Topic

low cost, ultralight tent for dad and toddler

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
Jeremy G BPL Member
PostedSep 20, 2009 at 1:14 pm

I am looking for some ideas and feedback on a low cost, ultralight tent for my toddler and I for next spring.

I currently have a tyvek sublite that I tried out for size on yesterday, and found that it was just a bit too small. I also watched in horror as he walked across it as I was setting it up and then turn and take both my trekking pole and then later a tent stake to it. Fortunately, no damage done, but I think for peace of mind I need to go to silnylon for the two of us. He is a little tornado and goes non-stop. What better place to have him outdoors and he loved going in out of this "fort" for a total of about 20 times in the 45 minutes I had it set up.

I am 6'4" which definitely limits my options. We are also in MN where the mosquito is also unofficially our state bird. Thus a floor and full netting is critical.

I used to have a floorless contrail that i traded up to a rainshadow 2. The rainshadow 2 is definitely overkill for just the two of us, but will definitely keep it for when the wife and newborn join us.

I am thinking about trading my sublite for a contrail as it is a little bigger, has a much bigger opening vs the very small door on the sublite.

I'd like to stay in the 1.5 lb range as I have to carry both William and all the gear/food.

How about feedback in regards to a groundsheet to help protect the floor. Normally I wouldn't, but William will want to walk around inside the tent. Maybe it's just a matter of taking time to inspect the ground under the tent and only let him walk around without his shoes on…

Anyone else have any other ideas for a shelter?

PostedSep 20, 2009 at 1:18 pm

From using it I can say the TarpTent Contrail has plenty of room for an adult and up to an 8 year old child. Get something with a floor space closely matching the floor space of the Contrail and you'll be fine.

Eric

PostedSep 20, 2009 at 2:04 pm

I would take the Rainshadow just to give him thrashing room at night or on a rainy day. My wife and I used our Rainshadow as a two-person tent for a while after our daughter went to college, and all that interior room was great. (We've since traded it for a Lunar Duo to get the two doors.)

PostedSep 20, 2009 at 3:04 pm

That was my rule with Ford when he was little (and now at nearly 12 he never questions it!). Shoes off before going inside – that way the tent stays cleaner but also doesn't get torn up.
Little ones don't take up much space inside – Ford and I slept in a 1 1/2 man tent till he was at least 7 or so. :-) But…in bad weather a roomy tent can be a good thing, giving them room to move around.

Thomas Burns BPL Member
PostedSep 20, 2009 at 3:22 pm

IMO, you can't go wrong with the Contrail — roomy, 24 oz, and reasonably priced.

Stargazer

PostedSep 20, 2009 at 5:43 pm

I'm with Ken.
No experience whatsoever in tenting with an hyperactive ( or Valium sedated for that matter) kid, BUT I imagine that any kid would drive me crazier ( maybe sane) if stuck inside a Contrail on a rainy afternoon.
But if you really want to help the economy, buy a Squall 2, cheap at the price…
Franco

PostedSep 20, 2009 at 6:19 pm

Den 2's were on sale at campsaver for $99. That's pretty cheap though not exactly UL.

PostedSep 20, 2009 at 6:54 pm

Rich
Pay attention..
Jeremy already has the Rainshadow II, bigger and a lot lighter than the Den.
Franco

PostedSep 20, 2009 at 9:32 pm

If my kids were still young, i would be looking at a mid of some kind. Lots of room for an active kid to stand up and move around. Side entry is better in my opinion, as you wouldn't want kids to have to climb over packs and other gear to get in, and any dirt trailed in won't be around the head area. An entry free of gulines and poles would be something i looked for too. I love my MLD Duomid and Inner, but i don't know how it would work with someone 6'4".

Jeremy G BPL Member
PostedSep 21, 2009 at 8:19 am

Thanks for all the feedback! I'm definitely leaning towards the TT Contrail. Realistically, if rain was in the forecast I would either just stay home and go another weekend or throw the Rainshadow in. Any of our trips would be 1-2 nights and probably less than 5 miles / day. Mostly because the little guy can only stay couped up in the carrier for so long.

