Topic

Cheap Carbon Fiber Poles From Costco.


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums Gear Forums Gear (General) Cheap Carbon Fiber Poles From Costco.

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 17 posts - 26 through 42 (of 42 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #2185231
    Brad S
    BPL Member

    @mrstop

    Locale: Cincinnati

    Thanks for confirming Paul. I'm heading to Virginia next week and I'll try there.

    #2185242
    Gordon Gray
    BPL Member

    @gordong

    Locale: Front Range, CO

    I may have to stop by Costco Louisville and get some myself. Now I just need a 'Price Club' membership…..

    Are these the poles in reference?

    http://www.cascademountaintech.com/product_p/1010.htm

    poles
    poles

    #2185247
    Travis W
    Spectator

    @lobopac

    Locale: Central Valley, CA

    Anyone spotted these in the Bay Area or Central Valley? My store in Modesto never seemed to stock them previously and haven't seen them recently. Got some a few years ago in the Bay Area. I'm headed into the Bay Area next week and if I know a specific store has them, I might swing by.

    #2185264
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    I haven't used em but I remember quite a few people reporting good things last year. You can probably dig it up int he archives.

    I thought the consensus was that they're entry level but good value. More $ will get you lighter poles.

    #2185291
    Frank T
    Member

    @random_walk

    Locale: San Diego

    I saw a full display case this morning at the San Diego Mission Valley Costco. They are in the "seasonal" section (with the pool toys, kayaks, etc.), not in the sporting goods aisle with the backpacks. Go figure.

    #2208233
    Brandon Gittelman
    Spectator

    @caverunner17

    Do the Costco's in Colorado still have them? Just checked three in IL and they don't stock them. :(

    Otherwise I'll order on Amazon.

    #2208235
    Eric Lundquist
    BPL Member

    @cobberman

    Locale: Northern Colorado

    A few weeks ago the Costco in Fort Collins had a pallet of them. Haven't been back since.

    #2208262
    Paul Magnanti
    BPL Member

    @paulmags

    Locale: Colorado Plateau

    The one in Superior, CO (10m from Boulder) had them as of Tues evening.

    #2208280
    Diane “Piper” Soini
    BPL Member

    @sbhikes

    Locale: Santa Barbara

    My boyfriend is on his second pair of Costco poles. The first pair broke. To be fair, he also broke his Gossamer Gear poles.

    #2208439
    Jeff Jeff
    BPL Member

    @jeffjeff

    I've heard a few reports of these breaking. I don't have first hand experience since I don't buy cheap knockoffs.

    http://www.nwhikers.net/forums/viewtopic.php?t=8014422

    #2208708
    Jacob D
    BPL Member

    @jacobd

    Locale: North Bay

    They can also be purchased directly from Cascade Mountain Tech:
    http://www.cascademountaintech.com/Trekking-Poles-s/247.htm

    I picked up a pair of them over a year ago and have used them quite a bit. These poles offer more bang for the buck than anything out there, in my opinion anyway. They're not the absolute lightest, but they're light. Besides the beefier shafts may offer a little more durability so it's not necessarily all bad. The flick lock version is what you want of course.

    Aside from these, there are not many other choices when it comes to carbon fiber poles with the flick lock… BD Alpine Carbon Cork (pricey, also not ultralight, but bomber), and the Locus Gear poles (pricey, lightest thing out there).

    I wrote a bit about all of these poles on my blog (blogspam incoming…)
    http://hikeitlikeit.com/2014/lightweight-trekking-poles-revisited/

    I ended up gravitating towards the Cascade Mtn Tech poles and have used them quite a bit. I met another hiker up in the Sierra who was also using them and asked him about his experience. He hiked the JMT with them, broke a tip on one pole (took a fall), finished his hike, then bought another set of them. You can call them "entry level" or whatever, but at the end of the day… they're all sticks.

    edited to add: I've found the staps on the Cascade Mtn Tech poles to be very comfy. I also like the feel of the BD Alpine Carbon Cork straps. Of all these poles, those two straps seem to slip the least also, which as everyone knows is the annoying achilles heel of trekking poles (if you use the straps)

    #2208743
    Mitchell Ebbott
    Spectator

    @mebbott-2

    Locale: SoCal

    I have a pair, they're awesome. If you can't find them in Costco, they're on Amazon with Prime shipping. A little more expensive, but still cheaper than anything CF from Black Diamond or Leki. I'm convinced that the quality is exactly the same.

    #2208768
    d k
    BPL Member

    @dkramalc

    oops, duplicate post.

    #2208771
    d k
    BPL Member

    @dkramalc

    I think the Amazon link is for the twist-lock, which seem to have some complaints about the adjustment breaking; if you want the flick-lock variety and can't find them at Costco, you can buy them directly at http://www.cascademountaintech.com/Quick-Lock-Trekking-Poles-p/1010.htm

    I've used these for a couple of years dayhiking and backpacking with no problems whatsoever. I keep the rubber tips on, contrary to what most people do, which seems to prevent me from getting the narrow tips stuck in a crack between rocks (which I suspect is one contributor to breaking poles). And I like the way it feels on rock (and mutes the "click, click" sound).

