I am not sure what makes Evazote foam so special but at one time I did seek it out myself…. and thanks to McHale as well.
MYOGing packs for a little over five years and what I have found to work the best for me so far is the 1/4″ tan CCF from The Rain Shed. Â I know The Rain Shed gets little love around here but they price their CCF by the yard and not by the inch or foot–making them cheaper than their competition.
https://www.therainshed.com/shop/Fabrics/UNIQUE-FABRICS/p/Closed-Cell-Foam—14-inch—Black-x20859291.htm
My local Jo Ann’s sells a black 1/4″ CCF that is a little softer than the CCF from TRS, but it also tears fairly easily and is 2.5X or so the price.
A trick to make CCF more squishy is to simply drill rows of holes into it.
Another thing to try is to glue a piece of open cell foam to a 1/4″ CCF. Â I got this idea from an old Jan Sport Rockies that had the most comfy shoulder straps and hip belt I have even seen in a commercially available pack. Â The foam I had used for this also came from Jo Ann’s. Â It will eventually become saturated with water but not nearly as fast as sponge or as fast as you might think. Â While I have never used such a construction during an extended rain period (or in the shower), as far as I can tell the open cell foam as always stayed dry.