Topic

quilt material for good water resistantance

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
Mike M BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 6:31 am

I'm trying to lighten my winter pack; I currently use snow trenches/caves for shelters, but have always carried a bivy (eVENT) to protect my bag from moisture

I know there are several materials that are pretty water resistant, but still breathable- can someone shed light on what materials I should be looking at and how they rate as far as water resistance, breathability and weight? my current quilt is Argon 67- where does it fit in the water resistance continuum?

thanks in advance!

Mike

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 7:37 am

my bivy is M-50 from thru-hiker. 0.7 oz/yd2. That is very waterproof from splashing or mist, but will leak if in direct rain. I sleep out a lot and dew/frost gets on the outside, but I've never noticed the down inside getting wet. I weigh it when I get back home.

eVent is maybe 2 oz/yd2 – more waterproof, less breathable

I tried some Nobul1 which is 0.7 oz/yd2. Not nearly as waterproof as M50. Still okay for minor splashing and mist. More breathable.

I'de guess argon67 is more like Nobul

Snow trenches/caves can get wet, but there isn't rain dropping on you, so probably M50, argon67, or Nobul1 would be okay. The Nobul1 I have isn't down-proof, so I will never use that again for down.

Who knows where M50 or argon67 would be better for your application?

Simon Kenton BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 7:47 am

I’m not sure if Luke treats his Argon but Richard N posted some measures on the material here

Looks like a pretty good HH. I just question how downproof it is?

Edit – Just checked the graph again, LUL uses Argon 90. The Argon 67 is listed as well, though.

Jerry Adams BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 7:54 am

is your argon67 down-proof Mike?

I've wondered that – others have said it is – haven't heard negative reports

Some day I might make another down quilt so am thinking about it. Like when so much down leaks out of my Nobul1 quilt that it loses too much loft. Seems like the down leakage has gone way down. It's still warm and enough loft.

Simon Kenton BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 8:53 am

Jerry, FWIW here is a direct quote from the HG copy on the topic: "Calendaring of the fabric further enhances the down-proofness of the quilt."

Edward Barton BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 10:06 am

I've been thinking along the same lines, and have thought of several solutions. Not sure which is better for which conditions…

Argon 67 is not very water resistant at all, only ~200HH per Richard's graph, but it is quite breathable, which is important for avoiding wetting out the quilt from within.

A snow cave or trench can also have fairly minimal air flow, increasing the need for breathability.

A few solutions:

You could use multiple fabrics in a quilt. A less breathable/more water resistant fabric at the edges, where it is more likely to come into contact with snow, and argon 67 toward the middle, where more vapor would need venting from your core anyway. Not sure if M50 would be resistant enough, especially if any of the quilt is pressed up against the snow at times. Pertex Endurance is another option, though heavier. I believe Katabatic uses it in their cold weather quilts.

You could try making an m50 bivy…perhaps 2.5-3oz for something very simple, akin to the quilt liner sold by MLD. Perhaps it could have a flap to open the middle for more breathability.

Finally, you could carry a larger groundcloth, out of polycryo or cuben etc., and use it to line the walls of a trench or cave around your bag, like a bathtub floor. Perhaps it could be attached to the walls with sticks driven into the walls through some small holes in the fabric.

Aaron Sorensen BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 1:25 pm

In your situation, I would just make another bivy with a .7 ounce cuben bottom and Argon.67 top (layers).

I would make it with a layer of 2.5 ounce insulation on top 40" width and half taper to 25" at the foot (just enough to cover you).
Then something like 25" tapering to 20" on the cuben bottom piece.

This would not only keep you dry but also much warmer.

Edward Barton BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 4:18 pm

Nice idea Aaron. I've had similar thoughts. I wonder how much warmer, perhaps 15 degrees for a single layer of 2.5oz Apex? (Edit: I read 10 degrees elsewhere)

You could also leave the top insulation sleeve unsewn and swap varying thicknesses of Apex depending on your needs. And you could save a bit more weight by making the inner layer of the top out of silk gauze instead of argon – the 3 momme gauze from Dharma Trading weighs something like half of what argon 67 weighs, though I don't have a good sense of it's durability.

I like the 3 season EE revelation style quilts a lot because they can be worn very well while doing camp chores or ambling after dark. The pad straps of the Revelation make a great belt too, and you can incorporate a sleep pad where the quilt opens for maximum warmth.

With a wearable quilt and a light insulated bivy to add warmth, you can forego a puffy jacket too and further lighten the load…

PostedMar 12, 2015 at 5:32 pm

I have pondered the same question and I am leaning in the direction of a light synthetic insualted overquilt – as others have mentioned. The lightest Event fabric I've ever heard of is 2.25 oz/sq. yd (I have some and have weighed it myself). It will keep moisture out for sure, but you will almost certainly have condensation – especially in a snowcave as they tent to be humid. Two layers of Argon and 2.2 oz climashield (from OWF)totals 3.4 oz.sq yd, will keep some moisture out of your down bag/quilt, add more warmth than a event bivy, and if you have condensation it will be in the synthetic outer, which will dry way faster than the down, not only because it is synthetic but also because it's thin.

Now if you want to use your bivy outside of snow shelters, in the open as your only shelter, different story. For that event is probably the way to go.

