I have been happy with the tempest without liners between 0-20F. Above 20F my hands start to get sweaty, and my hands overheat when it’s 35F or warmer. I have never used them with liners. When I have faces below 0F temps I have either been alpine skiing or climbing. Skiing I tend to wear a slightly a warmer glove (typically w/ primaloft insulation) and climbing I was something that has better grip and more durable.
In cool weather (say 20-40F) I have been very happy with Pearl Izumi Encore Gloves. I haven’t tried them with liners yet.
I should note that my hands tend to run a bit warmer than some peoples, so your comfort range might be somewhat different.
I wish OR would bring back the unlined rain mittens. The combo of rain mittens and a base layer glove coverage a huge range of conditions with comfort.
–Mark