Topic

Which Watch?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
PostedSep 1, 2009 at 9:46 pm

The functions that I could see being useful for me:
temperature
compass
altimeter
alarms (for interval training)
heart rate monitor

Also, would it be possible to have a watch tell you how much distance you've covered without being a GPS watch?
Thanks!

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedSep 1, 2009 at 11:29 pm

imho:
Temperature – useless – it just approximates my wrist temperature
Compass – useless – severely affected by any tilt, and very power-hungry
Alarms – useless (for me anyhow) – too tiny and inaudible
Heart Rate Monitor – I'm alive, so my heart is still beating. What more do I need to know?

However, the altimeter IS definitely useful.

Cheers

Hendrik Morkel BPL Member
PostedSep 1, 2009 at 11:33 pm

The Suunto Vector is a popular watch here in Scandinavia, at 55 g a lightweight and it has a Barometer, altimeter, a watch and a few other things; its also not to expensive (on offers around 150€). The Suunto X6 is one up from the Vector, with more options, and more expensive.

Gordon Smith BPL Member
PostedSep 2, 2009 at 8:18 am

I’ve owned a Nike Lance 4 for three years now and I love it! Best watch I’ve ever had. It doesn’t have the heart monitor function, but has the other features you listed and they all function very well. For accurate temp you have to remove it from your wrist obviously. Compass works well and has auto shut off so it doesn’t drain batteries. My first battery lasted nearly two years. Compass has to be calibrated occasionally but that’s easy. Altimeter is quite accurate once calibrated and the zero drift works fairly well. Great watch!

G

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedSep 2, 2009 at 9:03 am

I've been really happy with the HighGear altimeter watch I got on SAC for $39.

Mark Verber BPL Member
PostedSep 2, 2009 at 12:36 pm

I am with Roger. temp & compass on multi-functional watches as sub-optimal and reduce in a big watch with a lot of swing weight. I was suggest the lightest, cheapest digital watch for your alarms. I bit of self monitoring will give you a good enough feel for your heart rate. Altimeters can be useful in some conditions.

My solution was not go with a burton adc portable weather station which lives attached to my pack.

–Mark

Brad Rogers BPL Member
PostedSep 2, 2009 at 1:35 pm

I bought a Highgear Alterra? from Steep and Cheap about 2 or 3 years ago. I have been very happy with it for the price.

My watch doesn't have a heart rate monitor so I can't comment on that but here is my two cents on the other functions.

Altimeter – This is my favorite function of this watch. It uses barametric pressure to calculate elevation so as long as no big storms come in it seems to be reasonably accurate. I do try and set it at known elevations every few days, but even then it is usually less than 20-30 feet off, which might not be perfect, but is close enough for me. I like to use it to check my progress on a big climb. For Example on a 3500 foot climb, I may take a break at the half way point and can judge that with a quick glance at my watch.

Thermometer – Roger is right, the thermometer is useless when it is on your arm. You would think that they know when they are designing a watch that it is going to be worn, but obviously not. My thermometer is accurate to within a degree when off of my wrist though, and I always log the nighttime temps on my trips for future reference.

Compass – This is something I hardly use as it is so vague and finicky anyways. Any movement or tilt of the wrist can throw it off. If you just need something to give you a general direction than it should be fine, but don't expect to navigate with it.

Kenneth Knight BPL Member
PostedSep 2, 2009 at 2:24 pm

While I like my St. Moritz VS1 I have to agree with Roger that many of the function you want are of limited value. While I trust the compass to be accurate to the level it can be accurate I'd much rather use my usual baseplate Brunton compass if serious land navigation is required. As Roger noted the temperature function is great for telling you the temperature of your wrist so unless you put the watch someplace else (e.g., it often ends up on my camera bag) that funciton is not that useful either. I'm don't use the alarm. The altimeter can be useful but you can get a far less pricy watch that has that functionality.

Get a watch you want to wear an be happy with that.

Thomas Burns BPL Member
PostedSep 2, 2009 at 2:46 pm

My wife bought it for me for Christmas. If I don't take it along, I'd better hide it well .

The thermometer is a joke. The compass is sort of accurate. I use it to make sure I'm walking in the right direction generally.

The altimeter is very useful. If it matches the number on the topo map, I'm pretty sure I know where I am. Pretty sure.

The baraometer is actually quite useful. It charts its readings. If it's going down, head for shelter, you betcha. Of course, the dark, ominous skies are a somewhat easier indicator to read.

