Topic

“Light winter” down jackets

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
PostedOct 31, 2008 at 5:10 pm

Montbell Alpine jacket – 16oz, $136 online
Nunatak Kobuk – 20oz for size L, $469
Feathered Friends – 22oz spec on website (is this for their lightest fabric, though, or is it for the Epic shell version? will need to call) $285

These are the jacket's I'm currently looking at. I'm in need of a new down jacket this winter, but am not sure if I know all the comparable models that fit my criteria. My criteria are: the jacket must have boxed-baffle construction, the general weight guideline is approximately 20 ounces or less, and the jacket needs a full-length separating front zipper and handwarmer pockets. I'm not going to consider jackets that are outside of these criteria unless the jacket is really warmer than any of those in the short list above.

I'll be using it mostly for in-camp wear, and while sleeping (though not specifically to augment a sleep system). I'll mostly be using it in the lower Midwest, in places such as Missouri, Tennessee, and Arkansas, which have comparably mild winters. I'd expect evening and morning temperatures in the 20s and upper teens on most trips (which is mainly when I'd be wearing it outside of my sleeping bag). I have used a number of down jackets with sewn-thru baffle construction in the 10-14 ounce range, but I found that the zero-loft lines between the baffles made them not warm enough for me in these conditions.

Bottom line is, the above list seems too short. Does anybody know of any other down jackets that fit my criteria?

Steven Nelson BPL Member
PostedOct 31, 2008 at 6:12 pm

Take a look at the Western Mountaineering Meltdown as well (17 ounces; though it's sewn through it has quite a bit of loft, plus a stowable hood and I've found mine quite warm).

PostedOct 31, 2008 at 6:31 pm

That's going to be a tough sell, since it's an ounce heavier than the MB Alpine. Do you think the Meltdown is warmer than the Alpine, in spite of the sewn thru baffles? Is the hood insulated, or is it just a windproof single layer of fabric?

Steven Nelson BPL Member
PostedOct 31, 2008 at 7:52 pm

The hood is insulated; I can't compare it to the Montbell jacket because I've never seen that one, but the Meltdown has 850 fill power down, so has good loft for that weight. It's definitely pricier, though.

Brett Peugh BPL Member
PostedOct 31, 2008 at 7:52 pm

I have not been let down by the Montbell Alpine and it has similar specs to the rest and for that price you can't do better

PostedOct 31, 2008 at 10:04 pm

The Meltdown is seriously puffy- so much so that you might have issues wearing one inside a sleeping bag… is that thing really 17 ounces?

Personally, I need a hood on my winter parka, but if that is not an issue for you than I would get the Montbell just on price alone. However, be aware that the FF Volant has 3 ounces more of down with a more windproof fabric and so will be warmer.

If you really are willing to spend the money for Nunatuk, also look at PHD as they have a Yukon and Hispar jacket that might fit your requirements.

PostedOct 31, 2008 at 11:11 pm

I'm not really willing to spend the money for the Nunatak considering that I could literally get 3 MB Alpines and have money left over for the price of one Kobuk jacket. Kind of sad really…Nunatak seem to have priced themselves right out of the market. The jacket having a hood is a non-issue simply because I have a homemade Climashield hood that I hope to pair with whatever down jacket I buy. I'm going to inquire about the Volant weight in a different fabric. 22 ounces is heavy to me, although I really do like FF gear. I own one of their Icefall parkas with the eVENT shell, but it's way too heavy and bulky for the mild winters I see in the lower Midwest.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Loading...