Topic

is this a product defect?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
PostedSep 17, 2009 at 12:13 pm

I have a fairly new air mattress (used maybe 6 times), which I absolutely love, but 2 trips ago I thought it may have sprung a leak as it wasn't as full in the morning. This last trip I knew there was a hole when I made it through half the night and had to reinflate, by morning it was almost flat again. Not "all air out" deflated, but "my shoulder touching the ground" deflated. So the manufacturor said they'd patch it for free for the life of the product, all I would be out would be the shipping chgs there and 4 to 6 weeks. Ouch. So I attempted to locate the hole with thick soapy water wiped on with a rag, and I ended up locating 6 in total, all on the top and I marked them with a small sharpie mark. The bottom had no holes, I assume they make the bottoms thicker. Anyway, I have no clue how this could have happened, I am very careful with my gear and have never slept without the sleeping bag. I can't imagine getting a hole per trip in the thing. About 3 of the holes are very minor and likely it's the other three, one in particular that's the main problem.

My question is, is this normal? Is this a defect? It's a highly rated mattress I'm afraid to name the brand, but it's a name brand backpackers pad, not a W@lm@rt discount brand.

Included was a patch kit, which should be enough to do the holes, they are tiny pinpricks, very hard to see without the soapy water, so I could cut the single patch (3" x 4") they supplied.

I don't want to be without it for 6 weeks, I want to continue camping well into winter this year, so there's really not a good time to send it in, except for maybe February.

I planned to patch one hole, I have no problem doing that, but should I send the thing back because there's 6 already?
What would you do in this situation?

Many, many thanks,
Bill

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedSep 17, 2009 at 12:25 pm

Whoa! That's nuts. I have a pad that's at least 12 years old and I've never put a hole in it. Another that I don't use any more that's closer to 20. If you've got a ton of pinprick holes in your pad, it's probably something you're doing.

Do you have a cat at home? That's not an uncommon problem. By saying that you've not slept without the sleeping bag, that sounds as though you're using a top bag, which could lead one to believe you're using a BA system. Clearviews aren't all that tough. IACs, though, (and their brethern) are pretty durable pads. I have no idea how you'd be getting holes in it unless you're playing around cactus or something. I've used my NeoAir right on the ground and on shelter floors with nary a scratch… Do you keep things in your pockets? I had a problem once with a rain jacket 'cause I kept putting my keys in a pocket, and wore through the coating…

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 12:29 pm

No disrespect intended, but why in the world would you be afraid on naming the manufacturer of your pad. Secondly, do you have a cat?

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 12:38 pm

Thank you for your reply.

Well, that's reassuring to know that this is not the norm anyway.

Yes we have a cat, but the pad lives in it's bag inside my backpack, stowed on top of the dresser when not in use. Not a topbag, I am always inside my Helium 15 bag, I love the thing. I may not close it all the way on hot nights, but I never sleep on pad alone.

No cactus, simply forest floor, no roots or stones or anything sharp, and like I said, they're all on the top ORANGE part (hint, hint).

I am very careful with it and almost every time sleep in just underwear (sorry) or sweatpants and t-shirt, never the pants or shorts worn during the day.

I forgot to add the locations of the holes, maybe this would help… The largest one under left shoulder, the rest are on the middle to right side, under buttocks, under knee, and two at foot area.

I cannot for the life of me think of what is happening.
Thx.

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 12:40 pm

Have you used a closed cell foam pad on top?

Mine was laden with fir needles (old, dry, sharp) from using it on the ground. I caught it before it went on top of my Clearview.

My wife punctured a ProLite 4 (top) with fir needle without any help from me.

As innocuous as they may seem, dry needles have excellent puncture capability.

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 12:42 pm

I wasn't sure if it would be considered brand-bashing, I just wanted to be careful.

Disclaimer: I am not specifically blaming the brand, it may be me, but stating the brand in no way implies that I am unjustly brand-bashing, yet anyway.

It is a POE Ether Thermo 6 pad.
Thx.

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedSep 17, 2009 at 12:46 pm

Not that it is much help, but I have a brand name self inflating pad that is orange on top that I have slept on for almost 200 nights in the backcountry. It has always been used on a tent floor or groundsheet, but has never had a hole. Assuming that it isn't the cat, or anything like that, it seems like a defect as they are all on the top of the pad.

