E.E Quilt Down Smell?

Just took delivery of 2 new EE quilts today .. the were stuffed in the box about 5 days and no smells at all.

There are reports in other forums on here about down smells. I think most folks would say leave the quilt out to air out and dry very thoroughly both now and after each use obviously.

Washing is fine, but your new quilts shouldn’t need washing yet.

Thanks for the quick reply.

Yeah, I didn’t notice any smells at first either. It was only after my first time using it. It was in humid conditions, as it was raining, but the bag never got wet.

I hope I didn’t get a bad batch of down. I’m hoping a good wash will fix it…

Honestly, if the smell doesn’t go away, I don’t think I’ll be able to use it. It’s like sleeping with a wet dog; Or a wet dog that just murdered a goose.

As mentioned, this was discussed in another thread and has been experienced by others.  Some thought it was a duck down vs goose down phenomena but nothing concrete was determined and it appeared to either be hit and miss based on the smell or another’s tolerance/intolerance for the smell.

i would air the bag out well or tumble it on no heat in your dryer to help in the airing process.  You could also try storing it with a couple of dryer sheets placed inside the quilt to help.

Thanks for the reply John. I’ll try and find that thread. Do you remember if they ever found a solution? Or should I expect this smell to be a characteristic of this quilt?

Appreciate the help.

My EE quilt had the poultry smell initially, but I no longer can detect any odor, so I think if you just air it out well, it will dissipate on its own eventually.  I’m not sure how long it was before I noticed the absence of the smell, but I’d guess weeks to a few months.

Caulin … I would bet that we underestimate the “water exposure” to bags when humid even if the bag isn’t grossly soiled.

In the SE US where humidity is king, Things seem damp very quickly sometimes.

Here is one of the longer threads on this:  https://backpackinglight.com/forums/topic/92028/

I’ve purchased two E.E. quilts.  The first one didn’t smell, the second one did.  As reported above, after it aired out (weeks to months) I’ve never noticed anything.

Humidity is the issue here.

We get more reports of odor in the summer where it is humid here in MN and almost none in the winter when it is dry.  We have done testing in controlled rooms and changing the humidity impacts the odor but as mentioned airing it out well after use and storing it bone dry will go a long way toward reducing any odors you may experience.  Humidity will also impact the weight upto an oz or so depending on size and temp of the quilt.  Humidity is impossible for us to fully control but we do stuff quilts in a humidity controlled room as we do everything we can to make the best possible products.

-Tim

Be aware that different rooms in your house can differ a lot in their humidity.  Obviously the bathroom you take showers in is higher in humidity as is the kitchen when you’re cooking food.  But house plants also increase humidity while the added heat of a chest freezer running in a small room decreases it.  And it differs seasonally (for me, a lot).  So it’s worth running around with hygrometer, even a cheap little relative humidity gauge, to learn where the driest room in the house is.

I had the same problem with an EE quilt and no amount of airing out or putting in the dryer ever removed the smell.  As others have said, it was worse when humid.  I finally got some Grainger Down Wash and washed my quilt.  Yes, it was a PITA but it did the trick.  It completely removed the smell and the smell has never returned.

Thanks for all the comments and replys! And thank you, Tim, for taking the time to explain your findings, you’re the obvious authority on the topic haha

Gerry, that’s what I’m thinking I’ll have to do. I’m going on a trip on the 22nd and know that smell will drive me crazy after a couple nights.

The first time I used mine (2 years ago, PNW) it was raining and I had the same concerns about the smell.  I emailed Tim and he was very nice and explained, just as he has here, that is was the humidity.  I never did anything to the quilt after and I only smell it on wet nights.  When I get home It never smells, and I sometimes give it a random smell check and then end up wrapping myself in it because it’s so soft and comfy.

my WM highlite had the same smell when used in humid conditions … as did my EE quilt … as did my friends marmot xenon

for odorless go synthetic … even the best makers with down quilts/bags might have some smell initially

;)

Yep, it has gone away with time for me.  I hope my HammockGear UQ does as well!  Not a wet dog, but some other flavor of funk.

I bought a used EE quilt awhile back that had a very strong dead bird funk to it.  I tried washing it and airing it out, but the stink remained. After awhile it bothered me less, but it still bothered me enough to sell it.  It was like sleeping in a chicken coup.  My Katabatic quilt had a similar smell but much much less than the EE. I also have a custom quilt made by a MYOG’er that has the smell but like the Katabatic it is almost not noticeable and does not bother me.  For these reasons I do not see myself even looking at EE again.

Just to clarify, I am in no way knocking EE products or their down. EE’s craftsmanship and design is excellent, as well as their value. I think the poultry smell is a crap shoot and some batches of down have more of it than others. Not to mention the fact that ultralight products like EE use thinner materials, which could provide less of an odor barrier. With that in mind, I would recommend the optional weather stripes; Wish I got those.

In the same breath, I don’t think it is an unreasonable expectation to think that a sleeping bag or quilt shouldn’t smell like a wet bird/dog every time it is used in humid conditions. And trust me, it isn’t like I’m looking for trouble and jumped on the forums at the faintest hint of a smell. I woke up a few times in the night horrified and perplexed by the smell. I had no idea where it was coming from. It completely filled the tent.

So I’m going to give it a wash and see if that’ll changes much. I love the quilt and really can’t wait to be able to use it without frying my nose and odor staining my base layers lol

I’ll give an update after the wash. Thanks guys

The interesting questions is why even the best doen bags can smell when damp … But damp down jackets usually dont

Even cheap down jackets dont smell much when damp

Its a question for which i have no answer

;)

I did pick up a cheap down vest at Costco once that positively reeked of bird…and put it back down after carrying it in my cart for a few minutes.  This was before I got my EE quilt; now I probably would have kept the vest and just aired it out in the garage for a while.