I'm looking for a new pack and think I have it narrowed down to either the Gregory Z55 or the Deuter 60+10. Does anyone have any insight into these packs or recommendations? I want this pack primarily for 3-4 day four season trips.
Topic
Gregory Z55 vs. Deuter 60+10 ?
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Christopher,
I have the Z55 and I love this pack!
At 3 lbs and 3 oz, I am not sure that it is UL, but if you have to carry a load for any length of time, this is my go to pack.
I have carried 36 lbs over 70 miles and 4 day in 2007 to Mt. Whitney on the High Sierra Trail with this pack and it felt great the whole way.
I was well vented on my back and after a while, I really did not notice that I was wearing a pack at all.
Backpacker Mag said that it was the most comfortable pack in any class that they tested.
The only drawbacks, other than weight, is that if you carry a large bear vault, the size can be an issue for getting all of your gear in there.
The curvature of the frame sheet at the lumbar area cuts into the storage space inside the main compartment.
I have found that the storage compartments on the top and front are very useful and easily accessed.
Like any pack, the more the main compartment is stuffed, the hardered it is to access the things you have inside the front pocket.
There are two mesh stoarge pouches that are on the left and right sides, which I find are useful for putting my water bottle and snacks.
The hip belt pouch is great for my pocket camera, pen knife, watch, and chapstick.
Technically, it is listed as a weekend pack, but if you have compact gear, it can easily be used for a week trip with a bear vault.
I have since gone to a Jam2/frameless pack, but for anything over 25 lbs of weight, the Z55 is my go to bag.
Hope that this helps.
-Tony
I also love my Z55. As I've slowly replaced my gear with smaller and lighter stuff my old Mountainsmith with about 6000 cubic inches was feeling a little excessive. I've been using the Z55 for a couple of years for all my trips and love it. It's light enough and so comfortable I sometimes use it as a day pack. The longest trip I had it on was 5 days and carried a bear canister and thought it was perfect. I've been working on a quilt and a bivy to replace my tent / sleeping bag, so maybe this pack will be too much if I start using those. But even then I would still use the Z55 if I have to carry a bear canister. The bear canister was slightly annoying to deal with. I tried it horizontally in the bottom and vertically in the middle of my back, but I've found the best place to be horizontally under the top pocket. I think my favorite things about it are the vented back, light weight and fits great. If I had to complain, the top pocket is kinda small and I can't get my water bladder back into it's pocket if the pack is full and I pulled it out to refill it. If I had to buy a pack right now the only other one I would consider is the Atmos 50.
All that being said if you are a size large, I have a Z55 I could sell you. I got the large, only to find out I'm a medium, so it's been used once. $100 shipped.
I have tried both packs and the Gregory Z55 suffers from the same nearly non-existent garter-belt waist belt design that most lightweight packs suffer from. This is unfortunate since it adds very little weight to make a more rigid and supportive waist belt if the designer adds a sheet of thermoplastic and/or stiff high density foam outer to the softer foam inner belt. The Deuter waist belt does this and is more comfortable, supportive, puts more weight on the hips, and makes the pack more stable. As I have read in another review, the Deuter pack belt is supportive enough to be used as a weight lifting or back therapy belt. Loading the 2 packs to 30lbs. made the choice easy for me.
I think the larger version, the Z65, has a redesigned hip belt that is larger and much stiffer.
I looked at the same bags and decided in the end to just shell out a few more dolalrs and get the Exos 58… It fit my long torso length so much better, is lighter and can handle all I need to handle
I have the Z55 and love the way it carries, especially loads over 25lbs. Very comfortable and wouldn't want any stiffer hip belt.
With small loads I take off the top pocket to drop a few more ounces.
The Z65 has a well designed belt and is comparable to the Deuter 60+10 (actually, Aircontact Lite 65+10) in pack size, weight and back support. I happened to try the 2009 Z55 yesterday and -viola- the belt has been changed. It is solid foam, not punched with holes like the 2008 I had tried before. It may compare favorably with a similar sized Deuter pack (but I have to drive to Lake Tahoe to demo Deuter packs as they are not carried by local stores. Oh well.)
Although not a full hard core ultra light backpack, it looks like a fairly good light weight bag.
All the best,
Doug
Become a member to post in the forums.

