Topic

A case for smartphones on the trail.


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums Gear Forums Multiple Use Gear A case for smartphones on the trail.

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 20 posts - 51 through 70 (of 70 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1555383
    Miguel Arboleda
    BPL Member

    @butuki

    Locale: Kanto Plain, Japan

    Try using Star Walk. I have Starmap Pro also, but one thing that makes Star Walk incredible is its ability to follow the sky dome as you point the iPhone in any direction, including at your feet to view the stars on the other side of the planet. And while you scan the sky with the iPhone Star Walk will highlight and then name and diagram the constellation you are looking at.

    #1555416
    Thomas Graham
    Member

    @tomasito

    Thanks for the recommendations for apps.

    I love my iPhone, and the access to (mostly) useless apps in a million flavors is awesome (no sarcasm – I really like some of least useful apps). I'm an early enough adopter that I still have one of the first apps written sitting on my phone which was pre-AppStore.

    I am not a fan of phones, smart or otherwise, on the trail.

    From the perspective of aesthetics, non-emergency phone use doesn't sit well with me.

    I sometimes carry one anyway on the theory that it might conceivably have some utility in an emergency situation, but, if I am honest with myself, it's really because I don't want to leave it in my car. I consider it to have low odds of actually being helpful in an emergency, because of its battery life and its non-ruggedness.

    The iPhone to me seems particularly ill-conceived for the wilderness, primarily because of its battery life, which I'd have to characterize as 'pathetic'. I certainly do not wish to get into a gear cascade (phone, charger, backup charger, spare battery, etc.) to support it.

    Having said that, if I am lucky enough to be out skiing or climbing out of someone's remote and electrified cabin, I'd love to use it to stargaze from the lawn. Thanks for the recommendations.

    #1555579
    Paul Elliott
    Member

    @paulelliott

    Thomas,
    The iPhone does have rotten battery life, but since I turn mine off between uses, it's not as bad as you might think. I was over 100 miles from the closest cell signal, so the phone portion was useless. The other features I was able to use for many days without needing to charge the phone.

    I do however have a Solio charger with me. I take a DSLR camera, so having a charger that could charge the phone and the DSLR battery worked out better than trying to have enough extra batteries to give me power for what I wanted.

    I've found the iPhone to be surprisingly rugged. It's obviously not as rugged as a dedicated outdoor GPS, but it has survived some nasty drops for me.

    I'm not suggesting that a smartphone is for everyone, and clearly some printed paper topo maps and a pen to write on the back of them could serve in place of what I used a smartphone for. But it would not have been as quick and convenient or useful as the smartphone was.

    I think it's better to look at these devices for all they do that isn't a phone. Leave the sim chip in the car or turn off the phone capability. For wilderness purposes, they should not be treated as a phone, but rather a potential replacement for a GPS, topo maps, compass, pen, etc.

    If it's a philosophical thing where you won't be able to relax on the trail if you have any electronic gear, then a smartphone of any kind is probably the worst thing to consider. My viewpoint is that smartphones, or more accurately pocket computers, may be more applicable to wilderness applications than most people realize and deserve a fair evaluation.

    #1555699
    Thomas Graham
    Member

    @tomasito

    Yeah, I do the same.

    When I have carried the phone with me, I have typically planned my usage in advance while it is off. I then turn it on, use whatever I need or wish to use (one example lately has been txts and photos) and then immediately turn it off and stow it again.

    Even so I am underwhelmed by its battery life.

    Don't get me wrong – I am an iPhone fan, and in fact I am a fan to such a degree that most people I speak to about it probably add the extra syllables (to make fan-atic).

    I just haven't found it that useful on trails, or that reliably connected beyond day hikes in relatively non-wild environments.

    #1563983
    Michael Meiser
    Member

    @mmeiser

    Locale: Michigan

    First of all, thanks for the post Jesse/tacedeous!

    Second, I'd never heard of this Garmin XT before. Sounds like it uses the MiniSD slot. I wonder how it compares to some of the excellent GPS apps out there in the last eight months since you posted. Would love to here more!

    Third, My primary reason for contemplating carrying a smart phone:

    == CONVERGING DEVICES INTO ONE ==

    I've been contemplating getting an Android phone for a couple months now. I've skipped the iPhone because it's a locked down POS… primarily this is because ATT coverage is abhorent in my kneck of the woods, but also Apple's nanny-like approval process for all apps.

    The reasons I'm planning on doing this are simple.

    Mostly it turns four separate devices into one.

