I've stuck with Asolo through a couple cycles of footwear now, and while transitioning from boots to minimal hiking shoes (Quadrants) for 3-season use. I tried maybe 6 or 7 different shoes during this time (many recommended here) but came to the conclusion that only Asolo comes close to my foot shape (I think they use small Italian or Romanian men for their foot model). But the problem that all of their boots and shoes seem to share is very little cushioning on the balls of my feet. The insole padding in front is very thin out of the box (heel is fine even on my older boots). I think I'm loosing some fat padding in that area with age. I can feel it (in left foot more than the right) after maybe 10 miles on soft trails that I've been on all winter. So I'm worried about summer JMT hike on much harder surfaces.
I had a very bad experience with Superfeet, largely due to user error. I got sold on the "orange" to slip into some older boots. What was I thinking? Never mind the heel blisters I got from raising up my heels so much. The real problem was that I felt like I was walking on my arches. Extremely unpleasant. Even the idea of "arch support" makes me shudder now.
There are lower profile Superfeet (orange was about the worst I could have picked), but they all promise to give "3D support to my 2D footwear" or somesuch marketing gobbledygook. But Asolo shoes and boots already have a lot of shape in the heel, even without insole, and I suspect adding more shape can't be good.
Anyone have suggestions for me? (I just now Googled "front only insole" — seems there are gel-thingys that you can slip into your high heels…)

