Topic

Quick input on NEOAIR . . .Big Guy Perspective

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
PostedOct 6, 2009 at 12:44 pm

Hi All,

I'll start by saying that I'm a Big Guy (getting smaller.) I am 5' 10" and way about 275lbs. My chest measures about 52". I have been trying to find the perfect sleeping setup for some time. My prior experience has mainly been car/base camping and I have tried various combinations of folded comforters, full size air mattresses, self inflating Thermarest Basecamp etc. The results varied from "that wasn’t terrible" to "That really sucked."

I have been eyeballing the NEOAIR, shied away due to concerns of durability, width and the fact that the mattress will have a small Buffalo slumbering all over it.(me)

This last week, i called Cascade Designs and spoke to one of their customer service people. I was told that there wasn’t a stated weight limit and that as long as I didn’t jump on it like a trampoline, it would work just fine for my weight and much higher.

My next trip to the store, I pulled the trigger on a NEOAIR in regular size. I was completely amazed at the size and weight, but again felt some despair at the "light weight" appearance.

Flash-forward . . . returning from my two night camp outing at Edgar Evins State Park . . . what a piece of kit. I slept with the NEOAIR on the bare tent floor (the whole tent was on a 25 x 30 wooden deck which overlooked the lake.) I was inside my bag and snuggled up warm because the temps got down to 45 degrees. All worries about "falling off the sides" evaporated as I woke the following morning with no problems at all. I stayed plenty warm, no inflation problems and best of all I was well rested. The NEOAIR was neither too warm nor too cold. It felt neither too hard nor too soft . . .

Quite honestly, I awoke from my sleep and a huge smile crept onto my face as I realized that it may have taken 5-6 years, a lot of effort, wasted money and finally an expensive purchase, but I finally have my perfect sleeping mat.

Thanks NEOAIR . . .

ps. didn’t have any issues with it being noisy or crinkly.

PostedOct 6, 2009 at 12:51 pm

I'm 6'6" and 280 and wear a 52XXL jacket.

My height may not be a fair comparision for you, but here's the info anyway.

I purchased several different lengths of the NeoAir and ultimately hated my torso and legs falling off it as it put a lot of pressure on my back. The NeoAir is very thick, so that's something worth considering depending on your sleeping style and personal perspective.

Ultimately I got the longest version which was nice because it had extra width and the length didn't bother my back. It was comfortable enough, but then I started to ask myself what I was really gaining with it. I usually use either a 5 or 7 oz CCF pad which had very similar r-values. My CCF pad was about $25 (versus $200), much lighter (versus 19 oz), and it could never pop. Although the CCF pad does not pack as small, it wins in every other category. If it gets cold, I'd just add another CCF pad which would push the r-value to around 5…all for only around 10 ounces and $50. With that, I returned the NeoAir and haven't looked back. If I were car camping, I may have hung onto the NeoAir, but otherwise for backpacking, I'll stick with the CCF pad.

PostedOct 6, 2009 at 1:05 pm

Good info . . .
I'll say that I also have a z-lite. The pad is light, doesnt fold as small and although it might provide thermal protection, it just wasn't near as comfortable for me. I plan on using the NEOAIR for car camping and UL camping trips as well. I found that by manipulating the volume of air in the pad, I could get a sleep comfort value close to that of my pillow-top mattress at home but folded into a super small package that weighs roughly 14.5 oz with the stuff sack. I guess the thought here is mileage may vary . . . :)

PostedOct 6, 2009 at 3:16 pm

It wins in weight and price… but loses in comfort and pack size… a fair trade i would say. but if you can sleep on a CCF mat and wake up feeling good then, i agree, don't bother getting a neoair. unfortunately a good percentage of us don't fit into that group, and thus have purchased, and mostly been happy with, our neoairs

PostedOct 6, 2009 at 6:46 pm

I have read many opinions about this item . . . almost all agree that it's expensive. I real factors are does it work for you and is it worth the cost? For me, it has replaced comforters, thermarest basecamp, z-lite and no pad at all. It is honestly the first time I have slept (while camping) and not woken up with aches pains etc. I do agree with some other opinions . . . this is one of the best pieces of gear that I have purchased in the last 5 years. Is it worth the big money? Well . . . what kind of price do you put on a great night's sleep? For me . . .worth every penny.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
Loading...