Durability and comfort of Neo Air vs. Big Agnes pads

I am thinking of replacing my beloved BA Insulated Air Core (regular) with a Neo Air (regular). How many of you have gone this route?

My main concerns are comfort and durability. The BAIAC is pretty tough, never failed me. Have people have problems with the Neo Air deflating or puncturing? Will the comfort of the Neo Air measure up to Big Agnes standards (I read it is a bit narrow)?

thanks
David