NM
Topic
Montbell Diamond or Crescent 1
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
I owned a Montbell Diamond and bought an Atko. There is no comparison in my view. Atko offers much more useable space. I would not go back to the Diamond
I don't have the tent in front of me, but I'll try to measure it when I get a chance. My guess is you wouldn't touch the ends in a long bag, but because the sides become so narrow near the ends, a long bag would probably touch the sides at either end.
Hi David,
Art is indeed right on this. I have one long size synthetic bag that I sometimes use with the Diamond. The foot does touch the sides. It's not an issue with synthetic but could be one with down on nights when the condensation gods strike.
Hi David! Keep in mind that most Montbell products are designed for Japanese, not for taller Americans. For instance, the recommended max height for their sleeping bags is 5'10". I'm 5'11" and get by. So by extension, If you're much taller than that then you will crowd the narrow ends, but again, I get by. On the other hand, I do appreciate the width and heigth: there's enough room for my gear and to sit up, so I'm keeping it!
Looks like a nice, tight design that will deflect the wind well.
Hi David! Keep in mind that most Montbell products are designed for Japanese, not for taller Americans.
Thing is, the Crescent is not sold in Japan, only in the States.
David, when I was in Boulder over the weekend I had a chance to look at the Crescent 1, which was set up in the Montbell store. I can't say that I was overly impressed with it. The dimensions are the same as the Diamond but the foot half of the tent is mostly non-breathable single wall construction. There is a mesh vent at the rear point but I think that in certain conditions the rear half of the tent would be coated in condensation. This isn't a big deal with tarptents because there is plenty of room inside to avoid brushing up against the wet walls. The Crescent 1 is small enough that contacting the moisture would be inevitable for most people.
That's a shame. I wouldn't use any tent — esp. single wall — that doesn't provide enough sq. footage to keep my bag away from the walls all around.
Just stumbled onto this website after googling the crescent 1. Great resource! I know I'm digging up an old post here, but if anyone has any tips for a true: "Capacity: 1 person (2 in emergencies)" (taken from Mont-bell USA's description of the Crescent 1). I'm 5'11" & want something I can use alone in a wide range of weather, or with my better-half on fair weather excursions.
Thanks much!
According to Moontrail the Crescent 1 is 118" long, 53" wide and 39" high.
So this is what I do…
At 5' 7" I can fit under it sitting on a thick mat with about 2" to spare, but that of course is dead in the center.
This kind of plan will not give you the definitive answer but should give you a pretty good idea.
The mat is 70" long and 22" wide (not fully inflated)
Franco

http://www.moontrail.com/mont-bell-crescent-1.php
Nicely done, Franco. Your photo does give a good idea of the space in a Montbell Diamond or Crescent 1.
I'm 5'11" & want something I can use alone in a wide range of weather, or with my better-half on fair weather excursions.
Cole, based on your intended use, I'd pass on the Crescent 1. Two people in this tent wouldn't be comfortable at all.
But Franco, that's only half the story. You also have to factor in the very narrow ends that slant inwards, reducing the usable space at the ends.
Art
That is the first test, if the tent passes that the 3 D test follows…
Something like this …

Did this one a few months before the Brooke Range Rocket came out..
Franco
Become a member to post in the forums.

