Topic

Shangri-La 3 vs Luxe Minipeak II

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 45 total)
PostedJan 15, 2009 at 4:44 am

Having been obsessively trawling the forums and reviews on here (and having weighed up the pro's and cons of various kit and my own needs)- my word what a process – I seem to have narrowed down my choices (for now) of my next shelter. I have been very impressed with the Hex3 / Shangri-la 3 BUT find the inner nest too heavy – If only Golite did a half nest to allow cooking in the resulting vestibule, hey ho. Anyway, I need a contained space whilst sleeping so that my Jack Russell Terrier cannot run after any night time scent that seeps into the tent and so some kind of contained nest is important. I like the pyramid / tipi designs and their shedding capabilities although I have considered the TT rainbow and SMD lunar solo e but worry about their use in the U.K. The thing is I just discovered (on the other side of the world) a tent called the Luxe Minipeak 2 which seems to meet ALL of my requirements (pyramid style, ample space with vestibule, and light at 1.3 Kg (about 45 Oz which compares very favourably with the weight of the Shangri-la 3 with nest which is about 76 oz. The thing is I have never heard of this company and can find no reviews. Does anybody on here have any knowledge or feedback about this tent? The tent can be seen here: http://www.equipoutdoors.co.nz/index1.html

Many thanks, Clifford.

Joe Clement BPL Member
PostedJan 15, 2009 at 6:54 am

Never heard of the Luxe, but I think you'd be the perfect beta tester for us. I really don't understand GoLite. I'd love to have a nest for my Shangri-La 3, but the weight is just shocking. I'm think about building my own screened floor, that clips in where the nest clips in, and only goes up 1 foot. Until then it's just a tyvek floor. I'm thinking about buying one of those travel mosquito nets for beds, and cutting it off to fit the 3.

Fred eric BPL Member
PostedJan 15, 2009 at 7:56 am

I am also very interested by the shangri la 3, they are 2 things that have kept me yet from buying one.
– the usable space, is it truly enough for 2 and i hope 2,5 …, or should i get a slighty bigger shelter.
– the resistance to winds, i have read contradictory reports about it, majority seems to say its good though.
and what it would be if i bought a bigger alternative ( oware or MLD pyramid or even a shangri la 4)

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 11:22 am

Fred: The weights indicated on hikelight.com.au seem to include the bug nest and floor although I can't be certain. Also it has a lower profile than the Hex 3 / shangri-la and utilises a 140cm trekking pole (which is ample height for me)and ultimately easier than carrying the included pole of the Shangri-la as I use trekking poles. That extra tarp looks interesting but only if you have 2 minipeaks together. My understanding with the Hex 3 is that it is an ideal shelter for 2 or 3 if it is suspended. Useable space is meant to be good but maybe (in my case) a little too big for solo use with a small terrier.

Joe: I have also considered multiple ways of getting around the inner nest problem but really can't be a***d to attempt what might be a botched job with my limited sewing skills. On one of the U.K web sites they do offer a half floor for the Shangri-la….if only someone would offer a half nest much like the Oware Alpha Mid but made from netting and a tub floor!

David: I also saw that post and looked at the SMD Serentiy Net tent in combo with the Shangri – La and that is a solution BUT (and it is a big 'BUT' in the current economic climate) the combined cost would be $345.00 excluding shipping compared to $110.00 of the Luxe Mini Peak which includes floor and bug nest!

At that price maybe I simply need to take a risk without any real knowledge of the product?

Are there not any Auzzie's or Kiwi's out there who are familiar with this shelter?

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 1:16 pm

The lifespan might not be so good Clifford. The fly is PU coated polyester rather than sil-nylon.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedJan 15, 2009 at 1:20 pm

Hi Clifford

> Luxe Minipeak 2 ….. The tent can be seen here: http://www.equipoutdoors.co.nz/index1.html

Yeah, well, the reason you don't get much response is that the web site is a bit of a tourist/novice/car camping shop, specialising in Chinese rip-offs. Have a look at the Outer Limits Fantail stove and see if you can guess which brand-name stove it is cloned from. And how about the OZtrail Ensuite Pop Up tent???

The reality is probably that the shop has contacted various Chinese companies which do make the brand-name gear and asked them to spin off some cheaper brand-X versions for them. OK, quite legal, but you takes your chances with the quality.

