Topic

Another Rain Gear Thread

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)
PostedOct 1, 2009 at 8:41 am

Hi, Fellow Hoofers;

Just got back from 5 days on the Long Trail. It was amazing, but I had a complete rain gear malfunction.

I still consider myself "in transition" to ultralight backpacking, and my rain gear was just a modest campmor shell, and a campmor pack over. I forewent my goretex bike rain-pants and gaiters to save on weight (O, how I would rue that decision!).

I've read all about DriDucks etc., here. But what I'm really looking for is something akin to "the killer poncho;" something that would only need to be supplemented by a pair of gaiters; i.e. something that would keep me and my pack dry in 36 hours of driving rain.

Does such a mythical beast exist?

Thanks,

Tim.

PostedOct 1, 2009 at 9:24 am

Tough question. I'm just getting started with poncho/tarp camping, and I can say with my minimal experience that you're going wet. The trick is staying warm, wetness notwithstanding.

If you're a member, check out Roger's MYOG mountain poncho, which he and his wife used with GoLite wind pants (Whims) in France for a few months: http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/myog_mntn_poncho.html (This one is on my to-do list)

Also, make sure you read the article on gear for cold, wet camping: http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/cold_wet_gear.html

Sanad Toukhly BPL Member
PostedOct 1, 2009 at 11:22 am

Personally, I don't like poncho/tarps on long distance hikes or if I'm expecting "36 hours of driving rain". You have no protection from rain while you're setting up your shelter when using a poncho/tarp. Sure it's only for two minutes or so, but two minutes in a down pour will soak you and leave you wet and cold the rest of the night. I like using a poncho tarp on weekend trips when I'm not expecting a lot of rain. Otherwise, I stick with my Rain Wrap (2.5 oz) and O2 Rainwear hooded jacket (4.7 oz). I recommend the Rainshield products over Driducks, as they seem to last longer.

-Sid

obx hiker BPL Member
PostedOct 1, 2009 at 11:59 am

As Sid put it:
"You have no protection from rain while you're setting up your shelter when using a poncho/tarp" Not to mention leaving the shelter for ANYTHING. Like Sid I also love my rain wrap. Put on that kilt and climb a few munroes. I use an integral designs cape up top. Neat thing about the cape is you can leave it hanging around your neck and tucked into a pack strap or something in stop and go rain; it doesn't have to be actually "on" I rigged two 18" x 1/16th diameter bungee cords to "fasten" the back of the cape to the bottom of the pack using the exit grommets of the bungee-corded bottom cinch of the cape as attachment points. Also both pieces can be used to supplement your tarp ( gear alcove, sidewall, whatever ) or as a "tablecloth" for a picnic….. groundcloth for unpacking and re-packing and so forth and so on. So you have @ 6 oz of extra multi-use material that you'll often use even if there's no rain. And if there's any chance of 36 hours of driving rain for pete's sake bring an umbrella

PostedOct 1, 2009 at 12:14 pm

I should have mentioned that a long poncho (not a poncho/tarp) with gaiters may work fine. You could also go with chaps (see MLD) and stay dry. Still need gaiters to cover gap between shoes and bottom of wp pants.

PostedOct 1, 2009 at 12:44 pm

"And if there's any chance of 36 hours of driving rain for pete's sake bring an umbrella"

LOL. An umbrella is no use in wind driven rain, and if there's a good enough chance of 36 hours of foul weather, just stay home (unless you live in Scotland or New Zealand)! Mind you, if a trip is long enough, there is always a good chance of 36 hours bad weather at some stage.

I find a long rain coat and knee high gaiters are good enough for most conditions. If the bit between the bottom of my raincoat and top of my gaiters gets a bit wet, it's no big deal. Chances are I'll be crossing a deep river soon, and my legs will get wet anyway.

PostedOct 1, 2009 at 12:57 pm

>>…I'm really looking for is something akin to "the killer poncho;" something that would only need to be supplemented by a pair of gaiters…<<

In my experience, hiking here in New England there is one problem with using a poncho that's so long that it covers your entire legs: it makes it difficult to see your feet. In many areas where I've walked, this isn't a huge issue…but around here (the Long Trail is a great example) the rocks and roots underfoot can be somewhat tricky with a really long poncho.

