Topic

Permit legality when resupplying

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
ed hyatt BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 12:14 am

I'm from the UK – bear (sic) with me….

If I pick up a permit at a Sierra trailhead and head off to do a two-to-three week hike what is the situation if I hitch out to a town for resupply and a rest then get back on the trail again; is that permit still valid? Do I need another (possibly difficult)?

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 12:35 am

Like always, the answer is "it depends."

Rather than getting into that situation and then being totally dependent on somebody else's decision, perhaps the best solution is not to have any official contact with the authorities while you are off the trail. Then, if you never officially left the trail, there is no problem. For example, take the short trail between the John Muir Trail and Onion Valley. I would suspect that some backpackers on the trail will duck out to Onion Valley, hitch a ride to Independence to buy food, hitch a ride back to Onion Valley, and then try to hike back to the trail. That's likely to take more than one full day. On the other hand, I have never seen a forest service ranger or a park service ranger along there.

I've seen various rangers "cut some slack" for somebody with a foreign passport, especially if they claim they didn't understand due to the language. If you can suddenly break into a shouting match in Czech, they may try to ignore you.

–B.G.–

ed hyatt BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 12:38 am

Thanks Bob – I thought it may be a little bit like that.

I'm pretty good at looking slightly bemused and I can speak French – but that might get me in deeper!

Justin Baker BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 12:39 am

Edit: Nevermind, I obviously don't know what I'm talking about here. Sorry!

PostedMar 12, 2015 at 8:02 am

I'm not sure what the current regulations are. But about 4 years ago I check on this with the Inyo National Forest. I am quite clear that the rule then was: You are allowed to hike out and back the same day without getting a new permit. For instance, to use Bob's example of Onion Valley: If you hike out, get food in Independence, and hike back in the same day you are legal. But if you spend the night in town or at the campground without getting back on the trail the same day, then you need a new permit to be legal.

To make sure you have the current information, you should call the relevant park service that controls the area in which you intend to do your resupply.

billy

Dave G BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 8:10 am

Ed,

As a canny Northern Lad myself (born in Gateshead, living in Durham), you'll have no problem.
Out of wilderness resupply is a very common practice, and unless you're re-entering on either end of the JMT you're very unlikely to see a ranger.
When filling out the permit application for the night you're spending out of the wilderness, pick a plausible spot just inside the wilderness for your location.

Dave

Steve B BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 8:54 am

I remember reading (I think on the PCTA site) that PCT hikers cannot exit the trail through the Whitney zone for resupply. That is the only trailhead I could see being an issue.

Steve

PostedMar 12, 2015 at 9:29 am

One way to do it legally would be to get a second permit for the day you want to re-enter.
While it is true that you are unlikely to sea a ranger, if you do, and if he checks your permit, it could be a real drag to have to hike back out, hitch back to town, get a permit (possibly days after you want), then hitch back to the trail and start hiking again. And there could be a fine involved too for hiking without a valid permit…. all unlikely, but….

You can minimize your chance of seeing a ranger by hiking back in on a weekday that is not a holiday.

billy

Bob Bankhead BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 10:21 am

Permits allow you to leave and re-enter the trail system within the start and end dates on said permit. Do yourself a big favor and get a PCTA permit (must be for 500 miles minimum) so you don't have to deal with several individual permits.

CAVEAT: You can NOT exit and re-enter via these routes without a separate permit:

1. Over Whitney Portal and down to Lone Pine and back.

2. From the PCT at Tuolumne Meadows down to Yosemite Valley via the JMT. Nothing says you couldn't take the free shuttle bus both ways between the two, but why would you want to when you have a post office and a good store at TM?

PostedMar 12, 2015 at 1:35 pm

"Permits allow you to leave and re-enter the trail system within the start and end dates on said permit"

Only exiting and reentering on the same day when within Inyo National Forest; exiting one day and reentering on the next day is not allowed (if you get caught).

billy

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 2:42 pm

"To make sure you have the current information, you should call the relevant park service that controls the area in which you intend to do your resupply."

That can be slightly difficult. In the example I used around Kearsarge Pass, the area between the John Muir Trail and the pass is in Sequoia-Kings Canyon National Park (Department of the Interior). The area between the pass and Onion Valley is in Inyo National Forest (Department of Agriculture). Those two agencies do not necessarily talk together.

However, that trail junction near Charlotte Lake is geographically well suited for some sort of resupply event. It is right around the middle of a long stretch of trail with few other options. Plus, due to the time constraints of one backpacker out on the trail, another option rears its ugly head. That is having a resupply brought in to that trail junction over Kearsarge Pass. That may be in the mode of a human porter, or it may be in the mode of a packer service with animals. Some of that can get awfully pricey for cash, although it makes good use of backpacker time. It just depends on the priorities.

There is one small alternative within that. Last year, I was hanging around at Onion Valley (for altitude adjustment) prior to my own trip. I saw some backpackers coming east on the trail to reach the parking lot. There, they fished around in one of the bear boxes and retrieved a food package that they had previously stashed there. Then after an hour of rest, they loaded up and went back west over Kearsarge Pass. They eliminated the problem of hitching to Independence and back and the time that requires.

–B.G.–

PostedMar 12, 2015 at 3:22 pm

"There is one small alternative within that. Last year, I was hanging around at Onion Valley (for altitude adjustment) prior to my own trip. I saw some backpackers coming east on the trail to reach the parking lot. There, they fished around in one of the bear boxes and retrieved a food package that they had previously stashed there. Then after an hour of rest, they loaded up and went back west over Kearsarge Pass. They eliminated the problem of hitching to Independence and back and the time that requires."

