Topic

GPS HELP…PN-40 and Topo 7 or 8 Questions.

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
PostedSep 1, 2009 at 3:17 pm

I was looking for some insight as to the differences between the old topo 7 software and the new popo 8 software.

In particular you can now get the PN 40 for 259 or the PN30 at 199 from REI; however, they are still shipping with the topo 7 software not the new topo 8.

Should i just pick one up now at a discount or is the new software worth the extra money i will have to shell out to get one a better idea?

Also it seems the only difference between the PN 30 and 40 units are the compass and altimiter. is this true?

Thankyou for your thoughts.

PostedSep 1, 2009 at 3:29 pm

I think i am leaning toward the older software and the PN 30. The new software appears not to be a 100$ upgrade in my opinion. And i will always carry a small map and compass too, so the loss of the altimiter and compass are not a fifty dollar upgrade to me either.

So unless you guys can convince me otherwise. Its the PN 30 at REI for under 200$.

PostedSep 1, 2009 at 7:03 pm

I've used Topo products a lot, but their recent migration has me beyond just "disinchanted". Their old mapxchange process was easy to allow topo users to upload and share or download route files from other users. I *think* this might still work, but to do it now I would have to install their new "explorer" product, something clearly designed from a perspective of "extract more $$ from our users on an on-going basis" model. I've started multiple times to do it anyway, but each time I get irritated enough that I don't follow through.

They've taken something that was built as an easy-to-use community for existing users into something more confusing, harder, and now requiring special software.

Despite my having invested in state specific software for three states plus their (buggy) Pocket Topo product, I've decided to switch to try http://www.memory-map.com software. These guys also sell maps, but you don't have to buy them from them … you can just purchase their navigator product and then get USGS maps for free from libremap.org or seamless.usgs.gov in GeoTiff format.

I have as yet no idea whether this will turn out to be a better product or not, but between the Nat. Geo. Topo model change and bugs they told me they would never fix and the cost to buy what are otherwise free USGS maps on a per-state basis — I'm hoping that I'm done with National Geographic Topo products.

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
Loading...