    1) replaces my camera for video and photo (I carry this everywhere)

    2) obviously it's a phone (I carry it everywhere purely for safety's sake, but it remains off)

    3) no need to carry a GPS (up till now I've simply refused to carry one)

    4) iPod (I've stopped carrying one in the last year because I felt it to high maintenance, though I do miss it on occasion. It's good for raising spirits on those rare occasions when you get in a funk)

    So, at it's most basic a smart phone replaces two key devices with one. If you count those I have neglected to carry because I despise the clutter then four.

    == HOW I PLAN TO USE IT ON THE TRAIL ==

    First of all, I should explain. I don't just hike. Mostly I bike tour. I'm planning on combining the two this summer to section hike some trails. Maybe / hopefully even some parts of the AT or possibly a larger section of the North County Trail.

    Basically that works like this: I have the base weight for ultralight road bike touring setup below 30lbs. This includes gear AND bike. (picture: http://www.flickr.com/photos/mmeiser2/4245474921/ ) With a harness this should allow me to hike with it on my back simply by removing the wheels. Thus this should give me unlimited freedom to explore hiking trails without having to drive or circle back to a parked car. (More Freedom!)

    Admitedly this approach is a paradigm shifter. It's impossible to know how well it'll work and just what the advantages are until I've tried it extensively. However, if you choose to you could think of this approach as a great way to scout sections of trail for a future thru-hike. Isn't that what all section hiking is. ;)

    So, without any further adieu my somewhat prioritized reasons for carrying a smart phone.

    1) web, web, web… There are an infinite number of reasons why I might end up accessing the web but the best example is the simple ability to google the nearest grocery store or gas station (or bike shop) should I have an issue or a need to resupply.

    This is integral to my approach.

    I don't care for food drops when bike touring, don't need them, and when bike/hiking I shouldn't need to carry more then a few days food when potentially at any road crossing I have quick access to resupply. Hence I can go lighter then most backpackers to compensate for the 19lbs of bike weight. Thus the equation shifts from not how much do I have to carry but simply a matter of how long would I like to avoid civilization.

    2) taking photos and video (and posting them straight to the web)

    3) GPS tracking, mapping, route following. This as opposed to google maps… I distinguish between the two because I can use GPS maps when offline.

    4) blogging / micro-blogging (twittering) / journals… I find it's best to say it with video or photos rather then do to much typing.

    5) music… plus audiobooks and podcasts

    6) phone… mostly it's simply for emergencies

    So, that should be it

    – Mike
    http://www.flickr.com/groups/ultralightbiking/
    http://mmeiser.com/blog

    #1563988
    Michael Meiser
    Member

    @mmeiser

    Locale: Michigan

    Jesse Helmick (tacedeous):

    "and another function i forgot is the stylus is magnetized on one end for some reason, so if i float that on a leaf, I have a compass too…"

    Isn't there a built in/ software compas as well? :)

    So what you're saying is even if the battery dies it still has a functional compas? I can dig that. Especially since I always read about people who get lost or otherwise in emergency situations because they've relied on a GPS. At the very least I carry a tiny little ball compass.

    Also, you forgot to list paper weight… and I bet it skips really well across a pond too. :)

    Jesse Helmick (tacedeous):

    "The more I carry, the more I love to camp, The less I carry the more I love to hike"

    That's pretty brilliant. I'm alsays trying to explain the ultralight thing to people and I'll add this to key ways to explain it.

    Some other favorites are:

    "It's like going out for a sunday stroll and not having to come back for days or weeks at a time."

    and

    "It's not about going faster. It's about having the energy to take that side trip up that next mountain."

    #1564000
    Michael Meiser
    Member

    @mmeiser

    Locale: Michigan

    So… this post was started with a Smart phone running Microsoft's cell phone OS.

    However that was almost a year ago. The market has changed a heck of a lot since then. The open source cell phone operating system cool started called Android has gone from being a relative newbie to some 22% market share. It seems to be picking up tremendous steam and has started to get really polished as well.

    Best off all you can get Android phones through just about every major carrier which means we can all potentially get one, which means that this isn't irrelevant to anyone not on ATT (i.e. stupid iPhone).

    I've been trying to do some research to find out what is available for Android phones and was wondering what others had used and found.

    This might be worthy of it's own thread, but I don't want to thread spam so I'll wait until I have a bit more to share.

    == GPS backpacking use scenarios ==

    1) Tracking

    Google's "my tracks" application is a default application that seems absolutely perfect for recording your route as well as time, speed, distance, and elevation.

    http://mytracks.appspot.com/

    What's more you can use it to easily import that data into a google spreadsheat, share your routes and/or data via google and from there export it to all sorts of route sharing, mapping tools and serices via standards like KML and GPX.

