I will be going on a 2 week hike this summer and need to carry a Bearikade Expedition. I normally carry a BearVault 350 (solo) in the bottom of my pack on its side with the lid facing my back. That works fine for trips up to a week, but the larger canister has to go vertically and I can't figure out a good way to pack it in my McHale LBP36. When packed vertically there is just enough room on each side of the canister to be annoying, but not enough to really put much of anything. That leaves the lower 14.5" of my pack useless for storing anything else. I have tried packing the canister more in the middle of the pack (with some clothing in the bottom) but I worry about abrasion from the canister caused by the walking motion on gear (silnylon shelter, trash compactor bag, etc) and that still doesn't alleviate the fact that that the sides 14.5" of pack is of limited use.
I have started to think about looking at other packs for this trip (which pains me cause I really like the way my McHale carries) and off the top of my head can think of the following options:
A larger McHale – I wonder about the timetable, and I hate to spend that much $$$ on a pack that may only get used by my two or three times in my lifetime. – I mean how many two week trips will I ever get to do with a demanding job, wife, and two kids. One week trips are my norm.
Exped Lightning 60 – Seems like a simple pack that would do the job. I have seen nothing about how it handles a bear can.
HMG Porter 4400 – popular pack. No water bottle pockets though – wonder if I could attach my McHale pockets. My wife had a Windrider for a while and the shoulder straps were really flimsy feeling.
Paradox Unaweep – looks like it has the best frame of all the packs. Its hard to tell much about it from the website as the pictures really suck. I would probably get it in VX21 with no talon.
I really like my McHale hipbelt (perhaps the most important feature of any pack IMO), I wonder if it could be fitted to any of the above packs…….hmmmm.
I won't be carrying a ton of weight, probably under 35 pounds, just some bulkier gear than normal (the aforementioned bear can, fleece, synthetic jacket, etc)
In theory, I would love to be able to carry the canister horizontally, but I am unaware of any pack that can carry the Expedition horizontally (and that would have to be a huge pack) as I have carried a weekender horizontally and it was easy to pack that way (my McHale is to narrow to carry a weekender that way however)
I normally pack with the bear can in the bottom, along with my stove/cookpot, and fuel, then I put my trash compactor bag in and put sleep socks, insulating jacket, quilt, sleeping mat in, then stuff my shelter in on the outside of the trash compactor bag. raingear and the days food go on top.
What are your thoughts?


