I have done research on both shelters and have come to the conclusion that both are excellent UL shelters.
The One: 16.2 oz
Sublite: 18.5 oz
Price and weight really are not a factor(Both are already extremely lite) but cumfort is! I am 6'3 and both shelters seem long and wide enough for me with a little extra room for gear. Can anybody who owns one of these shelters please comment on cumfort or storm worthiness when it really counts. Thanks
Topic
GG “The One” or Tarptent “Sublite”
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Hmmm, I'll be interested to hear responses to this. When I was checking out "The One" I concluded that it would be *just* long enough for me (and I'm 6'1"). There's a good picture somewhere in the thread archives of someone (sorry can't remember who right now) lying in The One and they were around 6' tall… wasn't really any extra length once you have a sleeping bag in there.
Anyway, just thought I'd mention it in case you haven't come across the post in your research. I'm sure there must be some tall guys around who have actually used it who can give you some first-hand experience.
I don't own either, but there are major differences in the two.
No offence to GG, but I hate spinnaker.
It is just not good to deal with.
Then again, I have a Tarptent Sqaull and hardly ever use it simply because I want something that is completely sealed.
This is where the one shines.
I would say that if fit was not going to be an issue on the one and you don't mind spinnaker than that should be #1.
Weight does matter to me.
But I would get the Sublite because of the spinnaker.
It's just a tough decision because they both make great
products.
Hi Jay,
I have been using the one for a while now, I am 6ft tall and have not had any issues with length, having the high point in the middle definitely makes it seem roomier, I keep my murmur pack etc inside and there is a fair bit of room in the vestibule as well. For the weight it is an amazing shelter. I made a few improvements I posted in an earlier thread, if you cinch it down it can become really taught. Spinaker works a treat and noise factor is not an issue after a bit of use, I have some old spinaker stuff sacks that are silky smooth with none of the crinkle they had when new.
I'm also looking at both these tents- between the two sublites I think the Sil version will fit my needs better than the tyvek (but then again maybe not???)
Looks like the one has a bit of a vestibule, sublite looks like the gear is coming inside (although looks like it's a little roomier to accommodate that)
probably not a lot of folks (if any?) that have tried both, but I'm having a hard time between the two- of course the Sublite being a $100 cheaper certainly doesn't hurt a thing :)
The One, if only because it has a Vestibule.
I haven't tried the Sublite, but it looks smaller than the One.
I have the One and have used it in the rain. It's very storm-worthy and it does have a nice big area under the vestibule.
To me, they both look equally storm-worthy.
I prefer spinnaker fabric to silnylon. It does not stretch as much after you set it up. It stays tight. I even got to try a tarptent (looked like a cross between a contrail and a squall) that was made of spinnaker. It didn't sag by morning like most tarptents I've observed.
Tough choice. I own both "The One" and the silnylon version of the Sublite.
The Sublite is significantly less expensive.
The One ends up weighing a few ounces more once you add the hardware, etc. (The weight of the Sublite is calculated for the entire package.) The One isn't, or at least it wasn't when I bought mine.
The One has a really nice, roomy vestibule. The Sublite doesn't. That means The One is going to end up with more functional room. However, at 5' 11', I've never had any trouble fitting myself and my stuff into the shelter.
The One is a much tougher pitch (or it is for me, at least — YMMV). Henry Shire works very hard to balance convenience with functionality.
The Sublite feels more stable because of its pyramid style pitch. However, I've never tested them under exactly identical conditions. Neither tent has ever failed me.
The One is, I think, slightly more waterproof, but I've never gotten wet in the Sublite either.
The One's spinnaker cloth really is noisier than the silnylon of the Sublite. However, spinnaker is supposed to soften up and be less noisy with time. (Can't speak for Tyvek.)
Silnylon is tougher than spinnaker. You ought to use a groundcloth with The One. I never use one with the Sublite. Again, can't speak for Tyvek.
Bottom line, I own and use them both, but my go-to tent lately is the Sublite.
Like I said, tough choice. As always, the key is to pick the features you want most.
Somewhat confusedly (sorry),
Stargazer
Aaron,
I am just curious as to why you don't like spinnaker fabric. I bought a used SpinnShelter off this site and have been very pleased with the fabric. I really wish I had the newer gray color instead of the white, but other than that the fabric is great. It is slightly noisy to pack and unpack, but once I have it set up taut, I haven't had any noise issues. Obviously, you have had some different experiences that I would be interested in hearing as I was thinking about some other Spinnaker shelters.
As for the original poster, although I don't have experience with either shelter, I figured I out to throw in my 2 cents from looking at the pictures and descriptions after hijacking your thread.