    2) Turn-by-turn:

    i.e. might be great in an adventure race type scenario

    I've yet to find any apps or documentation on turn by turn apps that

    a) upload a route to your phone via GPX or KML (though I'm sure it's quite common)

    b) precache all the necissary maps along the trail (because obviously you're not likely to have cellular access on the trail)

    3) Spot checking

    I figure most of the time (and maybe most people) would just like to have their maps on their smartphone so they can doulble check it if they need to.

    4) Compass:

    Most Android phones do have a built in compas… though obviously it'd be only a matter of convienience, because quite frankly you should always carry a real compass.

    5) elevation?

    Most Android phones can now get elevation data, though I'm not sure if it's through altimiters or merely pulling that data from google. (If it's the later it wouldn't be to useful because you'd have to be on network)

    6) Thermometer?

    Not sure how many Android phones have built in thermometers yet.

    So! What other specialized GPS related features might one need?

    #1564006
    Michael Meiser
    Member

    @mmeiser

    Locale: Michigan

    Chad Miller (chadnsc) said:

    "Camera – 4.1 oz."

    You're just made me miss my JamCam!

    My first digital camera I picked it up on a lark for $9 to take on a canoeing trip. Only shot 800×600 photos which had a certain "quality" to them, but was nearly indestructable. I miss the beautiful simplicity of it.

    Perhaps I should go buy a tiny P.O.S. camera and ditch my really expensive, complex, high maintence (battery sucking) and heavy (1.5lbs) ditial one.

    All this is to say that… I do have reservations about carrying a smart phone on the trail. But they are not technical ones like weight. They are purely aesthetic ones.

    I just don't like technological distractions on the trail.

    Mostly I solve this inherent contradiction by leaving my current phone off and in the absolute bottom of my pack with other "emergency only" gear.

    However I if I get a smart phone with camera and intend to use that camera regularly it will be harder to "escape" the temptations and distractions of modern society which the phone is so obviously a symbol of.

    Even if I can turn off the cellular features it's still a complex piece of technology that has to be constantly navigated (to use the camera features), and maintained (batteries).

    This is why I stopped carrying an iPod after all. I got sick of carrying around the ear buds and an external battery pack that took four AA.

    It wasn't even so much the weight… it was just "clutter".

    Indeed I must admit I'm currently even sick of buying and carrying extra batteries for my camera.

    I'm sick of wondering how many spare batteries I'll need to carry.

    I'm sick of worrying about charging batteries.

    I'm sick of finding large grocery stores to avoid paying ridiculous amounts of money for batteries at grocery stores.

    So, In fact… I think I will, as an experiment, go buy a keychain camera and try shooting only with that.

    Funny that, I came here doing research on using smart phones (and I will get one) but have come away thinking about going less high tech.

    P.S. The truth is resolution and fidelity are way over rated anyway. When it comes to memories pictures are mere symbols and triggers of memories about where we've been and what we've done. The best of it all lies in our own minds and the stories written and told. In that sense the fidelity argument is a bunch of bunk.

    #1564031
    Michael Meiser
    Member

    @mmeiser

    Locale: Michigan

    @Nate Meinzer (Rezniem):

    First of all thanks for posting, I've learned a great deal about the state of GPS apps for smart phones from this thread.

    iTopo sounds like a great app.

    Just being able to download whole areas of USGS topo maps is superemely useful.

    However, though you can put in waypoints I don't see any way to download (i.e. GPX file to phone) or plot a compete trail on it.

    I guess this is ok if the trail is actually already on the map, but quite frankly 99% of the trails I follow are not.

    Are there any GPS apps out there for the iPhone that do this?

    #1564033
    Michael Meiser
    Member

    @mmeiser

    Locale: Michigan

    @Miguel D Arboleda (butuki)

    great list. I can count a few of these I might use including the knot guide, tracks, and potentially trees.

    Speaking of trees are there any great apps for identifying edible trees / plants / bugs / mushrooms? That I might find useful.