I'm sure that happens. But that is illegal too… if you get caught.
I asked Inyo about that a few years ago. This kind of thing is why they closed the food lockers at Kearsarge lakes last year…. any why they periodically remove food from the Onion Vally trail head locker that has been there too long.

as for any confusion about which park entity to contact about the entry/exit rules… there should be no confusion regarding the Onion Valley option for resupply: Inyo National Forest is the controlling entity on that trail head… SEKI does not care if you exit to Inyo and back or not. I asked them all this about 4 years ago. I doubt it has changed, but best for the Original Poster to call Inyo to ask.

billy

Valerie E BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 6:10 pm

Billy Ray is absolutely right. The regulations specifically state that if you are off-trail for more than 24 hours, you must get a new permit — regardless of the entry/exit dates on the permit you originally carried.

This regulation is buried somewhere in one of the on-line info (I forget where), and — to be perfectly honest — I never read it until someone pointed it out to me a week ago, so when I went off-trail during last summer's JMT thru (twice) for more than 24 hours, I was inadvertently in violation of the regulations.

I really don't understand the intent of this regulation, and it really annoys me!!! It seems counter-intuitive to potentially prevent people from completing the trail with their existing permit just because some problem arises (say, they need a doctor/dentist, or a resupply didn't arrive). It seems logical that — provided they are still within their entry/exit dates — they should be able to take as long as they want for a resupply! What harm would this do to others?

So, frankly, I would just do as you had originally planned, and IF you meet a ranger, just tell them that you were off-trail for less than 24 hours.

BTW, leaving unaccompanied food in ANY trailhead bear box overnight is strictly prohibited (but I saw several people do it). I fully understand this regulation, because long-term storage of food for thru-hikers could easily fill up the trailhead bear boxes, preventing day hikers and permitted campers from storing their food there.

Paul Wagner BPL Member
PostedMar 12, 2015 at 9:39 pm

Please note that in Yosemite National Park, you cannot leave the wilderness and then re-enter it with the same permit. That's what the regulations say. Hikers on the JMT can stop for a re-supply in Tuolumne Meadows, for example, because that is considered to be "on the trail." But if you leave the trail (get in a car, catch a ride, etc.) your permit is done.

So you are not allowed to catch a ride in Tuolumne Meadows back to the valley for the day, pick up food, and re-enter on the same day. Once you leave the wilderness, your permit is considered expired in Yosemite.

As others have stated, that's the technical answer. Rangers may well cut slack for someone who is trying hard to do the right thing. Or they may not.

PostedMar 13, 2015 at 7:50 am

Can anyone cite a case where a hiker has been fined or restricted from retuning to a hike?

Justin Baker BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 11:26 am

So if I'm hiking in Yosemite and I accidentally set foot into the Emigrant Wilderness, and my permit had no reference of camping in Emigrant, then I have technically invalidated my Yosemite permit?

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 11:39 am

Justin, for the next time that you are out there, go find the border between Yosemite and Emigrant Wilderness. Take a photo of the big dotted line on the ground.

Technically invalidating a Yosemite permit is possible, but enforcement of that is going to be very hit-or-miss. Mostly miss. You know how few backcountry rangers there are on patrol.

If you are two miles on the wrong side of a border when a ranger stops you, he may ask to see your permit. If he determines that you are two miles on the wrong side and asks you about it, I would recommend to dummy up about it. Then he is likely to turn you around to the correct direction. Once you get to the correct side of the border, if another ranger finds you, I would recommend to dummy up again.

Now, when they get very serious about those permits is when they have caught you in violation of some other wilderness regulations, and then they will slap you with a violation of the border as well. If the rangers can simply give you a verbal warning, then they are likely to do it. If you give them a hard time, then they will "throw the book at you."

–B.G.–

Paul Wagner BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 5:33 pm

Your permit from Yosemite allows you to hike into Emigrant, just as your permit in Emigrant allows you to hike into Yosemite. WE often get a permit through the Hoover Wilderness, on the east side, because it's an easier process than Yosemite, and then hike through Hoover into Yosemite

You usually won't get cited if you have a valid permit. If you get a permit for Hetch-hetchy and try to use that to hike up from Happy Isles to Half Dome, you will get stopped, probably cited and fined.

Art … BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 6:12 pm

I have not had my permit checked even once in the last 3 years in the Sierra.
most trips I never even see a ranger out there.
just sayin' …

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 13, 2015 at 6:22 pm

"Your permit from Yosemite allows you to hike into Emigrant, just as your permit in Emigrant allows you to hike into Yosemite."

Normally, your permit must state the cross-border visit, and then it is legal. The permit-issuing authority will do that easily, but if nothing is mentioned, then nothing will be added to the basic permit wording.

–B.G.–

Paul Wagner BPL Member
PostedMar 14, 2015 at 7:11 am

"I have not had my permit checked even once in the last 3 years in the Sierra.
most trips I never even see a ranger out there.
just sayin' …"

I agree. But then, I don't hike the Half Dome trail. There are areas in the Sierra that are regularly checked, and that's one of them. With the new proposed changes, Donahue Pass may be another one!

Bob Gross BPL Member
PostedMar 14, 2015 at 7:24 am

I have seen others being cited by a ranger packing a sidearm.

Rangers tend to be on the heavily used trails where the chance of permit abuse is high. If you are in a bear canister area, they want to strike their knuckles against the bulge in your backpack and hear that dull thud. If they don't hear it, they will ask you to dump out your whole backpack.

–B.G.–

PostedMar 14, 2015 at 7:30 am

Paul –
"With the new proposed changes, Donahue Pass may be another one!"

Are you referring to the Ursack proposal?

Dave G BPL Member
PostedMar 14, 2015 at 7:52 am

Greg,

From this year, there is now a quota on permits leaving Yosemite via Donahue Pass, ie JMT SoBo.

Dave

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
Loading...