Can someone explain why the Moment DW is dual wall while the Rainbow is not? They both appear to have a solid exterior fly with a separate, mesh interior. Also, does the mesh interior really constitute double-wall if it is not solid?
thanks.
Topic
Become a member to post in the forums.
Can someone explain why the Moment DW is dual wall while the Rainbow is not? They both appear to have a solid exterior fly with a separate, mesh interior. Also, does the mesh interior really constitute double-wall if it is not solid?
thanks.
Like any DW tent it has a separate inner with a rain fly that can be detached and the rainbow is a single wall design with the net sewn directly to the fly.You can watch the set up videos for both on their site.Here is a video of the double Rainbow and it shows more of the inside so you can see what it looks like a little better…… TarpTent Double Rainbow review
It seems logical to me that any tent which has a solid outer fly and mesh interior (be it sewn in, or detachable) would still be double-walled. It's just confusing to me. When i think of a DW tent i think of the traditional solid inner with optional exterior rainfly.
I believe the TT Rainbows do not have "full coverage" mesh — in other words, the ceiling of the Rainbow will be just the silnylon (no mesh at all), then the walls have mesh, which is connected to the bathtub floor.
So if you're lying down inside the Rainbow, you'll be looking up at silnylon ONLY (no mesh).
I think the term "double wall" is used only where you can detach the fly from the inner.
with the rainbow if you have condensation it will drip from the rain fly directly on you there is nothing between you and the rain fly above you, try watching THIS
Link, that is a great video and web page. It gives a good tour of backpacking shelter options. Thanks for sharing.
To the subject, many single wall tent designs use large mesh vents with some sort of cowl or awning over. You get the ventilation and insect protection in a lighter package. The Golite Utopia is a good example and we use an MSR Missing Link for car and bike camping. The ventilation on the Missing Link is fantastc, with two adults and a dog inside and little or no condensation issues, no bugs, and not stifling in summer weather.
The more awnings, the more weight, but not terribly so. The MSR is 3lbs and spacious for 2 plus an Aussie Shepherd, with lots of storage space and sitting height. It uses trekking poles.
"It seems logical to me that any tent which has a solid outer fly and mesh interior (be it sewn in, or detachable) would still be double-walled. It's just confusing to me. When i think of a DW tent i think of the traditional solid inner with optional exterior rainfly"
Steve it is a bit easier to confuse on the rainbow but there is no inner mesh. There is the outer fly and a groundsheet, and they are connected by mesh that is sewn to each. That is it. If you touch any point on the rainbow, there will only be one wall of material no matter where it is, hence the single wall construction. The moment has a detachable inner that can be erected by itself. If you touch any point on the inner mesh, there will be silnylon outer fly behind it.
Henry Shires chose the name Tarptent because his first shelter and the ones that followed soon after were "hybrid" shelters (hybrid is our term) consisting of a bug proof tarp, so not a standard tarp but not a standard tent either.
Initially only having a mesh door and mesh at the base of the fly, soon after and since then with a built in floor.
The Rainbows are like that, a fly mesh door/s and net between the floor and the fly.
However, unlike stated above , (If you touch any point on the rainbow, there will only be one wall of material no matter where it is) if you touch the door in the Rainbow (or either door in the Double Rainbow) there is a fly between the door and the outside , so at that point it is a "double wall".
You can add a "liner" to the Rainbow so that you also have a layer between you and the roof area.
We have now several full double wall shelters, all can be set up fly alone or fly and inner together.
To illustrate , this is the Moment fly alone :

you cannot do that with the Rainbows because the mesh and floor are attached :

Thanks for correcting Franco. I did in fact leave out the doors will have the double wall effect in most if not all of the tarp tents. I don't think the OP at the time of posting realized that it ends at the doors and there is no mesh elsewhere (other than connecting the bathtub floor to the tarp/fly) which is the main point I was trying to drive home for him.
the rainbow is a single wall tent with a fair amount of mesh on the sides. The "liner" makes it a psuedo double wall and works well. I know DW is popular right now but SW works just fine.
So I have owned and used both the SW Moment and the Moment DW.
The SW Moment, even WITH the optional partial liner, will get condensation/frost that will rain down on you when the tent is bumped while you struggle to get dressed or go for a call of Nature. And, since it is just a liner, it will deflect frost/condensation down to the sides of the liner on the floor perimeter.
The Moment DW inner tent protects you from this "rain". I've also sprayed my DW's inner tent exterior with Revivex DWR which helps it shed "rain" from the fly.
BTW, "hybrid tents like the Rainbow line and the original Moment single wall will let blown dust in and all over you, your bag, clothes, tent floor and mattress. (As will double wall tents with all mesh inner tents.) this is one reason I got a Moment DW with a ripstop inner tent. The other reason was to have a solo winter tent.
"The SW Moment, seven WITH the optional partial liner"
how many tarp tents do you have?
Katherine,
1. I bagan with the Contrail and used it for 4 years then sold it when the Moment came out. I wanted a more wind-worthy tent.
2. I got the Moment and put a crossing pole inside it and out through the Velcro reinforced netting ends for more wind resistance.
3. Then I bought the Scarp 2 and, again, put the 2 crossing poles inside the fly for snow load and wind resistance.
4. Now I have the Moment DW (with, natch, the X-ing pole inside the fly.) and sold my original SW Moment.
So I've owned 4 Tarptents and still have two of them.
As one poster here at BPL said when Henry Shires came out with a new tent, "Curse you Henry Shires." (Now) I have to have another tent."
"how many tarp tents do you have?"
Always one too few, unfortunately. :)
Become a member to post in the forums.