Cheers

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 3:37 pm

Hi Clifford
I was involved in the upgrade from the Mini Peak to the Mini Peak 2. Essentially I borrowed the original version and after some fiddling in my backyard I sent my report to Luxe and the designer there modified the shelter accordingly. My mods had nothing to do with any other shelters, were based on simply what made sense to me.
Keep in mind that the focus at Luxe is value for money and the main market is China . So the shelter will accommodate comfortably a person up to 178 cm (70") . Positioning the inner sideways (not perpendicular to the side wall) will allow another few centimeters but that is the limit of the inner.
Keep in mind that the inner is a largish bug bivvy but not a standard mesh inner.
Just for the record , the main reason the shelter came about is because Michael Wong, the Luxe designer, was interested in having a shelter for cycle touring. During those discussions I decided to have a go at the Mini Peak and later on the Speedup came about.
Luxe do have several shelters that somehow look like other shelters, the same applies to pretty much every other tent manufacturer.
BTW I have no financial interest in this, I just do it as a hobby.
Franco

Mini Peak 2 weightHi

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 3:54 pm

Really Mike? What makes you say that? My Mountain Hardwear Solitude is PU Ripstop Polyester and it's still going strong after more than 5 years. My TNF Mountain 25 has a fly made also from….you guessed it, 75D ripstop polyester, the same as the Mini Peak II.

Thanks Roger!

You raise an interesting point. It's true that TNF,Marmot,MSR, Vaude, Lightwave, Big Agnes, Mountain Hardwear and even Golite are all manufactured in China – to which I have no objection except it does then cause me to question price points and profit margins of the big names when the Mini peak is so cheap (I acknowledge my possibly misguided cynicism ;-)

Luxe is a Chinese brand that is simply sold in Australia / New Zealand and throughout Asia. The Asian market is, as we know, very different to the U.S / European market but does that necessarily reflect on the quality of the Luxe brand just because it is significantly cheaper I wonder?

It seems that equipoutdoors (no matter who their target market is)is simply one of many suppliers of the Luxe brand. Hikelight.com.au in Melbourne also stock Luxe products – as do a whole host of other outlets throughout Asia.

This is why I would love to hear from somebody who has actually used the gear. I mean 75D ripstop polyester is 75D ripstop polyester no matter what name is on it. Likewise, the pyramid design could not be simpler (I used to use a single pole and a sheet as a small child in the garden) – it is a tried and tested design that works. Under these circumstances what do we refer to when we talk about quality? The stitching, the cutting, the quality of the guys?

I don't know, but maybe (only maybe) we resist these products due to some degree of label snobbery?

I actually found a review which I translated from the Chinese and although the google translater threw up something quite amusing I could see that the Chinese reviewer was impressed.

I'm still on the fence!

BTW from searching the forums i see that Franco Darioli has had some experience of Luxe products! maybe Franco could comment on the quality / craftmanship issue?

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 4:08 pm

How funny – you posted Franco just before me! Thanks for the info. It really helps and inspires confidence. Having seen some of Michael Wong's youtube input the tents seem to be well made and well tested.

BTW i'm a diminutive 5"9 which is more or less 178cm. It is actually the mesh bivvy inner that I like as it allows the rest of the tent to act as a safe (ish) space for preparing food. Also the contained mesh bivvy inner allows my dog to be secure when I'm sleeping. Furthermore the arrangement of the Minipeak is ultimately a more appropriate alternative for solo use than the Golite with the SMD Serenity net – it seems to me. I also like the double zippered entries (great idea).

So, it seems that for me this might well be a viable alternative to the Golite. Would you mind Franco just commenting on the quality of the workmanship?

many many thanks.

CW BPL Member
PostedJan 15, 2009 at 4:09 pm

The only thing I noticed is this is a 3 season product where the GoLite is a 4 season.

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedJan 15, 2009 at 4:13 pm

> cause me to question price points and profit margins of the big names when the Mini peak is so cheap
You aren't the only one to ask this. The mark-up in Australian retail gear shops used to be about 66%; it is now 100% over USA retail. I priced some new skis here recently: about $2,000 for what we wanted, but that was for the 2006 models. I imported the 2009 models from an American web outlet for about half that price, including freight.
Clicks vs Bricks: a battle in progress.

> Luxe is a Chinese brand …. but does that necessarily reflect on the quality of the
> Luxe brand just because it is significantly cheaper I wonder?
I have been reviewing some sample Chinese tents recently. They looked good, rather like some well-known brands. But close inspection showed all sorts of defects which would not have been permitted by any good designer. Ground anchor points held by one short line of stitching; the throw-over fly did not sit on the pole properly; inadequate guy rope anchors; weird ground anchor systems, and so on.