    #1564598
    bj bretzke
    Member

    @lilorphanbilly

    Locale: Montana, MT (Stealth Mode)

    Picked this up when I got home:
    Man Buried in Rubble Uses iPhone to Treat Wounds, Survive.
    http://www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2010/01/haitian-survivor-iphone/

    We had a thread about best gear ever a while back on G-Spot and my cell phone was near the top of list. As a solo hiker I would be foolish not to carry the extra ounce or so. I have found very few mountain tops that there wasn't at least one or two bars. It is one of the few things I would rather carry and not use than to leave it behind and need it. Besides, the games come in handy when you're tent bound on storm day number two. I am an older guy. The only time I turn it on is when I use it. I don't want anybody getting a hold of me. It is kind of cool when you haven't talked to a human in two or three weeks and you know you can talk to family and let them know where you are.

    BJ

    sorry about the broken link.

    #1568471
    jeremy duncan
    Member

    @jeremyduncan

    Locale: Midwest

    I wonder if Crocodile Dundee thinks a compass or watch is a waste of weight, because he can tell the time/direction by the position of the sun/stars?

    I'd think the weight of a cell phone is pretty easy to justify on the trail no matter what else it does. For safety.

    My cellphone (not a smartphone) has a pretty nifty gps feature on it. I use that more for driving than on the trail. Since it's already on my cellphone, it's a nice to know it's there "just in case". Can never guarantee it's going to work or be accurate, so I never leave my map or compass at home. Except for when I'm hiking with Dundee, of course.

    I try to forget I even have it, though, when I am on the trail. Unless I really need it, of course.

    #1859708
    Sam McElrath
    Member

    @actionmagnet

    In the past I would have thought leave the smart phone home when you hit the trail. However, now with apps that can link photos with the GPS location that the photo was taken… I say that is pack item number 1. This is an awesome idea for water proofing a smart phone.
    =========================
    Deleted commercial promotion.
    Sam: please do not use BPL channels for promoting your web site.
    Roger Caffin (on instructions from Ryan Jordon)
    Online Community Monitor
    Backpacking Light

    #1859752
    Nick Gatel
    BPL Member

    @ngatel

    Locale: Southern California

    "I say that is pack item number 1."

    Mine stays in the car. Have your members get maps and figure out where to go on their own.

    :)

    #1860179
    Bradley Danyluk
    BPL Member

    @dasbin

    There are a couple really good toughphones / waterproof smartphones on the market. I use the Motorola Defy (an Android phone). It's very light, too, because the case is tough plastic, no metal.

    #1860181
    EndoftheTrail
    BPL Member

    @ben2world-2

    Roger — Ryan's surname is spelled Jordan.

    As for the smartphone… don't own one. Maybe someday…

    #1860301
    Justin Baker
    BPL Member

    @justin_baker

    Locale: Santa Rosa, CA

    There is no way I am leaving a $600 dollar portable device in my vehicle at any trailhead. Mostly because I would have no way to replace such a thing right now, and it's very important to me outside of the woods. It always goes in my pack for that reason.

    #1861259
    Robert Kelly
    BPL Member

    @qiwiz

    Locale: UL gear @ QiWiz.net

    GPS, MP3 player, maps, books, guides (flora, fauna, etc), camera, altimeter, weather radio, and more.
    And you can even make calls with it if you get a signal.

    BTW, I just got a LifeProof case for my iPhone (I have no financial interest) – Waterproof to six feet under, and you can even use the camera under water. Guess what – works great in the rain too. Now I'm ready for just about anything the trail can throw my way.

    #1863882
    Huzefa @ Blue Bolt Gear
    Spectator

    @huzefa

    Locale: Himalayas

    I have used iPhone 4 and I am currently using iPad 2. I am thinking of selling both and get Galaxy Note.

    #1922631
    Joseph Castine
    Member

    @momoandmavis

    Interesting discussion and i guess I'll start it again. Back in 1999 i was amazed one day in a campground in Utah to hear a TV – TV camping, wt*! Then from 2005 to 2010 my wife and i plus two cats full timed in a 17 ft Casita trailer. We eventually got satelite- i mean we lived in our camping vehicle, often volunteering as campground hosts. Now i am planning to hike the ADT – 10 months or so with my tent as my home, in fact my only home. i am planning on bringing a good gps and a tablet computer, maybe a NEXUS 7 (i hear a new 32 mb will be out this month) and a prepaid cellphone for a few contact family calls and emergency calls (my Mom is 85. So, phone is for one thing, gps too, but tablet is for email (when wifi is around), journaling (on trailjournals.com), reading some maps and journals of those who have gone before me, reading books when tentbound, etc. i was also thinking of a Droid 4., but then i would have to pay maybe $100/month data-phone service fee and that keyboard is so small. So what do you all think? You can see my "wants" any different recommendations for my devices? My journal is at momoandmavis at trail journals.

Viewing 20 posts - 51 through 70 (of 70 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...