For me cooking inevitably involves some frying. However, many ultralight cooking systems are more for boiling in the bag. I wonder if people have experience with frying on the Clikstand alcohol stove. With its windscreen, pan size is limited to a diameter of 15 cm, which is not that much. Any good suggestions for a 15 cm max pot and pan combo, preferably with good heat dispersions properties (i.e. non Ti)? Alternatively, one could use a larger frying pan such as the 80 gram 18 cm hardanodized Trangia frying pan. However, then you cannot use the extra windscreen. How well does the Clikstand work without the extra windscreen?
Topic
Cooking real food: a light stove for frying
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
I'm not familiar with the clikstand stove (I just now looked it up to see what it was), but I have a snowpeak cookset that comes with a small frying pan that would probably work. I love it. I've used it to fry brook trout filets and it worked like a charm.
Off topic, the clikstand stove looks pretty cool. How do you like it? pros/cons? (Sorry, I don't mean to steal your thread, it just looked interesting)
If you want to fry, grab yourself a FeatherFire alcohol stove by Packafeather. I have one, they work great. Just fry in a HAA pot (rather than ti) if you don't want to lug a frying pan along.
My featherfire weighs 46g (1.6oz) plus another 17g (0.6oz) for an oven liner windscreen.
I would say that an adjustable stove is ideal for frying since it is easy to burn food considering that most pans are relatively thin. I made some eggs yesterday on my Trangia and Snow Peak Hybrid cookset pan. It was fairly difficult to keep stuff from burning without the use of the simmer ring.
I share in your plight on this one..
I consider myself a gourmet light backpacker, so inevitably my cook system/food seems to be out of whack weight wise compared to other gear..
Side burner alcohol stoves work well for larger frying pans, and depending on the type of frying you can adjust the heat somewhat by using or removing the windscreen.
For stir-frying or hard frying they can be great, although if you are doing light frying, and have a heavy-ish bottom pan, you may need to get it hot, and then switch to some sort of open alcohol stove.. like the tuna can filled with perlite and hardware cloth screen, just to keep the heat up, but not scorching..
The issue of course with this, is more a limitation of ultra-light pans, other than the stoves really. I've occasionally taken a small cast-iron pan, and had zero issues frying with alcohol. Ti pans, it's a nightmare.
So what we need, is someone to make a Ti fry pan, that has a heavy bottom, like triple thick Ti.. It would cost in weight, but still be light compared to all capable alternatives..
Anybody seen anything like that? I've been wondering if I could order some Ti plates off ebay and have one welded onto a Ti pan bottom..
Also, if you find the right pan, I'm thinking you could make a small pepsi-can stove with the jet's just perfect for frying..
It might take a little trial-and error, finding the right heat output, but there's alot of flexibility with this.
Adding the weight of an extra pepsi-can stove would be extremely minor if you're already using alcohol.
I have fried in Trangia hardanozided pans and that worked really rather well and at 80 grams the 18 cm UL HA frying pan is really not that heavy. The Trangia non stick is even better, but heavier (120 grams for the 18 cm). So I am now considering using the lighter 15 cm non stick frying pan of the Trangia 28 (the mini Trangia) and use an 80 gram 1 litre pot from the Trangia 27 for boiling. I am not sure if packed the frying pan will fit around the top of the cooking pot, however. So far I have not yet found a store that stocks both, to try.
As a stove I think I will use the Clikstand, with the Trangia burner, for as long as no one make a lighter one with lid and simmering facility.
"I consider myself a gourmet light backpacker"
"I've occasionally taken a small cast-iron pan"
What?!
Cast iron is a different story….. As I said, I also like my real food. However, the 15 cm Trangia non stick frying pan weighs just 68 grams, and I think that is really not bad for a pan that keeps up with the best. Maybe you can shave off another 20 grams (max) with a uselessly thin titanium pan that also uses more fuel, but that is about it. The down side is a scorched meal.
PS: If you can find one (check online at Amazon!) look for a one egg wonder pan. It is a small slick as can be fry pan – I have one that the coolest guy sent me along with a custom made lid. F-U-N for the weight and little cleanup. It has a thick core as well for even heat.
I use an MSR frypan with a Ti Tri.
Don't know if its the lightest but it works.
Not crazy about the non stick surface but everyone puts those stupid non stick coating on their pots these days.
I am looking at the same thing at the moment so I can “cook” rather than redydrate when I take my 4 year old son out with me.
When solo I use a Vargo Decagon Stove and MSR Ti Pot, easy as no issues at all and it does what I want, when I want, and for minimal weight.
Now as for cooking I was looking at the Snow Peak and a side mounted canister stove, probably something in the MSR range as thats about all you can get here in Australia. This Snow Peak setup has two pots and a fry pan, one pot I can leave at home. The weight of the two pots and pan is 7.1 oz (200g) so I am quite happy with that. Of course a little less with one pot.
Anyone out there used the Snow Peak setup before?
Cheers
"Cast iron is a different story….. As I said, I also like my real food. However, the 15 cm Trangia non stick frying pan weighs just 68 grams, and I think that is really not bad for a pan that keeps up with the best. Maybe you can shave off another 20 grams (max) with a uselessly thin titanium pan that also uses more fuel, but that is about it. The down side is a scorched meal."
Willem, that does not seem to make any logical sense. How would a thin titanium pan use more fuel? It takes less time to heat the pan and less fuel to simmer which means it uses LESS fuel. Although you have a point that it would burn foods, that could be remedied by oil and a stove w/ simmering capabilities.
