I'm in need of a new solo pack. I was able to try the Exos 46 over the weekend. Loaded with 30lbs, it didn't feel too bad. I can't see carrying that much on my own, but it could if needed. The only gear shop we have that carries GG didn't have a VT in stock. I tried a few other GG packs, but the solid foam backs just didn't seem up to par compared to the Airscape. Any thoughts from users of both?
Topic
Exos vs Vapor Trail
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
For optimum load stability and load transfer (between the shoulders and the hips), you want a pack that carries its weight close to your back. Although Airscape is nice to cool your back, you will be giving up load stability and load transfer to a comparable pack whose back panel is against your back. Having said that, if the Osprey feels comfortable to you …..
I've worn both with 35 pounds for several hours at a stretch. I've found the Exos far more comfortable and effective at weight transfer. The pack is only about an inch from your back. I wouldn't consider the ventilation a crux issue; more important is the support of the pack. Different packs fit different people, um, differently. But the Exos feels a lot better out of those two for me.
I tried out the Exos 46 at home for a week and found it acceptable at 30lbs, which is the most I would ever carry in it. It wouldn't hurt to order a Vapor Trail and try it on. When you figure you don't have to pay tax for most online retail, that balances out the return shipping if you decide not to keep it. Backcountry has both the VT and Exos in stock and are having a 20% off spring sale. coupon code 475-1-65WHR.
I think it's best to actually try on packs side by side because you have to go with the one that fits best, and it's hard to know that without comparing them. I need them both at the same time, as my memory's not so good I can remember exactly how one thing fit compared to another a week apart.
Also try not to get hung up on the upper limit of the pack, unless you will be reaching that often. It's nice to know a pack *could* carry 30lbs, but if that's only going to happen very infrequently, you're better often getting the pack that will be most comfortable at the weight you'll be carrying the most frequently.
Perhaps a Gossamer Gear Gorilla owner could comment as to if it might be another alternative.
Edit: or maybe an ULA Ohm?
I have the Exos 58 (with a fair amount of use to date) and the 34 (with just a bit), but I have not tried the 46. I used a 2004 Vapor Trail quite a bit for two years.
I have had up to 41 lb of winter gear in the Exos 54, it carried it fine. I was very comfortable on two trips with my wife carrying 30+ lb loads in it too. I am not sure of the weights so far in the 34 as it was assorted approach hikes and day hikes in Zion and Red Rocks so it changed daily. Maybe heaviest load around 20 lb. It was comfortable.
The VT was always fine for me up to the high 20s. The couple times I went higher it was very uncomfortable.
I am loving the AirSpeed mesh back vs the AirScape of the Talon series (my old favorites), or the foam back of the VP because of how much cooler and dryer I stay. In Zion two weeks ago my wife had a Talon 11 and I was using the Exos 34. After getting back down from Angels Landing and boarding the shuttle for the next location Jenn’s back was soaked. Even though I am a very hard sweater my shirt was only wet where the hip belt had been.
My brother-in-law is going to borrow my 34 when we take off for a few days at the end of the week to see if he should switch too.
I recently replaced the Vapor Trail pack I'd been using for about 5 years with an Exos 58, with an "it's not you, it's me" rationale.
The last year or so, I'd been noticing that the VT wasn't comfortable above about 20 pounds for me. Above that weight, I had to cinch the waistbelt firmly, and I found that the resulting constriction of my hip movement was causing pain in my right hip and thigh (I suspect it was pinching a nerve); I'm blaming it on advancing age.
I switched to the Exos, and haven't regretted it. The hipbelt is much more pliable, but still provides excellent support. It doesn't cause the hip constriction of the VT, but still provides plenty of support. I also find the rest of the suspension more comfortable, but that's just a bonus.
The downside of the swap was that I also have to use a longer sleeping pad. With the VT, that cushy backpad can be used as a pad extender under your feet and lower legs, letting you get by with a lighter pad. (Thermarest Prolite 4 Short, in my case.) The Exos, with its more dramatic suspension (it's actually an external frame pack, I believe), doesn't serve the pad extender function very well.
There was, however, a silver lining there. The replacement pad was a full-length BA Insulated Air Core pad – thicker and more comfortable than the Thermarest, but only a few ounces more weight. (Downside: harder to inflate.)
I haven't regretted my decision to go for the Exos 58; I don't even have to kick myself for waiting so long to do it, since it just came out a few weeks before I made the switch.
Can anyone comment on how the Bearikade Weekender MKII fits in the Exos 58 and 46?
Can both packs fit the Expedition version, and in what configuration (horizontal/vertical)?
EJ,
I have the Exos 58 and a Weekender fits in it sideways with room to spare. I do not have an Expedition but a BV500 fits sideways in the bottom too.
I think both the VT and the Exos are excellent choices. If the 42 would hold a weekender bear can I would seriously consider it… but the 58 is too large for my summer use.
Weekender fits in the 58 either horizontal at top of vertical without a problem. It can be jammed into the 46 sort of but really deforms the pack… don't do it.
No experience with the expedition.
–mark
Personally I'd go for the EXOS for its great load distribution and overall design quality. Osprey is correct when they state that the energy you save from carrying a few ounces less in a "frameless" pack is more than offset by the energy saved with the comfort of an internal (or in this case, somewhat external) frame.