The tide indicator is a hoot, especially in the tideless wilds of Ohio.

It keeps excellent time.

I love it because my wife gave it to me. Otherwise, get a danged compass.

Stargazer

Dale Wambaugh BPL Member
PostedSep 2, 2009 at 8:42 pm

Complicated watches are a nuisance. I have yet to see an electronic compass that is worth trusting with my life, let alone one built into a watch. I opt for a good ol' Timex Ironman that has more than enough bells and whistles for time-keeping, and is cheap, light and accurate.

BPLwiia BPL Member
PostedSep 7, 2009 at 9:01 am

Avocet. I have several watches and it is my favorite. Have had it for years and it is easy to use. The control buttons are particularly user-friendly as they are easily readable, easily found in the dark and have a rubberized top which is great in the rain.

http://www.avocet.com/vertechpages/vertechalpin.html

Rog Tallbloke BPL Member
PostedSep 7, 2009 at 9:07 am

Everything Roger C said except that my altitude is easily discovered from my map.

Timex indiglo. I can read it's nice friendly analogue face without my glasses in the dark by pushing the crown wheel in. The battery seems to last forever, and it tells the time accurately.

Bob Bankhead BPL Member
PostedSep 7, 2009 at 11:19 am

I too have worn an (old original) Avocet Alpine for at least 23 years. Every two years I send it back to the Avocet Service Center in California to have the battery replaced and the altimeter calibrated.

The only functions I find useful are the altimeter and the time.

The temperature function measures the temperature of the case, not the air, so it is useful only when I awake in the morning and see what it says after hanging outside the tent all night. I still have to get out of my warm bed, no matter what it says so on some particularily nasty mornings I prefer to remain ignorant of the actual temperature.

PostedSep 7, 2009 at 11:28 am

Casio Pathfinder solar powered. The altimeter is the most accurate I have ever used. But the best thing about it, is that it is solar powered. I have had mine for 3 years now. It will last 6 months even if it never sees any sun. Mine has always read full power.

I have owned a Sunto and a High Gear. In one case the watch absorbed water after changing the battery and in the other it just quit working after a year and changing the battery didn't help.

Batteries only last about a year in watches with compasses so having solar power is very important in my opinion.

PostedSep 7, 2009 at 12:54 pm

Suunto's always get bad reviews for reliability.

Cassio Sport Protrek:

Ditto for previous comments about solar. Happiness is never having to change a battery.

The altimeter is the most useful feature. It tells me right where I am on the the trail profile.

Temperature: If the watch is exposed on my wrist, subtracting 10 F gives me the approximate temperature. If I need better (rarely) I hang it off a pack strap. I mostly use this function at night in my hammock. I hang it from the ridge line and can get an accurate temperature reading whenever I feel like it.

Compass: I confess that I rarely use this feature but it's been accurate enough for me when I have.

Heartrate: Count your pulse for 6 seconds and multiply by 10. Accurate enough.

Timers and alarm: Good for cooking, waking etc.

PostedSep 7, 2009 at 1:30 pm

My son brought a watch similar to this one on our Muir Trail hike in July

http://www.rei.com/product/775799

its alarm was useful, but the altimeter is a joke. It was constantly 300-500 feet off from what our Garmin 60csx, the map, or signs on passes told us. Even a 30 year old analog altimeter found for peanuts on ebay will outperform these watches.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedSep 7, 2009 at 2:24 pm

Re temperature measurements in a wrist watch:
I think we are stuck with this because they have to have a temperature sensor in the package to compensate for temp variations in the pressure sensor. The volume added is zero because the temp sensor is in the semiconductor pressure sensor anyhow.

re watch size
But the big volume of many digital multi-function watches (and their short battery life in some cases) is almost entirely due to the crossed magnetic sensors: they take up a huge volume. Grumble, grumble …

Cheers

Adrian B BPL Member
PostedSep 7, 2009 at 3:33 pm

I know this thread is about watches, but consider an alternative of an altimeter that you clip onto your pack (or where ever suits). I switched from my Suunto Observer to the Highgear ATF8, because:
– it's lighter
– I don't rip the strap/damage my watch or wrist when I slip and catch the watch on a rock or branch (broke my Suunto strap twice this way)
– can get accurate temperature readings while you hike
– doesn't get covered up when wearing bigger gloves/mitts

Brunton/Silva also make some similar models, although they are a bit more dated than the current highgear ones.

Viewing 18 posts - 1 through 18 (of 18 total)
Loading...