I certainly like the idea of a mid, but the Duomid definitely looks to short for my height. I looked at oware's mids quite a few times, but not having mosquito netting and a floor definitely dissuades me. After I get a little more experience sewing, I will probably take up getting one of those and sewing in a net door, net skirt and a floating bathtub floor.

I was looking at the SMD Lunar Solo as well, but I think that would be too short for me as well.

I like the idea of the TT Rainbow, but I don't know if the extra weight is worth it over the Contrail.

Rog Tallbloke BPL Member
PostedSep 21, 2009 at 9:06 am

I think you would just about fit in the lunar solo, maybe with a coat over your feet to keep condensation off the bag.

Not saying it's the best option though, as their is low headroom in the back, even for a little 'un.

PostedSep 21, 2009 at 4:48 pm

While not the cheapest or lightest option, at 6′,4″ you might have a look at the Vapor Light 2 XL from sierra designs (an REI exclusive for the very tall). With a 93 X 52 floor space it looks roomy, on paper anyway.

Link

PostedSep 21, 2009 at 5:32 pm

"I'm definitely leaning towards the TT Contrail"
Well, alright then..
Some like it.
Contrail for 2
Note the two pole set up. Also as you can see if set up correctly the bags touch the mesh not the fabric.
The two Nalgenes (one on top of the other) was to show the foot room you have at the end of my bag, around 5'10" from memory. As a (possibly redundant..) suggestion, leave the beak open for the night.
Franco

Jeremy G BPL Member
PostedSep 22, 2009 at 6:02 am

Brian, thanks for the heads up. However, that is quite a bit heavier than my Rainshadow 2 and still less room. It might be a little longer, but I have no problem at all fitting into my Rainshadow. I was just looking for something lighter than my Rainsshadow.

Jeremy G BPL Member
PostedSep 22, 2009 at 6:11 am

Franco, Your love for the contrail never ceases to amuse me!! When I had my previous floorless Contrail, I did use your techniques in my set-up.

contrail open

I am glad I will end up with a Contrail with a floor vs the one I had. I can't imagine having a little toddler sleeping in a shelter with no floor… Talk about getting dirt into everything!!

It does indeed look like there will plenty of room for the two of us… Now to figure out the best scenario for sleeping pads.

I have a couple sleeping bags that I have converted to quilts, so depending on temps, I figure I can cover the both of us with one quilt pretty easily. I have a BA Clearview and I think I can just put him on a foam pad, but he will be a couple inches lower than me… Not sure how that will work. May have to try it out in the back yard first.

PostedSep 22, 2009 at 6:33 am

My hand goes up for the Contrail too!, it was actually Franco's threads that convinced me to purchase one….and also my DR.

I have a 4 year old, we are yet to stay out in the bush in the contrail however it has been setup overnight in the back yard and there was pleanty of room for the two of us.

Cheers
Mark

Jeremy G BPL Member
PostedSep 22, 2009 at 8:01 am

Had a question via email as to how to do the two-pole setup, so I thought I would post my response for others…

In regards to using two poles on the contrail, I put both of the handles up. This way for a few reasons. 1. Tips down = no slippage on the ground. 2. Keeps the handles clean and away from the varmints. 3. Doesn't poke a hole in the fabric. 4. It seems a little awkward at first as it doesn't seeem like they would fit, but once the tension is in place it stays put quite well. IMHO, much better than with one pole with the tip up. I also have 53" poles, so that helps to have the extra length. It is quite nice to have the nice large opening!!

Henry Blake BPL Member
PostedSep 22, 2009 at 8:50 am

I have a floored Contrail that you can look at and potentially borrow to try out to help confirm your decision. I am not currently trying to sell it. I live in Minnetonka by Ridgedale, essentially at 394 and 494. You can reach me at hsblake@gmail.com or at 612-386-8565. Henry

Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
Loading...