I really don’t think you can go wrong with either. I think my Borah Gear Snowyside 2 uses the PU4000 bottom and it seems to be pretty durable.
My only advice is to choose the least expensive fabrics if this is your first attempt at a build. I always end up wanting to try something a little different after I complete a project and I’d rather not dole out the cash on very expensive materials on the first run.
That being said, I can send you a couple yards of 2nds silnylon from Oware for the cost of shipping. Drop me a PM if you want to go that route.