nm
Topic
Tarptent Sublite Silnylon Now Available
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
im going to be critical here: what is the big deal with silnylon? there are many other guys making shelters with much more modern and lighter fabrics, that have obvious benefits over sil. so why is Henry possibly the only guy who is not doing anything new? does this seem like a hinderance to you guys? it does to me…
Im just thinking… "hey look here, I made a new tent out of silnylon!"
well, big deal. Cuben has been out for years. Get with the program, man.
like I said, critical.
Michael,
I will play the devils advocate and defend Henry/Tarptent. Yes there are sexier fabrics that can be used but when one takes into account the performance to cost ratio silnylon is still a very viable material. Looking at other manufacturers shelters being offered an identical product made from cuben is three times the cost of silnylon. Tarptent is smart IMHO, in these tough econmic times, to stick with their proven and affordable lineup. Having said this I'm more then willing to pay the higher cost of spinnaker or cuben materials in the shelters I now own.
And Henry is venturing out in to new materials with his tyvek Sublite. Henry, keep up the good work.
It's in stock!
Spinnaker Contrail FTW!
To each his own wallet…
I'm all for new and advanced fabrics and certainly for saving weight wherever possible but I just don't buy the value proposition of Cuben fiber. For a shelter like the Sublite, Cuben offers perhaps a 4-ounce weight savings at a price increase of $100. That, to me, is a complete waste of money. 4 ounces is a sip of water and I defy anyone to tell the difference in a loaded pack. Then there's the inherent fragility/abrasion issues with Cuben–I certainly could not warranty a Cuben shelter. FYI – The Sublite in Spinnaker would be less than 2 ounces lighter with a price increase of about $50.
I'm just not wired that way and I don't think most backpackers are either but, for those that are, you have several Cuben shelters from which to choose. I will jump ship from silnylon into a new fabric when/if one arrives that offers a better value proposition. I'm certainly all ears until then.
-H
Henry, there are major differences between Spinn and sil, please do offer a Spinn tarptent. A $50 difference is nothing when compared to a shelter that doesnt sag, need re-tensioning – and yes, 4oz is a tremendous weight savings. An ounce here, and ounce there and you save pounds. There are hundreds of ULers who would pay $100 for a .5 lb savings. Easily.
no, I wouldnt pay $500 for a cuben sublite, but Id pay $400 for a Cuben Refuge X. and there you have it.
What about the performance increase of spinnaker over silnylon. Talking not from experience with spinnaker but from what i've heard/read, there is a significant increase in the material's resistance to sagging due to moisture or time when pitched.
That seems like that could be an advantage to tents like the Contrail or Squall. Long areas of fabric with preset tension. Just my thoughts. What do you think Henry?
looks like i took too long to write that post. nice mike!
"4 ounces is a sip of water and I defy anyone to tell the difference in a loaded pack."
THANK YOU for saying that. You've echoed what I've always thought when looking at the weights of some of these cuben fiber shelters. Why people worry about the decision to pay hundreds of dollars more for something that is only marginally lighter and significantly less durable is completely beyond me.
"Mike, you make your own tarps and sell them on this site among others. Based on your response I ask you to design the next great cuben UL shelter and present it to us for critique"
i dont feel it is my duty to provide the burden of proof. what i make or dont make is not the issue, im not a major player. i dont even make tarps anymore. I have moved on to more important projects. I did design a completely free standing sil tent, single wall, with about a 20oz weight. It just takes a complete overhaul of my workshop so I gave up on the idea. Plus, Jacks R Better needs some competition. :)
what my bee-atch is, TarpTent has the ability to increase it's sales by offering the far more superior Spinnaker nylon (to be fair, lets not include Cuben, just yet)
If Henry suggests that a mere $50 increase would prevent a user from having to fiddle with sagging and (possibly) pooling water, then yeah man, I think thats a smart idea.
I also dont feel its fair to point out the current state of our economic woes, since spinnaker predates this occurence by years.
"What I want" (without sounding like a spoiled child, because Im neither)
A Spinnaker TarpTent Rainbow, do away with the 15' pole sleeve and use clips such as found on Sierra Designs tents and others. Id easily pay $300 for that, almost half of a typical car payment.
Ron Moak and Ron Bell both offer marvelous designs, and with high-tech fabrics.
Now, onto cuben and the argument over cost: a buch of the cuben users just want to show off their gear. oh well. a bunch just want the lightest thing possible, and something that sheds water better than anything else. I can argue that a bunch of folks are right in their decision to spend hundreds more (not likely the case, but ok) to save 4 ounces. When you are doing SUB 5, 4 ounces is critical. It may not matter to the average guy with a 22lb pack.
> yes, 4oz is a tremendous weight savings. An ounce here, and ounce there and you save pounds.
I think an ounce here and an ounce there is still a few ounces if you do your best to bring down the weight of all your other items at the same time.
> There are hundreds of ULers who would pay $100 for a .5 lb savings. Easily.
4 ounces is 1/4 pound, not 1/2 pound.
> no, I wouldnt pay $500 for a cuben sublite, but Id pay $400 for a Cuben Refuge X. and there you have it.
Then run over to SMD and buy one. The Cuben Refuge X is an appealing shelter, if you have the cash.
