120-135 lbs

-condensation issues?
-prolonged slush rainy situations?
-Durability?
-Ease of repair?
-Ease of use?
-Weight (We're willing to compromise for durability)
-High winds?
-user feed back?

thanx!

PostedOct 7, 2009 at 5:00 am

I had a Bibler Solo Dome, made by Todd Bibler and used it largely in the Canadian Rockies and the Chilcotin area of B.C. I have an I.D.-MKI-XL and an I.D. Mega Sola plus three I.D. bivies; I bought the Bibler first and then switched to I.D. for my singlewall tents.

Bibler-BD are good, I.D. is better and that is my experience-based opinion.

PostedOct 7, 2009 at 6:02 am

I've used them both. They're nearly identical. The ID can be a customized a little more, which is a definite advantage…but customization does increase the cost.

When I tried them, I was looking for a mountaineering and winter expedition tent. No big wall work for me. I decided that (for me) neither were worth the cost for a shelter w/o an integrated vestibule…but if that's not an issue for you, then I imagine you'd be perfectly happy with either of these.

-condensation: same (typical, not great)
-prolonged rain: same (not very good)
-High winds: same (good)
-Ease of repair: same
-Ease of use: same
-Weight: same
-Durability: don't know

Carter Young BPL Member
PostedOct 7, 2009 at 10:48 am

First the tents you mention are quite small. They'll fit two people, but I'm 6'0" and have to sleep diagonally in my I-Tent.

I have lots of Bibler tents and one ID (a MKIII), and I prefer the Biblers because their doors open to side rather than down as on IDs. I also find the quick clip pole attachments of the Biblers easier to use than the Velcro on IDs.

I could tell you a lot more, but both brands are well worth the money.

Also, take a look at the Nemo Tenshi. I had an early version in eVent and it was great until the seam tape gave way. I now have the larger Moki, and it is a very well designed large alpine tent.

And if you can, avoid Bibler or ID tents that have the flame-retardant treatment: they're heavier and don't breathe nearly as well as non-treated versions.

PostedOct 7, 2009 at 1:03 pm

Thanx for all the replies

Unfortunately in CA, all tents require FR, but good to know that it reduces breathability

What are your experiences with eVent vs Todd-tex in slushy weather? (I have an ID salathe bivy, but no experience with eVent).

Another contender has also surfaced which makes the decision even harder: Rab Summit Superlite Bivy, made of eVent!

PostedOct 8, 2009 at 7:34 am

>>Unfortunately in CA, all tents require FR, but good to know that it reduces breathability<<

– You could have your order shipped to a friend in another state, and then forwarded to you. Personally, I'd do whatever I could to avoid the FR coating. From what I've read, it pretty much negates all the breathability that you're paying for with these expensive fabrics.

>>What are your experiences with eVent vs Todd-tex in slushy weather?<<

– I've never used an eVent shelter in slushy precip, so I can't really comment…but I'd imagine it would be just as effective as it is with rain?

PostedOct 8, 2009 at 8:06 am

…and another entry. An new ID eVENT shelter called the Wedge, due out mid-Oct. Cross pole design similar to the RAB.

PostedOct 8, 2009 at 8:23 am

It is all one to me which tent you choose, but, I would be guided by comments from those who have actually USED the tents/gear in question, rather than remarks from those who have …read… about certain aspects of said gear.

I have found Toddtex to work fairly well in quite wet conditions and so does Tegraltex, however, my experience with eVENT has led me to use it anytime I can, in preference to any other fabric of it's type. It is SO good in even severe B.C. coastal rain, that I was just amazed when I first saw my buddie's jacket, compared to my highend GT parka.

My local gear shop called me a month ago to offer me the first I.D. Wedge they had received to test and then buy, if I liked it. I declined as I have all the tentage/shelters I need and do not want another costly one I really will seldom use. I prefer the "Mega Sola" design to the "Wedge", which seems to require the optional vestibule in serious rain and thus the weight is the same…I asked Evan to make the MS in eVENT about 3 years ago, but, he refused and so my "ideal" shelter is not available.

The "Wedge" would be a good snow-wind rig, but, I consider either the BD-I-Tent or I.D. MKI-XL far superior for any major camping trips as the tiny shelters get pretty claustrophobic in short order. Each to his own, try to test them all.

PostedOct 8, 2009 at 8:42 am

Has there been any data on the Wedge? Photos/pecs/data/etc?

Also, ID MK1 XL owner here. I use it in MN for winters, but have yet to have a really huge storm with it (I did get 12-16 inches of snow overnight once.) Snow slid off nicely. Also, the fabric is fantastic.

If I were going to get a temp for dryer conditions, I would go with a BD Firstlight. I really like the wedge design with the door on the short side.

PostedOct 8, 2009 at 9:58 am

The only info I have on the Wedge is that it uses a cross pole design, has two upper vents, mesh door, fits 2 people (essentially the same footprint as the MK1XL), and will weigh just under 3 pounds. However, it will have a low height.

Charlie (VigilGuy) may be able to shed further light on the supject. There is a pic here:

Scroll way down this page: http://www.trailspace.com/blog/?page=2

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
Loading...