Topic

Need Shelter Advice!

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
PostedMay 21, 2009 at 12:41 pm

I'm looking for advice on purchasing a shelter. On my first and so far only fastpacking trip I bravely/stupidly took a trimmed down sheet of painters plastic on a 3 night July trip in Yosemite – I was lucky and only had a light sprinkle one night.

Now that I am planning on doing more trips I realize I need something more substantial/safe. I am currently looking into the GoLite Shangri-La 1 (I actually have a credit w/ GoLite) and some version of a tarp. I will only really be out in the summer as I am a teacher and only really in the Sierra. My only other consideration is that while I usually go on pack trips alone, I would love the option of being able to bring my dogs and not leave them out in the cold!

Thank you so much for your help/advice with this essential of all questions!

Jonathan Ryan BPL Member
PostedMay 21, 2009 at 12:53 pm

Unless you know your dog will sleep well under a tarp, I would suggest one of the Tarptent models. While I prefer a simple tarp/bivy combo, when I go out with my dog the only way he will calm down is if he is in an enclosed tent. Guess it goes back to his crate training and needing the comfort of a defined space. That said if your dog is ok under a tarp with you I would just get a simple Oware Flat-tarp. Simple,durable,cheap with many options to pitch.

PostedMay 21, 2009 at 1:09 pm

How big are your dogs? The Shangri-La 1 is an excellent option and more storm proof than a simple tarp, easier to set up, more robust fabric, two huge vents, and tension locks all the way around. Plus it only weighs a pound. The design of it does create a vestibule in the front that is of reasonable size, however your dogs may be too big.

The other option is the moutain laurel designs trailstar that is quite large and offers room for dogs.

Jim MacDiarmid BPL Member
PostedMay 21, 2009 at 1:26 pm

Dog size is definitely a deciding factor.

I have a Tarptent Rainbow which is long so has a good amount of room at the end. Depends where you’re dogs like to sleep whether you need long or wide. Tarptents also offer bug protection. With a tarp, or the Golite, you might want a bivy or bug net too.

Oware makes quality, inexpensive, and light tarps. I have their 2 person Cattarp. If it fits two people, it should fit a couple dogs.

I don’t backpack with dogs, so maybe someone else will answer this, but unless you leash them at night, a tarptent would keep your dogs from wandering off to investigate the bear, or worse skunk that goes sniffing around your food at night.

PostedMay 21, 2009 at 3:43 pm

Jonathan, David and James – Thank you so much for your feedback – you all had good suggestions and brought up good points. I feel silly, but it never occurred to me to leash the dogs to ME at night – I would definitely have to rig up something for that if I were to use a tarp tent as I know they would try to sneak out to guard/investigate. My dogs are somewhat sizable, a tall 60lb collie/pointer and a more dainty 45lb collie/mc nab – so I don't know how well we would squeeze into the Shangri-La – Fortunately the folx at GoLite are good about returns so I can always pitch it on the lawn to see!
Thanks again boys, I really appreciate it!

PostedMay 22, 2009 at 10:25 am

Melisa,

I second the other posters in starting off with a more enclosed shelter. Even dogs accustomed to long days on the trail can act differently in the woods once the sun goes down, and an enclosed shelter tends to be a more comforting presence for them, and by extension you. In my mind, camping with a dog under a tarp, or under the stars, is a bit more "advanced."

The SMD Lunar Duo provides a great deal of room for the weight if you have pups that like to sprawl, and a few extra pieces of closed cell foam for them to sleep on goes a long way towards making them comfortable overnight. Lots of other good threads on these topics on BPL that should show up in a search. Good luck!

James

Brad Groves BPL Member
PostedMay 26, 2009 at 9:50 am

Hey-
I frequently hike with two dogs, one about 90 pounds and one about 75. It's nice to have some extra room with a couple of muddy pups in the tent! I'd consider checking out the Shangri La 2…

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
Loading...