Ok, I'll say it: I'm just not a UL/Extreme UL advocate at the top end of the curve when $/ounce ratios get really high. Some are and that's fine but my focus is lightweight and reasonably affordable. Call me conservative if you want.
Now I'll shut up…
> There are hundreds of ULers who would pay $100 for a .5 lb savings. Easily.
i noticed that too… there are still some who would pay to reduce by 1/4 lb.
The thing is, I like some of your shelters. I would like some of your shelters to be 'more hassle free' is all.
i'll shut up too. now get crackin on that spinn rainbow :) lol
(provided there is no current spinnaker shortage)
"…in thier decision to spend hundreds more (not likely the case, but OK)"
MLD Duomid in silnylon $165.00
MLD Duomid in spectralite (cuben) $345.00
This equates to spending $180.00 to save 5 oz and gain any performance benefit offered by the alternate material.
The GG The One is NOT IN STOCK!
The economic times are going to get rougher to. Just how many folks are actually buying these spinnaker and cuben products? Probably not many now, and you won't be able to "give them away" in another year.
Well as a recent college grad now employed as an engineer at a small firm for the past 6 months, I would say I plan on purchasing several items in the next few months. Spinnaker tarp, the new GG adjustable poles, a new pack, maybe a serenity shelter from MLD, the list is endless.
There still are people that have jobs and no responsibilities (per say) :)
Keep em coming!!!!!! *nudge* Spin Contrail *nudge*
"There still are people that have jobs and no responsibilities."
We need to raise payroll / social security taxes! Mwahahaha…
I have to say I think you're right on mark, Henry. I think there are other mfg. out there that fill the niche for high price, impressive spec. shelters. I'm a poncho-tarper myself, but I was looking at your website after the first post in this thread was put up and thinking how reasonable the price/weight of the Sublite was.
Reading this thread re-fired my thoughts on this shelter. Owning both a Contrail and a Rainbow I thought I'd go for the Sil Sublite now… and just ordered it. Will it replace my MLD Spectralite tarp for SUL hikes? Only occasionally, but I think that there are many times/seasons and types of hikes that a 21oz TarpTent will be perfect. At the sale price of $159.20 I couldn't resist.
"We need to raise payroll / social security taxes! Mwahahaha…"
You're gonna get your wish! But you can sleep in your new shelter.
Being a person that lives on 1k a month or less there would be now way in h-e-double-hockey-sticks that I would buy a tent that costs $500 or even $300. I want my gear to be light but I don't want to have to keep buying a piece every year or every other year just to have the lightest gear. I am sure a pound or two could be shaved off of my pack weight but is saves me so much more cost year to year to just hike with that extra pound or two.
I always wanted to buy a tent from Henry but had to instead get a used Contrail because of what I could afford at the time. I like it and think it is just above that comfort level line for durability. If the silnylon he uses is much more durable than the cuben, I don't even want to touch cuber.
"MLD Duomid in silnylon $165.00
MLD Duomid in spectralite (cuben) $345.00
This equates to spending $180.00 to save 5 oz"
My god what have I done!
For some reason I was up at 4 AM and noticed this thread. At first I had the impression that Mike misunderstood the Family Guy 's intent, pointing out that there is now an alternative to the Tivek version rather than beign exited about silnylon.
As usual it is hard to keep everybody happy but (IMHO) as much as to a few (and I really think that is in tens not hundreds…) saving 2 or 4 oz is a big deal, to most it's hard to justify. Having spent 30 years in retailing I am used to customers getting very upset about why what they want is not made , but having access to some of the product managers the answer most of the time was simply "not viable"
Now if Henry was making a few shelters in his spare time it would be a different situation altogether, but I think that we already know what happens when you have too many orders to handle in house and not enough for a production line
Back to the Sublite Sil version…..
The Family Guy has already mentioned the entry flap (rain curtain) but another important addition, that I can see, is the separate "zippered mesh door" , nice in a buggy environment.
Just when I though that I was really happy with the Contrail
Franco
Yeah, the Sil Sublite is looking really awesome to me right now! From the design of having the 2 poles in the middle of the shelter, the Sublite should be able to handle higher winds than the Contrail. Another feature not mentioned that looks cool (can't tell how functional it is) is the ability to create a rain-flap/mini-porch with the door. Could be useful in rainy/humid/non-windy conditions. I also like the price (especially w/ the 20% off!).
Since this would be my first non-tent shelter purchase, I am still not exactly sure what my shelter needs are yet. This looks like a perfect piece of gear for transitioning into UL. I was considering a tarp, but I don't feel like I have the experience for that yet. Also, from my research it appears that many college outdoor clubs/programs severely frown upon the use of tarps (I am a HS senior). You should see the recommended gear lists for some of these colleges. They are actually really funny!
Franco, I hope you didnt take my opinion in a serious fashion, after all im not trying to take wind out of anyone's sails. If a guy is excited about the sil version, and has been anticipating this event for some time thats great!
I was trying to imply that there are some of us (well, me) who like TarpTent, and think its unfortunate that Spinnaker is not an option for any of the designs. It surely should be. (not to include the GG squall)
cmon, say you wouldnt do a backflip for a Spinn Contrail.. hehe
* i know 10 people that consider 4oz to be considerable, just in Arizona alone. So, by the reasoning (or lack of!) I assume its in the hundreds. maybe it isnt..
Become a member to post in the forums.