Edit… sorry, not the same pad, mine is a Prolite 3.

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 12:49 pm

No, it goes REI tent floor, POE Ether Thermo 6, Marmot Helium 15, Me in cotton (underwear or sweatpants) (I know, shame shame) and that's it. I am 175lbs… ok, 180lbs. I start out back sleeping, then often roll on to side and may switch sides a few times before morning.

I can't state enough, the gear I buy is not cheap (I hate buying things twice) and therefor I treat it very well. Oh, I forgot, under the REI tent is a 3mil sheet of plastic, but the holes again are on top.

So, given all this info, is this something I should spend time patching myself, or send it back and hope for a replacement, or at least have the 6 holes patched?

Thx.

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 1:06 pm

So, assuming I patch myself, how big of pieces should I cut for a pinprick sized hole? Like 1/2" x 1/2" or 1" x 1"? How do you patch it? How much goop do you use? They included a small to medium sized tube of goo and the 3" x 4" patch. What is the process? I've never patched before.

Thx,
Bill

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 1:11 pm

Shooting into the dark….

If you are rolling your pad without first folding "dirt side to dirt side" you are rolling the "dirt side" into the top side. (I know there is no dirt involved, but to say "down side" is a bit ambiguous.)

Are the holes located in the same general spot or pretty uniformly spread out?

You can repair it easily with a little dab of SeamGrip.

But if you send it back, Maybe POE can determine if they are punctures or if (unlikely) it is a coating failure.

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 1:42 pm

Good points.

I fold it and roll it the exact same way it came to me. Exhaust all (remaining) air, fold it laterally in thirds so it's down to maybe 8-10" wide. This IIRC would overlap the clean and dirty sides a tiny bit, maybe two inches. Then I roll it up, not tight, but as loose as I can and still fit it in it's original bag. Then it goes in backpack and stay till the next trip.

I looked for, but did not see a pattern to the holes, with the exception of 4 of the 6 are along the right side, but the biggest "hole" is under my left shoulder.

Hm, just the goop, no patch at all? Or use a patch on the "big" hole and goop the smaller ones?

Thx

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 2:10 pm

"I am very careful with it and almost every time sleep in just underwear"

Boxers or briefs?

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedSep 17, 2009 at 3:09 pm

Very odd.

I would suggest returning the mat to POE and asking them for help.

Cheers

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 4:13 pm

Sounds like a lemon to me. If you bought it from REI like your tent, I would return it there. If not, I ship it back to the manufacturer.

ID

PostedSep 17, 2009 at 10:24 pm

No way to tell how the holes were caused. But since the pad worked fine for a few trips, then started to deflate, it indicates that the holes were formed in your care. Thus not a lemon. Though there is a VERY slight chance that the top fabric was a dud batch and overly thin. Unlikely.

In the future you could pay attention to whether you have sharp debris stuck to your bum before you sit on your pad. Happens very easily.

For the repairs. Unless it's a BIG hole, just put some goop on it. I've repaired over 100 holes this way. Works well.

PostedSep 18, 2009 at 7:15 am

"But since the pad worked fine for a few trips, then started to deflate, it indicates that the holes were formed in your care"

Very good point. I'll have to pay closer attention to what's happening to it outside of my sleeping on it, which should be just fine.

"It's rare but zippers can sometimes have sharp spots"

Also a good point, I'll have to check for that. That COULD be the left shoulder (the biggest) "hole" culprit I suppose since it's a left zip bag, and also I often roll onto that side. I'll have to check that out, thanks! But the other 5 are on the right, so, hmmmm. I'll pay closed attention to everything that happens, throughout the day in there. My son sleeps in the 2P tent with me and goes to bed before I do, so (copping out here) it could be him :^)

"Unless it's a BIG hole, just put some goop on it"

Thank you very much, I will goop it up and save the patch for the monster hole that will likely happen at this rate. How long does the goop have to cure? 3-4 hours or more like 2 days? I suppose until it's not goopey anymore.

"Boxers or briefs?"
thongs, doh! just kidding.

btw, idcrickmore, what is that a picture of????

Thx

Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
Loading...