The problem with Trangia is that no matter how hard they try to be ultralight, they will never be able to grasp the concept. They are stuck in the past with a museum of things like bare aluminum cookware and brass stoves when other companies are light years away in the future.
Well apparently it has to do with heat dispersal. See http://www.ultralight-hiking.com/stoves-trangia.html for some measurements, and this is not the only research.
As for "stuck in the past" I am not sure that applies to their new pots and pans in hard anodized aluminium. These are quite non stick, and really rather light. A 1 litre UL HA pot weighs 80 grams, and an 18 cm UL HA frying pan weighs another 80 grams (and the 15 cm teflon non stick frying pan in the Trangia 28 only weighs 68 grams). That really is not heavy.
The thing with titanium is that it is stronger than aluminium, but also heavier. So it only makes sense if you use it for very thin pans. And that is not a good idea for cooking. Because aluminium is lighter you can make thicker pans for the same weight. For pans tensile strength is hardly an issue.
I do think their windscreen design though very efficient is also unnecessarily heavy. Thus alternatives have been developed like the Clikstand and the Caldera Cone. I also think the actual burner is indeed unnecessarily heavy. However, it has two advantages that for some at least are important: it has a lid so you can conserve unused fuel, and it has the simmer ring. If and when someone markets a lighter burner with those two features, I will buy one. The new Ti burner from Evernew lacks both, and is still heavier than a soda can burner.
For me the attraction of a Trangia system is that it is very good for cooking real food from fresh ingredients. I am a cycle tourist, and on tour I shop every day for fresh food. So I need to be able to fry properly, and I also need a slightly larger pot. I want to apply as much as posible of the ultralight principles to a different kind of trips. Unfortunately most ultralight gear is for weekend warriors.
That is quite true. In the case of pans, aluminum might be the better choice. I don't understand how they could make lightweight cookware but refuse to make lighter stove model. It does not make any sense at all considering that the burner is their primary attraction.
I disagree with you that most ultralight gear are for weekend warriors. I'm not sure to what degree of UL you are talking about but many backpackers on here have lots of ultralight gear and I'm sure they backpack for more than 3 days.
One thing you don't see a lot of in UL cooking gear is fry pans. Why? Frankly, it doesn't fit in with the ideal the companies are presenting. If you think it out, it does make sense.If we are to go simple all one really needs is a pot to boil water or to cook in. A fry pan is a frill, a luxury item. Same with a mini spatula, a pepper grinder and a bowl. We don't "need" them.
Hence why you mostly only see fry pans aimed at old school backpackers.
Ti fry pans, lined or unlined suck and blow. They are masters of nothing. They heat unevenly, heat too fast and fry food on – the non stick suffers as well, it has a shorter lifespan than it does on a similar HAA pan due to this.
If you are going to want a fry pan, do a favor to your pocket and to avoid frustration/cussing later, get a light HAA one.It will heat evenly, clean well and not cost a small fortune.
Honestly, when I do use a fry pan I just use the fry pan lid off of a GSI Backpackers Set, it is sized perfectly.
By gourmet light backpacker I mean someone that's willing to sacrifice a bit on weight to eat real food. Which I feel I've become quite good at keeping weights down while avoiding the re-constituted food styles.
Yeah I carted along a small cast iron before I could afford anything else. And if I didn't mind all that weight, id still use it. Nothing cooks better.
I don't think frying is necessarily a frill. If you buy fresh food at the end of the day on your cycling trip in France (and on a cycle tour buying fresh is the real ultralight option), you need something to prepare it. This means a slightly larger pot because e.g. fresh vegetables may be less compact, and a frying pan to fry that steak, that chicken breast or those mushrooms. Moreover, the frying pan can also serve as an admittedly heavier lid for the pot.
What you might consider instead is a wide and more shallow 2 Liter pot – you would be surprised that yes, you can make pancakes, fry fish, etc in it. You can also cook one pot meals and as well boil water. The wide opening allows easy cleanup, shallow is easy to get in and out of.
+1 for the one egg wonder – cheap, light, nonstick. I used it with a supercat to fry an egg, took less than half an ounce of alcohol.
Ever since I heard that a wider pot boils better than a tall one I've been sold on the deep frying pan idea. I think that design is a truly one size fits all design for a single solo pot. Only problem is there are virtually none on the market deep enough and with a lid. Any favorites for a wide and shallow 2 liter pot?
> Unfortunately most ultralight gear is for weekend warriors.
'Weekend warrior' – like 3 months in France one year, and 6 weeks in Switzerland another year? Some 'weekend'!
Cheers
I have a wide 2l Ti pot with a snap on plastic lid as well as a Ti lid.
The secret to even frying with a thin pan is patience. You need to have a small wood fire and spread the glowing coals out and fry on those when the flame has died down.
Willem, you've mentioned several times a certain Trangia frypan that weighs 80 or 85 grams. Could you please furnish a link to that on their site? I'm having trouble finding pans at those weights on their site. The lightest I've found are in excess of 200 grams. Maybe you meant 8.5 oz instead of 85 grams?
Th elink is http://www.trangia.se/english/3652.directions_for_use.html
Click on Weight Table, and you get the list of weights of the constituent parts. The one I am referring to is the hard anodized 18 cm frying pan of the Trangia model 27 UL HA, part number 642711. 80 gram is just under 3 ounces. You need a separate gripper, however.
Become a member to post in the forums.

