I am going to Philmont next summer and looking for shoe/boot for the trek. Have decided to go somewhat lightwieight trying to keep pack around 35lbs. Want to try Merrell Moab goretex XCR's. My question is do the mid heights really provide much if any additional ankle support over the standard shoes? I am paranoid about twisted ankles during the hike. Mid's are 7 oz more than shoes, is it worth it?
Topic
Merrell Shoe Question
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Richard, Do a forum search on each of your topics – you will find more information then you can read. Read this one especially Philmont Scout Ranch: How Light Can You Go?
This is just me talking-
35 lbs isn’t lightweight (drop 20 lbs off that, then your talking lightweight).
Goretex shoes/boots aren’t good during the summer.
If you are paranoid about your ankles, strengthen them! Don’t think that a boot is going to make it better. I rolled my ankles when I use to wear boots but I haven’t since I got out of them. Boots don’t allow your foot to move properly nor do they allow you to fell the ground. When you can fell the ground your mind will adjust the muscle tension/flex appropriately. BTW, 1/2 a pound isn’t worth it- that like putting 4 pounds on your back, now you are up to almost 40 lbs!
There is a great article this summer about a guy who did Philmont with 8.5 lbs.
At least you have a lot of time to read and get ready.
I have always been a huge fan of Merrell's and have a pair of mid height Moab's. I think they offer a lot of ankle support! I've worn them while hopping across rocks in the south yuba river in california and I havn't twisted my ankle yet! Knock on wood… ;-) I like em. I don't have the gore-tex though.
I agree though, 35 lbs isn't very lightweight and you're going to be prone to more ankle rolls anyway.
I consider the idea of wearing boots to prevent ankle twists to be a myth. If you're that worried about it, get some high quality ankle braces and wear shoes. But strengthening your ankles is the best idea. As far as Goretex, it's great in shoes, if you want them to stay wet inside longer, and take a lot longer to dry out. You have some time, so you should also look at Salomon shoes, they are fantastic.
Thanks for the comments so far. I just want to be clear the 35lbs I mentioned would include crew gear, water, and heavy Philmont food. I know it still is not UL but it is better than the 50-60lbs that some do. I may get the weight down to 30 but I am just starting the process so I gave myself a pretty easy goal.
So do most people agree that goretex is not the way to go for a summer trek at Philmont? Keep in mind that it rains a lot there in July from what I hear.
Also, should have mentioned that I need a shoe that comes in wide sizes.
Richard- no on the Goretex (I understand rain- I live in the Seattle area, and I don't use Goretex)
Just a note- It looks like you need to adjust your crew gear, and look into how to make your cooking lighter… I can't see how all of that will add up to 20 lbs. (15 lbs max for your personal gear)
Water is available for the most part and on the dry camps you will only need to carry it for a little while at most.
UL is below 10 lbs-
If you are justifying 35 lbs by pointing at someone carrying 50-60 lbs, saying "at least I'm not carrying that much", well that is like the boy who stole a cookie from the jar and when caught said "but Johnny stole 2".
You can get your weight down- it will be a lot more difficult if you keep looking at the 50 lb packer as justification for your 35 lbs.
I speak from experience- I was that 50-60 lb Scouter, then one summer I cut it to 35 lbs, then by the next summer it was at 15 lbs.
Last weekend on our scout hike, I was at 10 lbs (including water, food, fuel), you too can do it just make the commitment and don't look back.
> I consider the idea of wearing boots to prevent ankle twists to be a myth.
Absolutely!
> But strengthening your ankles is the best idea.
Absolutely too!
Gore-Tex is good in the snow, but less useful elsewhere. When it rains the water goes in the big hole at the top – and can't get out. Your feet may stay wet longer.
Cheers
I debated the same question with the same shoe. I went with the low cut and non-gortex model.
I decided that the extra "leather" in the high top just meant that there was more area to rub against my foot to cause blisters. I decided against the gortex. As Joe C. said above, gortex takes longer to dry. If it is raining all day ylur foot is going to get wet regardless.
As to size, my foot measures US size 9. In the Merrell, the size 10.5 felt fine in the store, but proved too short in the field. I traded it ion for the size 11. No problem I wore them to hike the JMT and many miles on the AT.
Regardless of which shoe you buy, try to hike in it ahead of time before you commit to a longer trip.
BTW I waded through a stream wearing them, boy did that wet shoe feel heavy. Imagine how it would be if the shoe weighed more when dry!
I have the low-cut Goretex Moabs. They're great if you can guarantee that you aren't going to have water come over the top and into the shoe. Like everyone else has pointed out, Goretex shoes make great buckets. For me that limits their usefulness to around town in wet or snowy conditions.
I prefer something that dries quickly and breathes well when I'm hiking.
Adam
…
I wear these everytime I'm hiking somewhere and I love them. As for your worries about carrying 35lbs with them…I've never had a problem. When I'm hiking to a climbing spot, it's not uncommon for me to be lugging 50lbs of trad gear and I've never rolled my ankle.
As for gore tex…I agree with what someone mentioned above. It's great if you want to keep water inside your shoe. The Ventilator has a lot of mesh and it actually dries rather quickly.
I have Moab Ventilators in both the low and mid height versions. Wore the mid-heights to do 200 miles and nine high (11 000 foot plus) passes of the high Sierra plus climbing Mount Whitney. That's LOT of rocky switchbacks and scrambles. Definitely get the wide versions.
The wide mid heights were great; no ankle turns, walked right thru the water crossings, and the boots dried quickly.
The only downer is the lack of forefoot support. In earlier training hikes in the Cascades, I found the Ventilators had great heel cups, adequate arch and midfoot support, but were sorely lacking in the forefoot. I took a pair of gel insets and cut them down to fit under my full length Superfeet insoles. The gel went from the tips of my toes back to just in front of the ball of my foot. Worked GREAT! No more sore feet. YMMV.
Like most shoes and boots, the Merrell factory stock insoles are worthless for trail work. Replace them and your feet will thank you.
Become a member to post in the forums.