I like the full ventilation that the One offers with the side that opens up completely, but 84" might be a bit short for someone your size. It really depends on how much vertical space you have at the ends of the bathtub floor before you hit the sloping sides.
The Sublite looks like a good design as well, but not as well vented. It is longer, but looks like its usable leagth may not be any more. What kills this tent for me is the fact that it is Tyvek. I realized this might not be as noisy as the Tyvek I am used to, but the big drawback here is even stated by Tarptent:
"Breathable, water resistant, spunbonded olefin (soft structure Tyvek®) fabric handles even heavy rain of moderate duration. Fine for all night moderate rains but not recommended for long-duration intense rainstorms."
Thomas- thanks for your insight, I really didn't think there would be anyone out there w/ first hand experience w/ both :)
sounds like two very well thought out out designs
easy pitch is a plus, sil being a little tougher a plus as well (of course cost is a plus)
how about the vestibule or lack there of? I'm thinking about going to a shorter pad so my pack might just start coming inside anyways
can you also comment on ventilation comparing the two? condensation?
thanks a bunch!
Mike
Thanks for all the great feedback fellow GearHeads..I am still up in air-some what confused…But I can't go wrong choosing any of these two great shelters..Both are maid by excellent UL Companies..It seems like I am leaning toward the "One" because of the vestibule,length and headroom.
-Jay
Hey Jay,
Since I got my Sublite, in April, I've not had anything but one night of light rain, so no real weather test yet. But… I really like this tent for solo use. I've only had condensation on my first night at Bear Lake, on the BPL trip. None since.
I'm only 5'9" and find the headroom to be more than adequate.
>how about the vestibule or lack there of? I'm thinking about going to a shorter pad so my pack might just start coming inside anyways
I use a short pad (The BPL Thorofare or whatever its called) and generally pull what little stuff I have (base weight 5.5 pounds) inside the tent anyway, using my Alpine Trail BP to extend the pad). Thus, I don't miss the vestibule on The One when I'm using the Sublite. The Sublite has plenty of room at its foot to throw my meager possessions, and plenty of room at the side to put nighttime stuff.
>can you also comment on ventilation comparing the two? condensation?
Henry Shire is the king of ventilation. The One is well ventilated, but I do get some condensation (hard to avoid with single-wall tents). All of Henry's Tarptents (I own four of them, I'm embarrassed to say) have the best-designed ventilation in the business, IMO. (Of course, that can be a weakness for severe winter use.)
Stargazer
P.S. I really do own too many shelters. Just got the Moment in the mail, and i intend to camp with it this weekend.
My take on the Sublite (Tyvek)
Good points
Fast set up . Peg the corners down and insert the poles. No fiddling with length and position of guylines.
Very cool under a hot sun (afternoon nap) and very breathable.
Almost no condensation, so no wet walls .
Lots of ventilation if required. Large bottom vent,360 degree mesh and a mesh door.
Very quiet. It is soft Tyvek (feel the label on your pillow for this…)
Small footprint , including very short guylines.
Room for a pack inside (just)
Not so good
No vestibule
Low waterhead but will take prolonged rainfall provided is not a storm…
Not that suited to exposed (windy) areas. The sil version is on the contrary well suited for this.
I am on a mission here….
Tarptent has a "cutaway dimensions" page for each shelter. Get some masking tape out, some bits of string and replicate the foot print of the shelter as well as the slope of the walls. Then you will know if you fit in or not… (any tent)
Franco
Great Idea Franco about the TT "Cutaway Dimension".
I will give that a try…
I'm very jealous :)
if I end up going w/ a short pad (likely) then the only thing left for the vestibule is my shoes which aren't too large of an item- so maybe a vestibule isn't all that necessary (although cooking in a vestibule might come in handy at times)
leaning sublite
thanks to everyone who has contributed thus far
Franco- good idea :)
Thomas-Which tarptents do you own?
Franco-Same question?
I'm a little embarrassed to admit it, but . . .
Squall 2
Contrail
Sublite Sil
Moment
Each one is good for a specific hiking circumstance or predicted weather condition. Also, Henry Shire is a true tent artist. It's hard to turn down his work.
Truth is, I love them all, but I'm going to have to sell at least one of them to keep peace in my house.
Also, conversation on another thread has convinced me that I need to get a true winter tent like the Scarp . . .
(Hand moves on its own volition toward credit card.)
Help me before I buy again! :vD
Stargazer
I am temporarily down to 12 tents, just one per season.*
My Tarptent collection so far is the Rainbow,Contrail,Sublite and Scarp.
Not sure why HS still bothers with 2/3 person tents…
Franco
* the weather changes a lot here in Melbourne, so better be prepared.
if the sublite sil happens to be one that gets on the list to sell- please let me know :)
Just posted one to Gear Swap
Become a member to post in the forums.

