I was about to pull the trigger on the Montbell UL Down Inner Jacket, when I noticed that there is also a Montbell Extremely light Down Jacket that weighs a wee bit less and costs a wee bit more. There is a little less fill, though it says it is 900 fill down. Is this Extremely Light model a good substitute/replacement for the praised UL Down Inner Jacket in a layering system? Anyone with any info on the key differences? Thank You!
Topic
Montbell UL Down Inner Jacket vs. Extremely Light Jacket
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
The EL jkt uses lighter fabric (7 denier vs. 15 denier) so it is slightly less durable but lighter. I believe the E.L. jkt is also cut a bit different. Supposedly the E.L. does not have a bit of extra length on the back, but rather it is the same length all the way around, so it can feel short on your back….especially when you bend over. The U.L. is already kinda short, so I wouldn't buy the E.L. as a fashion statement.
The E.L. also has just a standard DWR treatment, whereas the U.L now how the new 'permanent' DWR. The U.L. was just updated a few weeks ago with a bunch of small but good changes.
The U.L. now has an cinch cord in the waist hem, whereas the EL does not. (edit, oops…I think just the parka has the adjustable hem, not the U.L jkt).
I imagine the warmth is the same since 1.8oz of 900 fp down likely equals 2.0oz of 800fp down.
The $15 price different doesn't seem too significant. I think it really comes down to weather you want a more fragile face fabric and potentially a shorter cut in exhange for saving 1.6oz.
Personally, if I was using it just for lightweight backpacking I would buy the E.L., but if you want to use it in your day to day life as well then it's probably better to go with the more durable fabric and better fit.
Have you considered the U.L. parka? The hood is quite handy to have, especially if you are a quilt user.
With the parka, you can leave your beanie at home so there probably is no overall weight penalty with opting for the parka. You may actually save weight since a typical light beanie is 3oz and the weight penalty to opt for the parka is about 2.7oz. My parka (size medium) actually weighs 0.5oz less than the claimed 9oz. So for 8.5oz I get it all.
My U.L parka weighs slightly less than someone with the E.L. jkt and a 3oz beanie (8.7oz total), and I get:
– cinch cords in the waist and hood
– simplicity of having it all in one (less stuff to lose)
– warmer because you neck is insulated too. There is no gap between the jkt and beanie.
Compared to the U.L jkt (7.3oz), there is only a 1.7oz penalty to opt for the parka (if you use the claimed 9oz weight) which is likely lighter than any decently warm beanie.
I have a Montbell UL down inner jacket and it's a nice piece of kit. However, my beanie comes too, because there are plenty of times when I want to wear a warm hat, but not a warm jacket. E.g, uphill in a cold wind.
The hood is nice for sleeping in though, so worth it's weight IMO.
I'd call a 3 oz beanie heavy for sure. When light balaclavas weigh 1.5 range, a beanie can surely weigh the same or near 1 oz.
For the last week or so, Ive been crunching numbers, comparing jackets, studying jacket constrution, and learning about down and loft.
When looking at the two jackets you have in mind, I figured that since the difference from 800 and 900 is 13 percent of 900 (rounded up) we could multiply the fill of the lightest jacket by the percentage difference of quality of down and add them together to get 2.034. That number lends to me that the Ex Light jacket would be just ever so slightly warmer than the Inner by .034 ounces of down. Since the Ex Light has a smaller cut than the Inner, its then fair to assume that the same amount of down has to work less hard to warm you up in the Ex Light. The only caveat I have is that I have no clue if the numbers I crunched actually flow so easily in regards to thermal properties.
Throw a drawstring on the Inner, though, and it trumps the ExL all around as a result of better protection.
If I weren't trying to get a hood and only trying insulate for ~30 – ~40 degrees, I'd totally get the ExL.
Jack
Thank you all for the replies! Actually, I sleep in Montbell mummies… so I have a hood in my sleep systems. The jacket would serve as warmth when needed about camp, or if needed to add extra warmth to the sleeping bag should temps dip near or below the bags rating. I know what you mean about the fit though… The EL seems all the business, while the UL might possess better Starbucks manners should I decide to wear it out in town. Of course, it is still 90 degrees in southern California…
I wonder why MB didn't just go all the way with the EL jacket and eliminate the full zipper as well; make it a pull over? Then you're talking some real weight savings over the UL Down Inner; as it stands, it's just too incremental a difference for me (personally)to consider it over the Down Inner considering the drawbacks of no pockets and very fragile fabric. But a potentially sub-5oz down sweater? That'd be great.
I have no experience with the 7D nylon, just the 15D of the UL Down Inner. But based on that, talking about something half as strong, you'd certainly want to stay far, far away from anything that could abrade or snag on the 7D. Seems like that would be plastic bag type thin.
While the fabric on the EL is pretty fragile, I have been pleasantly surprised with how durable it is. After a few brushes with branches that I thought would for sure have torn the fabric, I have not noticed any wear or abrasion on the surface. Definitely not an around town jacket, but great for around camp and in a quilt or bag.
