For years, I used the Nike Air Orizaba because it was a good combination of my three most important criteria: good traction, good cushioning, and good stability (low profile). I also liked that it drained water really well and was light-weight. But Nike has given up on the adventure shoe category, and I have struggled to find a good replacement. I would like to hear your thoughts.
I will use the shoe primarily for fast mountain hiking and running in Alaska (pack weight ranging from zero up to 25 lbs). This means tundra running, rock scrambling, mud bogging, and bushwhacking, as well as some on-trail use.
I tried a pair or Salomon XA Pros for a while, and really liked the stability, but the traction was poor on wet tundra and mud. When I got sick of slipping and falling on my ass, I bought the most aggressive-soled shoe I could find – the Inov-8 Mudclaw 330-O. These shoes were great, except that the cushioning was non-existent and the huge lugs began to break off after a few uses. I also tried on the Inov-8 Roclite 295, but it felt sloppy – a different last than the 330-O.
Is it possible to find a good adventure shoe that has very good traction, good cushioning and decent stability? What do you recommend?

