Topic

Big Agnes Mattress Debate

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedSep 11, 2009 at 3:30 am

I think I already know my answer, but I figured Id ask the experts before committing to buy anything. Here are the contenders.

http://www.rei.com/product/763895

http://www.rei.com/product/775861

They are both petite, so nice and small. Howevever, here is what gets me. They both cost the same price, yet the Dual Core has a 5 r-value rating while the Diversion has a 4.1 rating.

Im going to do spring and summer hiking 90% of the time with an occasional fall hike here and there. I will admitt, when I say fall hiking, I mean I wouldnt mind venturing into the month of Novemeber. This being in the middle of Wisconsin. So heres the thing they are both the same price which really boggles my mind with the R-value difference. Still the freaking Dual Core weigh 10 ozs more, so really it just dont seem like it is for me.

Personally, from my standpoint, I think I will do just fine with the Diversion and even that might be a slight overkill especially if most of my hiking will be done in late spring and summer. Can I get an verdicts from anyone else. Thanks.

P.S. I dont like the Air Core mattress which is slightly lighter than the Diverison, so please dont throw that idea other there. Something about the pad just doesnt feel right to me.

PostedSep 11, 2009 at 6:46 am

Those things are heavy.

I used to use a long REM Insulated AirCore BA pad all of the time. It insulates down to fifteen degrees and I never experienced any discomfort in fall or summer for it being too warm.

That being said, I'd get the diversion if you're not going to get the lighter Insulated Air Core.

Why not a NeoAir?

Jack

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedSep 11, 2009 at 7:07 am

I've always liked the POE air mattresses better than the BA products myself. Ether Thermo 6 baby!

Jim MacDiarmid BPL Member
PostedSep 11, 2009 at 8:05 am

I'd get the lighter pad. For the 10oz difference, you could bring a torso length Z-lite or similar ccf pad. The Z-lite has an R-value of 2.2. If I remember correctly, while it's not an exact science, you can combine the r-value of two pad together, so close or at 6 for a ccf pad and the BAIAC. And when the ground is cold, (like November is WI) you're going to want to be bringing a sit pad for around camp anyways. Unless you plan on standing until you go to bed.

So for me, the foam pad + the lighter inflatable pad would be the more versatile combo.

PostedSep 11, 2009 at 11:31 am

Really quick though, I use a quilt so I dont know if this will change the minds of anyone. Thanks.

. . BPL Member
PostedSep 11, 2009 at 2:04 pm

R-values fluctuate significantly and should be taken into account with only moderate weight: The results can vary depending on what temperature the test is conducted at, how much pressure is used for inflation (when applicable), and how much and where they are compressed by body-weight, etc.

It is a good idea to have a section of closed cell in addition to your air mattress, in case of field damage and to help protect against such instances. It also provides a more effective barrier against ground source conductive heat loss.

PostedSep 12, 2009 at 4:39 pm

Timothy,

The Diversion is just an Insulated Air Core made from recycled materials. They are heavier than the standard IAC.

The Dual Core is an IAC with an open-cell foam pad glued to the bottom (inside) of it. It is made for winter hiking. They are heavy but do work well. I don't think I would ever carry mine for 3-season use.

Mary D BPL Member
PostedSep 12, 2009 at 5:36 pm

I suggest trying the POE Ether 6 and the Thermarest NeoAir before you decide. Remember that any air mattress pumped up full is like a brick–let enough air out so it's comfortable. I didn't like the BA pads with their thinner tubes (I could never find the sweet spot between soft enough to be comfortable but not having my hip hit the ground). I really love my POE Ether 6 (I have an older version)–it's extremely comfortable for me (with half the air let out, it's just perfect). I'm lukewarm about the NeoAir but I do sleep comfortably on it and do like the lighter weight. On short trips, though, where weight isn't so important, I take my beloved POE pad. Your Mileage May Vary. For late fall use (November in Wisconsin is probably colder than January where I live!) I'd get a 1/4" Thinlight pad from Gossamer Gear to put on top of it.

Whichever pad you get, sleep for several nights on the floor with it at home before you decide if it's a "keeper." 10-15 minutes on it in the store is not enough of a test, IMHO.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...