I have a Rainshadow 2, love it – its 44oz plus tyvek. I'd like a 2 man that's much lighter and can double as one man. Suggestions please :)
Must fit in my NEW Mariposa :)
Topic
Become a member to post in the forums.
I have a Rainshadow 2, love it – its 44oz plus tyvek. I'd like a 2 man that's much lighter and can double as one man. Suggestions please :)
Must fit in my NEW Mariposa :)
Your subject line "Two person tent versus Double Rainbow" is a good example of a freudian slip and may contain the answer.
Franco
The DR is about the same weight as the Rainshadow II, as is the Lunar Duo. The Squall is lighter, but I think the only significantly lighter 2-man is the Spinnaker Squall from Gossamer Gear.
We own the Rainshadow (original), Double Rainbow, and Lunar Duo. I really like the LD.
You can't get a lighter tarptent than the Refuge-X.
+1 for the Squall 2. This will be significantly lighter than your Double Rainbow and provides great headroom, space for 2. My fiance, dog, gear, and I all fit in there without touching any of the tent walls. We're both under 6' (5'8"and 5'10") so YMMV. To avoid any condensation issues with the 2.5 of us, I always pitch with the foot towards the wind-this gives us a the perfect ventilation system and keeps us comfy+dry. Great UL tent! Highly Recommended :) If even more weight savings is your goal then check the Squall Classic or a tarp +bivy or net tent combo. I was really eyein the Squall Classic when I was buying a tarptent, but didn't have/want to dish out the extra money. I will for sure add one to my collection of UL shelters, but for now I'm lovin the Squall 2 and you will to. An Oware double bivy(10.5 oz) for example + 2 person tarp would push your BPW even lower and provide lots more versitility than a tarptent. Our Oware Dixon Double bivy + Oware Cattarp 2 weigh in at 22 oz's total. If the weather is nice than we can skip setting up the tarp and enjoy an excellent night stargazing in our bivy. The pertex shell provides excellent breatheability and protects perfectly against spindrift and anything else that my tarp doesn't . For summer/bug weather there's many net tent options out there, so this yet another option . Have and fun with your selection and research.
The GG/Tarptent Squall Classic is definitely smaller than the Squall 2. It's perfect for me plus my 80-lb. dog, who sleeps curled up at my feet, but it would be a pretty snug fit for 2 fully grown humans. It certainly wouldn't do for two plus dog unless the people are short and the dog is small. Only one person can sit up at a time in the Squall Classic because there's less headroom than in the Squall 2. Note that Gossamer Gear is now advertising it as a 1+ person tent. While I love my Squall Classic, if I'm going out with a grandkid, I'll take my Squall 2 instead. If the weight savings of the Squall Classic are worth the money and the cramped conditions for two persons, fine–YMMV!
The Double Rainbow, last time I checked, is the same weight as the Cloudburst 2 and lighter than the Rainshadow 2. The Rainshadow 2 has an awfully big footprint, making it harder to find a place to pitch it (it is a three-person tent, after all, that could sleep four in a pinch). The nice thing about the Double Rainbow is that each person has his/her own door and vestibule. If you've ever had your sleeping partner plant his/her foot or knee on your face during a middle-of-the-night trip, you'll know what I mean.
We haven't got to the bivvy comfort level yet :) so thats out although getting more appealing all the time just for weight… the Refuge X would probably crumble in my hands…it looks too fragile really….and pricey at $400!
The Refuge X is definitely not bullet proof, but what UL shelter is? With proper care and site selection, it is a great shelter…

…although I do prefer my GG SpinnTwinn for its extra room, open feel, and sub 9oz weight!.
I'm not sure how it feels compared to silnylon? I'm just worried it'd not do well – the weight is awesome… but if i went spinntwin, what bug covered bivvy would i go with?
I really like the freestanding mode of the DR with the trekking poles. I gets gusty here quite often and I find the DR well suited for it.
John,
The Refuge X has a silnylon floor, and the rest is cuben. The cuben is much lighter than silnylon, but pretty tough, although elss puncture resistant.
If you go with the GG SpinnTwinn, they do offer a bug canopy that basically protects you from the flying type, not crawling.
http://www.gossamergear.com/cgi-bin/gossamergear/Bug-Canopy.html
In my neck of the woods, we don't have many bugs, so it's not much of a consideration. And I don't use a bivy because the tarp is so large it has adequate rain protection on its own.
John
What about duoMid with the bug tent – that seems good! Not mentioned thus far….
I've got both the DR and the Squall II. Love them both. The slightly lighter weight and simpler setup of the Squall is very attractive, as are the options and possibilities with the DR. I honestly can't decide between them, even though I really need to sell one of them…..If only life were made up of more of these type of decisions!
I just went throught the same dilema. I was torn between a Six Moon's Refuge (not the cuben version) and TT Squall 2.
I finally decided on the Refuge because it is lighter and roomier. It does lack a bathtub floor which concerns me because I have never owned a tent with this style of floor. Mine weighed in at 23.8 oz. after seam sealing. It packs very small as well. For the price they could have included the extra two guy lines that can be used to pull the sides out and stakes.
I haven't even set it up yet so take this all with a grain of salt.
Become a member to post in the forums.