This design intrigued me, so I borrowed one from the local importers, (the retail site is http://www.hikelight.com.au/) , to have a close look at it.
It comes in a package 19.5" long (the length of the pole segments) and 4" wide (less than 3" when squeezed as it would be in your pack). My scale is not working but the stated weight , 1lb 10oz, seems correct.
Having seen a picture of it …. I did not bother with the instructions (later I discovered that it was a good decision as there is nothing much there) and proceeded to set it up. From start to finish it took me just under three minutes. Not rushing and discovering as I was putting it up that it has an asymmetrical design , it's a parallelogram, I expected the same diamond shape as the Akto
Then I fiddled, discovering the two way zipper, that of course allows a gap at the top as well as the bottom (if desired) . That gap at the top will be your only chance to get rid of some condensation as there are no vents at all.
BTW, I am confident that the next time I could set it up in less than 2 minutes.
The max height I could get was 41", but I had a better shape at 39". I set it as low as 32" , this would work for 1 person only but it would protect from any wind . At the standard setting it is nice and taut I would expect a very minimal amount of flapping. BTW it does stand up with just two pegs.
First impression.
Good spacious, easy and quick to set up, great weather protection.
Bad : possible condensation problems. Not likely to handle any snow.
( please keep in mind that this is not a review, just a first impression)
Franco


Topic
ID Sil Dome pics
Become a member to post in the forums.
- This topic is empty.
Hi Franco,
I've been intrigued by this design ever since I first saw it. Your photos really make it seem a lot more interesting. It's sort of like a Hilleberg Akto without the inner, isn't it? But more versatile. Another one to consider.
Thanks!
nm
Franco: Does Henry Shires know you're cheating on him with an ID design? (The fact that you borrowed, rather than bought, doesn't really help.) :)
Of course, you know I'm only kidding.
Have you ever looked at ID's other offering, the SilShelter? It's substantially lighter (about 15 – 18 ounces, depending on the number and type of stakes you use) than the Sildome (26 ounces according to the website.) Anyhow, if you have seen or used the Silshelter, how would the Sildome compare? Is it worth the extra weight?
And then the obvious question: How would it stack up against any of the TarpTents you've used? I'm pretty sure it would be as heavy or heavier than most, by the time you added a groundcloth; any bug netting would also add weight. What about your thoughts on performance?
Finally, any thoughts on how it would do as part of a tarp/bivy system? I'm thinking weight would pretty much kill it off for solo use, especially if you used any of ID's bivies. But, for two people, the weight-per-person compares favorably with the Silshelter, which can't hold two people comfortably (newlyweds excepted.)
Anyhow, thanks for taking the time to check it out – the pictures were great.
First I have corrected a couple of mistakes from my original comments. Like others I could not work out how you can fit two people in there. I made a mock up using the expected diamond shape and that proved to be too narrow.
The really clever part of the design is having the two ends offset so that it creates a wider area inside.
To make this a bit clearer I set the shelter up again . This time in 1 min and 50 seconds ( the pole end slipped from the grommet, so I had to go around to it again, a 90 sec pitch is achievable but the world record is at 140 sec for the moment…). I took this shot standing on top of a ladder and using my walking pole plus Ultrapod Francopod ( available anywhere at no extra charge, if you have a stick and an Ultrapod….)
Clever design, isn't it ?
I have used two pegs only for this shot.
BTW, not for me because most of the time I have too many biting insects around. I had a look at the ID Buga Bivy (16 oz) very nice, but by putting the two together it is about the same as the Rainbow. Could be a good solution for the ones that occasionally hike in pairs.
Franco



This last shot is to show what happens when the pitch is too low..
nm
No, you don't want one of these. Simply because it is much bigger and lighter than the Akto and that it stands up with only two pegs, it does not mean that you should have one.
Franco
The MLD Bug Bivy looks more practical for less than 2 oz more…
Thanks Franco.
I notice that you have used the longer Easton pegs in your second set up, but the sildome is provided with the shorter (blue) Easton pegs. It seems that the longer pegs may provide more ventilation around the base of the shelter.
I think the big question though is condensation, is it manageable? and the answer to that question will be; it depends on … many different issues including configuration used, weather at the time of use, number of people sleeping in the sildome.
Longer Easton pegs.
That is because I suffer from ALS (Acute Laziness Syndrome) , I could not be bothered to add a guyline to it. The longer Easton is in fact attached to another peg increasing the holding power by 63.5%, or more accurately avoiding attaching a guyline…
I think that attaching a vent at the apex should be relatively easy (that excludes me …) but I am a little puzzled at why (considering the "down to earth" design) it is not there already.
Franco
A picture for the ones that cannot visualise the MLD BB attached to the single internal hook
Warning: that is a bug bivy not THE Bug Bivy
What is the length of the sleeping area like? I'm 6'6", so need a minimum of about 7' usable internal length, which very few ultralight shelters have.
Would I still be able to use it +1, or would I need to lay diagonally, rendering it a one-person shelter?
Thanks so much.
OK, at 26 oz. for the ID tent I'd still go for my 28 oz. solo TarpTent Moment with a floor and netting AND excellent ventilation.
If sufficiently motivated I could "accomodate" a female friend in the Moment.
Yeah, this is a design that, definitely is missing a few things, but has awesome possibilities. I find myself desiring this to chop and sew.
This might be just the design to spur some truly innovative asym designs.
Cool.
ccc
Become a member to post in the forums.