It seemed to me that while the Chinese manufacturers were trying quite hard, they had very little technical understanding of what they were doing. Once they left the detailed design and instructions supplied by a Western designer and went out on their own, they were lost. Or so it seemed from the samples I inspected.

It may be that in time they will learn the why of the designs as well as the how of the manufacture. When that happens life may become very interesting. I look forward to it in fact. In the meantime one needs to be extremely careful, and do a detailed inspection in the hand.

Cheers

All the above stands, but to be fair I should add that the wholesale price for the 2-man fly-plus-netting-inner tent was US$85.
Blimey – makes you realise that the Chinese are working very hard for their money, while some Western 'gear companies' are raking in the cream from the Chinese sweat.

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 4:26 pm

Correct me if i'm wrong Clifford, but doesn't sil-nylon have a better UV resistance than PU coated polyester?

And it's very heavy. A similar set-up from the likes of MLD would be half the weight. My Hex 3 and MLD Bug Bivvy is around 300g lighter for twice the space.

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 5:35 pm

First "Made in China" means absolutely nothing at all quality wise.
I happen to have a Bibler and a BD made in China, the finish is top notch but I would not have bought them if I had to pay retail.
It's not a secret that I use Tarptents, there must be a reason why I have several other shelter from different brands that I never use in the bush.
So a Luxe Mini Peak is not to be compared with say the Hex ( and yes I do know that one…) nevertheless in China they are about a third (or less) of the price of the Hex.
Materials and finish could be compared with, say, something like the Eureka or non technical Sierra Design. So not state of the art but nevertheless functional.
Maybe the fact that Michael Wong and his mates take off several times a year for remote areas ,including glaciers and wind swept deserts , to test the Luxe tents is a testimony to what these shelters can do. In fact only a few weeks ago Michael returned from one such trip, that most would only do with a 4 season tent , that exposed him to all sorts of weather conditions including temperatures well below zero(Celsius). The shelter he was testing was the new Oasis , a freestanding design that will be marketed as "three season". ( video clip under "new tent for 2009" at Luxe) . The Oasis is the result of some comments I made about the Hurricane.
Franco
Clifford : on a standard 1" mat you will be alright but your face will be close to the net .

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 6:54 pm

Yes Mike, it is – although the PU Poly is more breathable which may be preferable in a single skin shelter?

When all is said and done , like many on here, I have multiple shelters for multiple uses. I would be the first to admit that the shangri-la 3 with the MLD serenity option gives a great 4 season shelter with bags of space. At 1.33Kg (with supplied Golite pole)it weighs the same as the Minipeak (1.345 Kg according to Franco's scales) with floor so i wouldn't say that it was very heavy. There is also the option of leaving the floor behind which would make it lighter than the 1.3 Kg (I'm waiting for hikelite to confirm the weights of the seperate components).

It seems that the minipeak though can offer something that the Golite, Oware, MLD mids can't which is an opportunity to try a new (for me) design at very low cost. I have always had double skin geodesic domes and tunnels and if I decide that I'm not keen on the single skin Mid design then I would have a lesser gripe as my investment would not have been that significant. If i am however completely bowled over by single skin mids then i can always fine tune my shelter at a later date.

Chris: yes it is 3 season – fine for me as i'm no longer a winter camper.

As Franco says, the minipeak should not be compared to the Shangri-La / Hex but I'm still thinking that you get an awful lot for your $110.00 and that gives me a nice warm feeling inside!

PostedJan 15, 2009 at 11:48 pm

Hi Clifford,

I bought a Luxe MP2 a month or two ago after asking Franco about it (thanks Franco). I bought mine as a cheap way to try a pyramid tent setup.

Reinforcing Franco's comments, the inner is definately a bug bivy but you can hang it off the hiking pole so that it doesn't hang on your face and body. I use a Pacific Outdoor Equipment Ether compact full length and resting on it fully inflated, the mesh doesn't touch my face but the mesh does usually rest on my feet.

It's important to pitch out the sides to gain more space and make it more of a hexagon than a square shape. I also like the fact that you can open both doors wide open and let the air flow through the tent, which is great for the hot and humid environment I hike in. The inner could also be used with a poncho tarp or similar like a normal bug bivy.

On the negative side it is heavier than a hex3 and probably bulkier I'd imagine. I can't comment on durability or quality as I've not tested it out in the field yet but I haven't noticed any particular defects. I'm not sure if the mesh inner is no-see-um mesh though.