"When light balaclavas weigh 1.5 range, a beanie can surely weigh the same or near 1 oz."
They sure can. MH makes a couple including my favorite, the Transition Featherweight Dome, which has a Gore Windstopper barrier and weighs 1 oz. It's my go to beanie year around.
Thanks! Anybody care to comment on how the NEW UL Down Inner models fit? Tight/loose/or same as normal size? I am usually a small. 5'10" 139 lbs. No belly. No boobs.
I think the hand warmer pockets will come in… handy. Also the Polkatex DWR finish will be a plus in contrast to the previous models standard DWR finish.. not that one would want to trapse around in the rain while wearing one of these jackets. Again, thank you all for the information!
I am considering purchasing a Montbell U.L. Down Inner Parka for its weight savings over my REI Primaloft jacket (savings of about 7oz!).
My concern is the possibility of getting the down wet. I am an umbrella user, and only carry a 1oz emergency poncho as a backup, and rarely use it. I also use a Nunatak Down BCB, so in wet conditions, the possibility of wet down and no synthetic backup is real. Since I am a tarp user, condensation is not much of a consideration though.
Thoughts…experience???
If you hike in your insulating layer, then it's a big risk. I wouldn't try it.
If not, go with down!
Good point Todd…I don't hike in my insulation layer. If it were that cold, I assume I would need more than the Montbell U.L. Down Inner Parka when I got to camp!
The DWR on MB garments it superb. Do you carry a windshirt? If so, would could wear that over the top of your parka and underneath your umbrella if you need to me moving around in camp (without a pack on) during a shower.
FYI – I have an 2008 inner down parka and 2007/08 thermawrap parka. For the price, they can't be beat.
Yes, I always carry my Golite Ether. This too is not water proof, but I think what you are saying is that it would be another layer and help keep the moisture out?
Yes – two layers of fabric with DWR should be better at keeping the down dry – assuming breathability is not too compromised.
"I'd call a 3 oz beanie heavy for sure. When light balaclavas weigh 1.5 range, a beanie can surely weigh the same or near 1 oz."
You're right…I stand corrected.
"I wonder why MB didn't just go all the way with the EL jacket and eliminate the full zipper as well; make it a pull over?"
Hmm…excellent point. They should do this for sure. Just give it a 1/4 zip…just enough that you can get your head through the neck opening while still being able to zip the opening snug to retain heat.
"Anybody care to comment on how the NEW UL Down Inner models fit? Tight/loose/or same as normal size?"
There is a bunch of info on the updated ones here:
http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=23790
I posted a review with some pics there.
"My concern is the possibility of getting the down wet."
As mentioned by Matt, the DWR is superb. I ride a motorcycle (okay a scooter actually) and one night I was coming home from work when it was pouring rain unexpectedly. The ride home is about 5 minutes and I was travelling at speeds from 30-50mph. It was raining hard and when I got home the DWR had not failed at all. There was a bit of water that soaked in at the seams on my chest where the rain was hitting hard, but overall it was hardly wet.
I still wouldn't plan on wearing this in the rain while hiking, but it should do just fine under a rain shell or a decent DWR windshirt.
I think this is a really nice jacket. I don't have one yet but I am going to sell my MB down inner parka and get one of these.
Marketing aside, I think the biggest difference between the UL inner and the EL is pockets…the UL has them, the EL doesn't, and that explains most of the tiny weight difference between the two IMHO.
"I think this is a really nice jacket. I don't have one yet but I am going to sell my MB down inner parka and get one of these."
Yeah this does sound like a really nice jkt. I think it's quite comparable to the updated U.L. down inner parkas, now that the u.l. parka has more down. The U.L. parka has 2.5oz vs. 3.0oz for the WM. Besides that, there is price (the WM is $100 more) and the Montbell has cinch cords in the hood and hem. I think it's a tough call, but the $100 saved for the Montbell is what sold me. I don't think it's worth giving up the cinch cords and paying $100 more to gain 0.5oz of down.
Can someone comment on the durability of the Montbell U.L. Down Inner while wearing a pack? Over long distances, do the shoulder straps wear/ball/abrade the fabric on the shoulders? Or does it hold up well?
I want to know if I should be wearing something over the parka while hiking to protect the fabric or not.
I don't think the Mont-Bell jackets were designed for wearing under a pack. In fact I don't like the idea of wearing any down jacket while hiking. I think fleece or even a synthetic puffy jacket suits this need much better.
I have worn my Thermawrap parka under pack straps briefly. As stated, I wouldn't recommend it for long periods of time. But I did what I needed to do to get warm. The problem, especially with the synthetic insulation, is that you put a lot of pressure directly on the insulation and a shift in the pack could tear insulation. Not recommended, but do it if you need to.
Thanks guys…I'll try to avoid it.
Become a member to post in the forums.

