Topic

Caldera cone as windscreen

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
PostedMay 22, 2008 at 3:15 am

A comment from Allison made me think of a wind screen that I came up with sometime ago. It was made out of the skin of three soda cans wrapped around the pot , protruding a couple inches below its base. Worked really well but only at the lowest setting, IE good economy but slow. So I thought of using the Caldera cone that way. Have not tested if it does save any fuel compared to the traditional wind screen but I think that it will. Last night experimenting on my bench top gas stove , I worked out that on a low and medium setting ( using the smallest burner) I get the same boil time with my 550 ml pot as I do with the wider 900 ml pot. When the flame (on high) creeps up the sides of the smaller pot the larger boils faster, about 25% in my test.
In other words if the flame is narrower than the pot, I think that you end up using about the same amount of gas.
I used the same principle with this set up.
Two ways of using it,
1) wrapped around the pot , use a low to medium setting with that.
2) traditional way, using two pegs (or a few stones) to keep it close and in shape. By varying the distance to the pot you can have a slow (and likely economical ) burn , or as fast as the stove allows.
Warning : don't join the cone, keep a good gap to let some heat escape. (or you may blow up the canister)
With either you need to do the touch test. If you can keep your hand on the canister (the top of it) it is safe .
Why would I use this rather than a foldable version ?
Because the TiTri version allows for the occasional use of wood and I think by reflecting some heat to the canister maybe it can be used in below freezing temperatures (?)
Must stress common sense for this one…..
FrancoCaldera cone screen 1
Caldera cone screen 2

Roger Caffin BPL Member
PostedMay 22, 2008 at 4:14 am

Hi Franco

In fact, your lower photo is not much different from using an ordinary windsheild wrapped 3/4 around the pot and stove.

What does this mean? Hum … well, it just seems a reasonable idea to me, anyhow. I like the use of pegs to hold the windshield in place of course.

PostedMay 22, 2008 at 4:49 pm

Hi Roger
Yes, nothing new in the bottom pic, just a suggestion for the ones that occasionally would or could use wood, saves carrying two stoves.
At the same time, often windscreens are too short, possibly losing too much heat. In reality I have it a bit tighter but also a couple of inches off the ground (using sticks or stones) , to allow some air circulation at the bottom and more protection/heat retention at the top. I just had "safety" in mind. I never use my stove past about half power. I can wait for an extra couple of minutes.
My previous screens have been shorter or heavier or too fragile and usually fiddly in the wind.
Mind you, I mostly use alcohol now anyway.
Franco

PostedMay 22, 2008 at 5:32 pm

I have used a similar set-up combining a cone with a BushBuddy. We were only car camping, but the wind was horrendous and the BB is not happy in high winds. Having the cone around the pot like your photos was enough to protect the flames at the top of the stove (but not the bottom), and allowed the feeding of more wood without too much difficulty. Worked just fine.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
Loading...