Having said that, I used a SeaToSummit poncho/tarp, combined with BPL chaps for the entire Long Trail in 2006. It rained at least a couple hours/day, probably 7 or 8 of the 11 days. Using a "belt" to keep the poncho tight around the waist helps to keep your feet visible, and keeps the excess material from becoming unwieldy on windy summits.

PostedDec 14, 2009 at 6:01 am

I'm wondering if anyone has tried making rain "leggings" to go with their Poncho.

I bike tour and had tried Frog Toggs. Love the jacket, but the pants are way to delicate in the crotch for biking. It occured to me I could just make leggings by cutting off the legs at the top and using some elastic cord and cord locks.

I figured I'd just find some nice breatheable waterproof shorts to go with it, but then I was on the Jack's R' Better website and saw a bivy made from a Frog Togg Poncho and it occured to me Frog Togg leggings plus a Frogg Togg Poncho might be the ultiamte lightweight combination.

BTW, the leggings are not just for rain… I figure they'll also make great emergency legg warmers.

PostedDec 14, 2009 at 7:43 am

"I'm wondering if anyone has tried making rain "leggings" to go with their Poncho."

I did this (home made rain chaps) using dri-ducks pants (similar to frogg toggs). Just cut the crotch out at an angle, retained about 1 – 2 inches of the elastic waist band on each side, and my wife kindly hemmed the cut edges. I'm not much of a MYOG type of guy but this wasn't difficult, and both frogg toggs and dri-ducks come in a set — so if you just want the jacket, not much downside in trying this out.

To keep them from falling down I just sort of roll the former waist band elastic around my belt a couple of times, and that seems to be sufficient, though a person could easily enough sew some sort of loop on or something.

I now use a set of GG spinnchaps (well, I carry them a lot more than I use them …) because they're lighter and pack smaller,
http://www.gossamergear.com/cgi-bin/gossamergear/Spinn_Chaps.html Despite the link, I'm not sure GG sells these anymore (?).

Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedDec 14, 2009 at 8:17 am

I use a SMD Gatewood Cape for rain gear and shelter. I carry a GoLite poncho for day hikes and emergency shelter. With either, I get a pack cover in the deal and actually keep the pack dry– notably the back pad. Ponchos are weaker in the wind and a simple paracord belt can help. Ponchos and capes don't look very pretty but they are light, less expensive, ventilate well.

Leggings or chaps are okay, but I prefer regular rain pants and wear them with a light base layer in all day wet conditions. Trying to layer them over pants or shorts just makes for a clumsy mess for me. I use short gaiters but more for keeping my pant legs out of the mud and crud out of my shoes. If you are wearing waterproof shoes, more substantial gaiters might help; if not, your shoes are going to wet through anyway.

A 45 gallon low density polyethylene garbage bag makes for quick and dirty rain gear if using a poncho shelter, as well as pack liner, half-bivy, ground sheet, solar still, or waterproofing an improvised shelter. A 99 cent poly poncho can do the same.

For regular rain gear, I do have a set of DriDucks, but haven't used them. I do have doubts about the durability. IMHO, they are best for summer backup coverage. They are light and cheap.

Getting to harder shell gear, IMHO Marmot Precip or Patagonia Rain Shadow give the best compromise of weight, durability and all day protection. My heavy-heavy rain jacket is a North Face XCR parka. Whatever you choose in a hard shell, good ventilation features are mandatory. For the conditions you describe, keeping the DWR in good working order is a must.

PostedDec 14, 2009 at 5:43 pm

A very unique and nice solution to the pack cover/rain parka problem is the "PACKA". It's a rain parka W/ a back extension that covers your pack.

GOOGLE PACKA and take a look. You'll like the idea.

PostedDec 14, 2009 at 6:08 pm

"GOOGLE PACKA and take a look. You'll like the idea."

Loved the idea. Hate the reality!!

PostedDec 15, 2009 at 12:41 am

"something that would keep me and my pack dry in 36 hours of driving rain."

It doesn't exist.

I've come to prefer rain gear that is a little heavier than the lightest stuff. I'm liking paclite stuff.

PostedDec 15, 2009 at 10:34 am

""something that would keep me and my pack dry in 36 hours of driving rain.""

A good tent!

PostedJan 26, 2010 at 6:59 pm

@Brian Lewis (brianle): thanks for the response on the rain leggings thing. Hadn't thought about making them tuck into the waste band. Probably much better then what I had in mind. Since I just use the jackets I have a spare pair of leggings sitting around.

Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)
Loading...