Mike M BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 7:59 pm

thanks gents- lots of good ideas!

jerry- thus far the Argon 67 has been very downproof (knock on wood!)

Pertex Quantum looks pretty close to what I'm looking for, roughly 1000 mm HH, water resistant, not waterproof, not as breathable as the Argons, but still pretty breathable

from Richard's charts looks like Argon 67 is ~ 211, the 90 352

the insulated bivy is definitely an interesting idea, but if I could ditch a bivy entirely and get some decent water resistance in a quilt shell, I think that would be ideal

Edward Barton BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 9:16 am

@Mike, I'm surprised Quantum is 1000HH. If I remember, that's the same as the material in the Dragon 20 which we both have I believe, and which is seriously water resistant, if not waterproof.

I don't have much experience with Quantum though, only GL, which is decidedly not waterproof, but better than Argon I think. Let us know how it works out for you.

Mole J BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 11:21 am

pertex endurance is specced at 1000mm HH

it's got a pu coating on the inside

so nominally waterproof

pertex quantum decidedly less HH so as it's uncoated just a DWR

Mike M BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 5:21 pm

I saw an earlier thread where someone referenced it as Pertex Quantum Endurance, was that a misspeak (or a mistype)?

sounds like they may be different???; if so, what is the ~ HH of plain Quantum if known?

thanks

Mike

Mike M BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 7:28 pm

Richard N was nice enough to pm me, there are two Quantums (maybe more???) Quantum GL which by Richards measurements have a HH of 211; Quantum Endurance is GL w/ an added WPB pu coating on the inside and sound and is reported to be ~ 1000

Soooo- given that, would Q Endurance work for a quilt ie breathable enough, certainly water resistant enough it would appear? I see Nuntatuk offers a Epic fabric that is highly water resistant- anyone have experience w/ that by chance?

Edward Barton BPL Member
PostedMar 14, 2015 at 1:08 pm

*Here* is an old Epic thread, with an analysis by Richard.

Endurance is lighter, though not by much (1.4oz vs. 1.71oz for Epic) and about as breathable going by the MVTR specs I've seen, 7000 for Endurance, via the Pertex site, vs 6852 for Epic, via an old, thorough SOTM on WPBs by Alan Dixon from 2004 (here), but I wonder if the small air permeability (.44CFM) of the Epic may make it move more moisture in practice. From what I've read, air permeability influences comfort in a garment more than vapor transfer rate, but perhaps for quilt function, MVTR is more important.

Another consideration is that PU coated fabrics like Endurance tend to transfer moisture better as humidity rates inside the garment rise, while something like eVent or Epic will transfer vapor equally well regardless of humidity levels inside or outside the garment. This is why PU coated fabrics trend upward in Fig 1 of Dixon's report. This isn't such a problem for active movement, where humidity is quite high inside the garment, but it may be when sleeping in a snow trench, where humidity is ideally low inside the garment, but may be higher outside. I don't have a good sense of what the normal relative humidity would be in a snow trench or cave though, or how much this would effect real MVTR for Endurance.

Katabatic uses Endurance on their cold weather Grenadier quilt, which has received good reviews, so perhaps it would work fine.

Maybe Richard or someone else with more knowledge can chime in though, or recommend any more suitable fabrics.

Aaron Sorensen BPL Member
PostedMar 14, 2015 at 7:44 pm

You have to remember that coated fabrics will have a harder time laying completely flat against a lighter DWR nylon.

What happens is the result of a slight air spacing or gap between the fabrics
That gap is what will give you the better water resistance.

So finding a lightly coated fabric that still breaths should be more important than fabric which has a good HH.
Keeps a lot of dew from collecting inside as well.

I loved the Impetus 1.1 for this reason.
The coated Argon that was out before was almost as good.
The Argon was a better over-all material, but not for bivy fabric.

Well an Argon 90-sil with Impetus 1.1 top would be awesome.

Mike M BPL Member
PostedMar 15, 2015 at 9:46 am

Edward- thanks. I might chat w/ Nunatak and see what they have to say. It's definitely on the humid side in most of the snow caves/trenches I've been in, not always dripping wet (but sometimes).

Aaron-how moisture resistant is the Impetus 1.1? Wonder if it will come back on the market???

thanks

Mike

PostedMar 15, 2015 at 3:08 pm

Mike,

So far I have only one piece of Dri Down down clothing (and EB vest) but may I recommend getting your next winter bag with a DWR down treatment. Along with a very water resistant shell it will make your down "very water resistant" as well.

And then buy some Grangers or Revivex DWR spray and treat your bag shell with it.

This combination should do the trick. But I still like your eVent bivy bag as the best answer to staying dry.

PostedMar 15, 2015 at 4:36 pm

One other thought – milesgear sells not only the Uber bivy which is more than what you want, but also a simple sack type that's prety light, and even the fabric used for the tops (non-woven, WP/B stuff, around 2.3 oz/yd I think) Supposedly very breathable and waterproof.

Mike M BPL Member
PostedMar 15, 2015 at 5:08 pm

Eric- my most recent quilt is treated, hoping not to have to test it out though :)

the eVENT does work very well and at 14 oz, maybe I should just be satisfied- also a little bit of a safety factor as it takes some time to construct a trench or cave, sometimes with the wrong weather, possibly time you won't have???

Paul- I'll check milesgear out

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 20 total)
Loading...