    #2208786
    Tom D.
    BPL Member

    @dafiremedic

    Locale: Southern California

    I wrote the Amazon review that Sam Farrington included in his earlier post in this thread. That was written in 2012, a few months after we had completed a thru-hike of the JMT (the “Multi-day hike in the Sierras” that I mentioned) where we attempted to use the CMT trekking poles. My youngest was without poles within the first week when both of his broke (we were able to pick up some ski poles at the Mammoth thrift store for him to use the rest of the way). I initially attributed it to the technique of an 11 yr. old (and still do to some degree), but my older son’s and mine all broke at some point after that during the hike and I was left wishing I had ponied up for higher quality poles.

    Just an update, I have since bought two more sets (both twist locks, the flick locks hadn't yet come out) along with a set of GG LT4’s. One of those CMT sets failed at the adjustment points fairly soon with regular use. I have been scavenging that set, along with the remains of my JMT set to keep this last set going. I usually save the LT4’s for multi-day hikes, using the CMT poles for day hikes, etc. Some things that I have learned along the way:

    1. Get the flick locks if they are available. As any mountain biker knows, Flick locks can be kind of sketchy with CF although I am sure that they have reinforced those areas, but the twist locks on these have been too unreliable in my experience.

    2. If you get the twist locks, try to minimize adjusting the length and when you do, do so as gently as you can while still twisting it just secure enough to use. If your style dictates that you change the length for uphills, downhills, setting up your shelter, putting them back in the car, etc., I’d suggest a different brand (or get the Flick Locks). This last set has lasted me almost 2 years now because I try to use them as fixed length poles as much as possible, only using the adjustments when I have to for a shelter, etc. Otherwise, I leave them at my hiking length. If you need to shorten them for storage, store them with the twist locks loose.

    My opinion on the CMT poles is that if you see them in Costco, buy them. Even the twist lock version is far better than anything else in this price range IMO, and certainly better than the low quality (to put it kindly) poles that I’ve bought for the kids from Target, Big 5, etc. both in usability and reliability. But the twist lock version is clearly not of the quality of the higher end offerings from Black Diamond or Leki (and definitely not GG), mainly because of the adjustment mechanisms. Maybe they have solved this with the Flick Locks. My local Costco doesn’t carry them (I checked again earlier today).

    #2208848
    Marc Pierrat
    Spectator

    @usermarc

    Locale: Southern California

    I have bought and used BOTH the Yukon Charlie and Cascade Mountain Tech (CMT) poles from Costco. Here is what I've gathered about these two poles:

    1) The CMT flip lock poles were 7 oz each, and the Yukon Charlies were 6 oz each.
    2) The CMTs were NOTICEABLY stiffer. Just put the pole over your knee and press.
    3) The CMT carbon tubes are LARGER. I did not measure since the Outside Diameter (OD) doesn't tell the whole story.
    4) The CMTs had tapered tubes, Yukon Charlie straight tubes. So, for 1 oz more per pole with the CMT, you get what I think is probably a stronger pole, HOWEVER: when you close it up, the last end stays loose unless you adjust the flip lock tension. Minor nuisance.
    5) The Yukon Charlies, with straight tubes, did not make any noise when planting. The CMTs, however, made a slight click. The reason is because the CMTs include a small plastic spacer at the end of each tube and it's not stiff enough to keep the inner tube from plinking against the outer tube.
    6) The tips of both are not replaceable. I dont care. I carry the rubber boots and use them over rocks or whenever the ground is hard enough to merit. The wear rate is minimal.

    That said: ANY carbon pole is a tradeoff. They WILL break if you are careless. They will not break if you are sticking to longitudinal forces only, which is what they are designed for. I can put my entire weight with a pack on these poles. TESTED. So far, the CMT poles have been fantastic. I love them.

    #2209006
    Sam Farrington
    BPL Member

    @scfhome

    Locale: Chocorua NH, USA

    Not only lost this argument, but the nails keep being driven into the coffin.
    But will crack the coffin lid, and just croak that good filament wound carbon tubes are way better than cheap carbon, despite the price difference. That I know for sure.

    No longer an issue for me, as have gone to highly tempered alloy ski poles made in Europe. Scott Explor – Series 4. Made sturdy and weather resistant enough for skiing, very long grips for choking and telescoping 3-sections. Novel cam lock on upper joint that is easy to adjust in all weather and works better than either twist locks or flip locks. Feel safer with the alloy than even more expensive carbon from Japan. Just don't want to break and lose the use of a pole on longer treks when they are indispensable. Use only one pole, so it gets a lot of abuse no matter how careful I am. The extra two ounces (~8 oz) doesn't bother me at all.

Viewing 17 posts - 26 through 42 (of 42 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...