I used to camp quite often 5-6 years ago and I am now getting more time to get back out there. So I need to a new 2 person tent (have a wife now too). So I'm looking at the MSR Hubba Hubba, BA Seedhouse SL2, Montbell Thunderdome 2, and Sierra Designs Lightning 2.
Topic
Tents, MSR, BA, Sierra Designs, Montbell
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Things have changed in the last 5-6 years. Do I go light weight with BA and sacrifice some structure and size, or go with the Lightning or Montbell, I have to be honest the MSR is not be considered too seriously. I have considered a tarp tent but living in Canada makes it difficult to get a variety of products….
Although not on your list one of the most popular lightweight 2 person tents on this site is the tarptent double rainbow – 2.5#
I have considered the DR, I am not terribly familiar with the tent, can anyone comment on its ability to withstand wind/rain, I am not camping on mountains or anything but it can get windy or rainy anywhere. Is it freestanding? And is condensation something to worry about?
I have a Sierra Designs Lightning 2, and still really like the tent alot. It's a palace for one, and sufficiently spacious for two. It goes up and down fast. It's not light enough for many people on this forum, but is still reasonably light, especially when the weight is divided among two.
I've moved on to one and two pound TarpTents, but would still use my SD Lightning 2 for car camping, Boy Scout outings, and short distance (not duration) backpacking trips. It has the two wall advantage of reducing condensation, more privacy (good for the wife) and warmth, ie. reduced airiness over the TarpTents
One small downside is only one door. That means the person away from the door has to crawl over the other person in the middle of the night if they have to get out. It's not a problem if the same person is always the one getting up—just put them on the door side at night.
Go to this thread where a member is selling his SD Lightning now for only $125.—a great bargain.
http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=24397
I've moved on to one and two pound TarpTents, but would still use my SD Lightning 2 for car camping, Boy Scout outings, and short distance (not duration) backpacking trips. It has the double wall advantage of reducing condensation, more privacy (good for the wife) and warmth, ie. reduced airiness over the TarpTents If you begin to get as avid as some on this site, you can upgrade later for more weight savings, is my opinion.
I have done more research into the Tarp tents and would like any opinions from those that own them. Of particular interest would be any condensation issues people have had. I haven't found any reviews that question the ability of the tent to withstand wind or rain with the proper pitch. The SD lightning would be a very good tent, and probably wouldnt have any condensation issues as its a double wall but I'm leaning towards a tarp tent, so small and light…
Dave,
All shelters condense. Double wall shelters keep you away from it with a taught inner. In a single wall You manage the condensation by staying away from it and occasionally wipeing it down. Open and breezy single walls probably collect less moisture than a to-the-ground fly of a double wall.
If you search BPL for 'condensation' and 'single wall' you will find many long threads on this topic.
Dumb question?
David,
Go to the top right of this screen and select Forum Index.
Select the Forum of interest.
At the top of the forum page is a ‘Create a New Thread’ target.
Use the Insert Image button to add images.
Look at this to embed links.
Have at it.
I have s TT Rainbow(single) and never had too many condensation issues. Only time it was bad was a night that dropped into the upper teens with little breeze. I woke up with heavy frost inside my tent. But that is a trade-off in single wall silnylon shelters. Can’t speak to much to wind resistance, as I haven’t had it out in those conditions.
If you want more wind stability in a Tarptent, perhaps looks at the Scarp 2
If you consider the BA SL2, I’d actually look at the SL3 or Copper Spur 3 or REI QuarterDome 3. More space for not that great a jump in weight. The SL2 is a tight fit for two people, even a spouse. I got it as a solo tent before I found out I could get more UL.
Thank you!
The DR is a great shelter… though my wife prefers a slightly larger space. It’s always good to keep the wife happy so I don’t use the DR with her. I have used the DR in a lot of conditions. Short of a blow the tree down sort of storm it will keep the rain off you. It might be a bit breezy but that’s managable. As others have said… it will often collect (just like on the inside of the fly on a double walled shelter) some condensation… but I have found that is completely managable. I switched to mostly using tarps and tarptents ~7 years. I have never regretted the change. Some of my experiences are written up on my recommended shelters page. That page references a nice article by Ron Moak about getting the most out of UL shelters which captures most of the issues well.
–Mark
All of your insight has been very helpful, I want to get either the DR or Rainshadow 2, however, since I'll be camping with my wife and I am just getting back out there, the SD lightning 2 may be a better choice for now. As I get more experienced I'll switch to a TT, but to limit any problems and keep the wife happy the lightning will be easier to manage, thanks for all the help!
"…the SD lightning 2 may be a better choice for now. As I get more experienced I'll switch to a TT, but to limit any problems and keep the wife happy the lightning will be easier to manage…"
A sound approach. As you use the Lightning be sure to occasionally and lightly note the condensation on the fly, and the need to let it dry etc. Then, over time, introduce the concept of a single wall or tarp, and the minor inconveniences of condensation, and the major reduction in weight.
Starting with a single wall and watching the condensation roll down the walls in the morning can be pretty intimidating. But learning that it was always there, just well managed, shifts the perspective, and allows for the possibility of transition.
Having a knowledgeable and happy hiking buddy is well worth the effort.
Your likely future transition could easily follow mine. After my Lightning, I bought TarpTents—first a Squall (2 person), then a Contrail (1 person), then a Squall 2, then a Sublite (1 person). I still own the Lightning and the last three TarpTents. My wife didn't complain when she slept in the Squall this summer on a day that there was plenty of condensation. Another night this summer had about 35 mph winds with no problems, again in the Squall. It was breezy in the tent, but my quilt was plenty warm enough. They'll all handle the wind, rain and condensation just fine. Good luck.
I bought the lightning 2, and hopefully my skill and confidence with tents will increase, I have my eye on the TT DR I might just buy it next year despite my inexperience and figure it out in my backyard. Thanks for all the help!
Become a member to post in the forums.