As for the "unbalance" of having the load too far from yer back W/ the EXOS net "trampoline" style back support? Well, Osprey has moved it close to your back (compared to the original Atmos) so that is no longer even a tiny concern, as your back almost touches the back of the pack in the EXOS. I mean this thing is comfortable – PERIOD.
It still doesn't touch the back though does it? Then assuming one puts the heaviest pieces of gear in the middle of the pack to maximize the centre of gravity, the weight is still not placed optimally.
Glad it is comfortable for you.
Mark, how will the Bearikade Weekender deform the Exos 46? I just checked with Wild Ideas,the Bearikade maker, and found out they also make custom-length Bearikades. That said, the Weekender is 9 in. in diameter and 10.5 in. tall. It seems that would fit, at least vertically, inside the Exos 46, as the 46 is a pretty big pack.
If possible I'd want the outside 90 degree edges of the Weekender rounded, or at last padded with something rounded and soft, to avoid stress on the pack fabric.
For comparison – the Bearikade Scout is 8" tall, Weekender is 10 1/2" tall, Expedition is 14 1/2" tall. Wild ideas also noted lots of 12" and others to 18" tall have been shipped.
Does anyone know if the Weekender will fit vertically or horizontally without stressing the backpad inside the pack? Again, I can pad the edges with something rounded and smooth to prevent pack fabric damage – I just want to make sure the pack fabric or backpad are not super stressed.
Patrick, what did you finally go with?
Raymond, I love the Exos 46, but would have to go with the 58 because I want the ability to accommodate a Bearikade Weekender. The Exos 58 L is supposed to weigh only 3 oz more than the Exos 46 L. My one question – can you compress the Exos 58 enough to comfortably use it for long day hikes without the pack contents shifting around?
Thanks again for the very helpful feedback.
The Exos 58 compresses just fine for day trips…and I agree with the otheres that it is just plain comfortable-end of story! You can also trim a lot of excess weight off the Exos by removing lots of un-needed straps, replacing the drawcord with some Spectra and smaller cordlock, and leaving the top pocket at home.
Thanks Lynn, very helpful. I figured it would compress enough, and we already loved the load distribution and "air conditioning" of the Exos 46. Reading early reports of the 58 being so enormous led us to the 46, but the 58 is a better size for our uses. The Exos 58 has the added benefit of being large enough for us for short winter trips, though I could see situations where we'd want an even larger 4500 cu in. pack.
Which straps did you trim?
I might take a photo this evening to show all the stuff I managed to remove. I think the Exos 58 is a lot larger than the "58" leads you to believe. First of all, I have a size large which is actually a 61 litre pack…as mentioned earlier, the "58" only refers to the main pack body, and doesn't include any of the pockets. So it's really closer to 70 litres (or more???) all up…and then there are all those straps which allows even more load carrying capacity for winter trips.
Nimbus Ozone
"Nimbus Ozone" hands down???
" I tried a few other GG packs, but the solid foam backs just didn't seem up to par compared to the Airscape."
Agreed. The Exos 58 is the only pack I've ever loaded up to 35kg and had the pack itself still feel comfortable. The Granite Gear suspension is nice up to a point, but not 30+kg, and the ventilation and extra pockets of the Exos is superb. But everyone is built differently, and maybe the GG fits some better than others. If in doubt, buy/borrow/beg both and return the loser!
FYI, we have an Exos 58 (size L=61 litres nominal volume) and a GG Nimbus Meridian (supposedly 60L). The Exos 58 is MUCH bigger than the Meridian. Think of it as a Meridian with extra large top pocket, huge hipbelt pockets and a kangaroo pocket (plus those other funny pockets). Makes organising you gear a breeze….
I briefly had an Exos 58 – it was really uncomfortable for me at 25 pounds. The hipbelt is abysmal. My old Ozone carries much better for me. Not sure why you say that the Exos is MUCH bigger. Because it isn't.
Lynn, if you were carrying that much in an Exos, you are over double the recommended maximum weight load. You must have a strong back.
There are post on this very forum that talks about how uncomfortable the pack is so it obviously fits some and others not.
I should add that the Ozone is completely customizable which is ideal for 100% of the population. The Osprey requires one to 'fit' into their sizing parameters. Not always ideal (i.e. I have a 19.5" torso, a 33" waist but a 47.5" chest measurement).
Lol, I'm assuming Lynn means 35 pounds rather than 35kg. If not, she really needs to rethink her gearlist ;-)
What's 2.2lbs between friends….
Ahh, that's the trap when trying to convert back and forth to empirial units :( We tested it at 16kg/35lbs (the recommended max from the manufacturer).
Three out of three women that have trialled our Exos and Meridian agree that the Exos is more comfy, so maybe it's a chick thang! As for volume, the Exos swallows our gear…all of it every time. The Meridian always has stuff hanging on the outside because it's smaller. I can't see how THAT could be a subject of disagreement. I feel a photo shoot coming on ;)
"There are post on this very forum that talks about how uncomfortable the pack is so it obviously fits some and others not."
True, but they haven't tended to add their comments in the gear review section. Fit is very important….if the Exos is too short in the torso then it would be dismal. That's why I recommended getting both packs and trying them on to judge if they are right for the OP.
Become a member to post in the forums.