My weights are 955g for the Fly in a S2S compression sac and 350g for the mesh inner. I'll be testing it out next weekend and I'll report back how it goes.

Michael

[edited] Reread your first post and just wanted to add you won't be able to comfortably fit both yourself and a dog in the mesh inner.

PostedJan 16, 2009 at 12:45 am

Clifford
I completely forgot about your dog, sorry about that.
Here are a couple of shots that should give you an idea of the interior space. As you can see the inner takes up half of the shelter so there is plenty of space for your JRT there but not inside the inner. You may notice that in these shots I did not use the mid tie out, but as Michael commented , pulling the mid guyline out does increase the inner space but also was incorporated to make it a bit more wind worthy. ( more than anything else I prefer, esthetically, the hexagonal shape)
Maybe a ground sheet ( helps minimising condensation) and a long peg for the leash on the dog will help (?)
Franco

Hi Michael
Thank you for your comments.
MP2 inner
MP2 inner 2Clifford

PostedJan 16, 2009 at 12:55 am

Hi Clifford.
Yes the Hex 3 pole is heavy. Like almost everyone else on here, i use trekking poles instead. Being bigger, there is less chance of touching the sides in the steeper sided Hex 3. It might be harder to avoid them in a smaller, lower pyramid? Just something to think about with a wet dog maybe?

PostedJan 16, 2009 at 3:46 am

Thanks for posting Michael. My motivation is similar to yours and I'd love to hear your feedback after your next trip. The weight, for me, is relative as the minipeak will be bliss after the TNF Mountain 25 (about 9 Lb)or even the Mountain Hardwear Solitude which is 2Kg (4 Lb 8oz). Going ultra lite is a process that takes time – I may eventually be happy with a Gossamer Gear ponch/tarp but not yet!

Franco, the images really help so thanks very much. My JRT sleeps in my bag behind my knees or by my shoulder – she is a smaller short-legged Jack so does not take up much room. I'm sure she could happily squeeze in and in warm weather just curl up by my feet (I would have the same issue with the SMD or MLD versions in the Golite).

I don't want to put you out Franco but what are the actual measurements of the tub floor of the 'bivvy net'?

Thanks again.

PostedJan 16, 2009 at 6:17 am

just a little input on this:
Roger – i really dont think the fact that some of the chinese gear isnt up to par has to do with knowhow or ability. With 1.5B people i wouldnt be surprised if there were more PhD's in China than people in Autralia (:)….
I feel it has to do more with targeting, positioning and QA:
some of the better known chinese brands (like Shehe http://translate.google.com/translate?sourceid=navclient&hl=en&u=http%3a%2f%2fwww%2eshehe%2ecom%2ecn%2f who makes gear for Marmot) actually do top notch gear for US based brands and have and have a pretty decent own brand name gear (they make gear for everst summiting teams and such)
i was slightly involved in the fashion industry myself and know that there is a great deal of effort and resources into quality assurance and control. It might just be that all the items we are seeing now from china (Fenix, Zebralight, Shehe, Luxe, kovea) were initially positioned for their local market, and as such might have a different price/performance target than say Marmot has (even though as i said Shehe manufactures marmot)
i think what is happening is because of the web and "fedex" some chinese entrepreneurs take local brands global through websites (since its so easy – no need for costly floor space in your mall in the US only a URL, Paypal checkout and some SEO/SEM) so maybe we are getting exposed to some gear that was not designed with western quality target in mind.

Mike

PostedJan 16, 2009 at 3:02 pm

After a day of watching my decision process and fielding each rationale with a critical eye I have decided to purchase the Golite Shangri-La 3. The space to weight ratio did it and also the postage costs of the Minipeak from Australia to the U.k. I have to say that the British weather also played a large part in my decision and the proven ability of the Shangri-La to withstand it.

I spoke to Golite about the possibility of a half nest for solo use in the future and they said:

"This might be happening in 2010 and it is something our design team has definitely been looking at."

We'll see. In the meantime I now have the bug issue to resolve. SMD, MLD, Integral designs, or home made?

Backpackinglight.co.uk are offering a free half hex floor (310g) when you purchase the Shangri-la 3 which is a good deal.

So, no more rainbows, no more lunar solo's, no more alphamid's – thats it. Shangri-la 3!

PostedJan 16, 2009 at 3:12 pm

Just in case anybody else is interested, the floor of the Mini Peak 2 is 220 cm long (86") and 75 cm wide (29")
Franco
Sorry, no pegs in that bag. Add 6g for 6x TN pegs
(that is a joke)

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 45 total)
Loading...