Topic

Long-Long-Long Term Test: Smartwool Long Johns


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums Gear Forums Gear (General) Long-Long-Long Term Test: Smartwool Long Johns

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1310914
    Max Dilthey
    Spectator

    @mdilthey

    Locale: MaxTheCyclist.com

    If anyone's wondering about the life of a pair of expensive Merino Wool tights, I've got the scoop:

    I bought these in May of 2012. In August of 2012, I wore them about 15 nights on a bike tour as sleeping tights.

    Then, I put them on underneath some pants in September and wore them every single day, 7 days a week, all winter until April when it warmed up. I used them sparingly this past summer as sleeping tights, and then in September I put them on again and wore them every single day until today, when I noticed a 1 inch hole in the crotch and retired them.

    I estimate I've got about 300+ days and nights in them, and would not be surprised if it was closer to 350.

    The threads along the seat and the center stitch in the crotch are wearing thin in rows, and there's a 1 x 1 inch hole along the center seam. Overall, though, they held up well- no seam failures at all and no substantial pilling. They got softer and softer.

    I washed them in a washing machine about once every three or four days, using cold water and low heat to dry them. Since all the wear is in the seat, where they contact the seams in my pants, I would say that washing them did not contribute to their lifespan.

    Obviously, I really like these. They got more use than any other piece of clothing I've ever owned. I have a matching top, but I wear these much more often.

    For the $63 I paid for them on sale, I am enormously pleased with their performance. They lasted a long time and kept me warm and comfortable in so many different conditions, from windy 60º days to frigid -20º nights. I've hiked in them, sat for 2 days straight on trains in them, gone to rock concerts in them, and worn them to weddings underneath my slacks. They never built up an odor once in the entire time I owned them, even after 30-day trips.

    I am going to try out Ibex Woolies 220 next to see if the durability is better. See you next year!

    #2053484
    Kattt
    BPL Member

    @kattt

    Max, I have had a similar experience with my Smartwool long johns. I bought mine four years ago and have worn them several days a week for three winters now, some in fall and on most backpacking trips with chilly temperatures. Mine are getting a little thinner in the inseam as well, but no holes yet. I have been very happy with these and they have helped keep me warm during many cold days at work and cold nights at home.
    I would think that if one's thighs rub together a lot they might wear out a little quicker.

    #2053487
    Ian
    BPL Member

    @10-7

    "I would think that if one's thighs rub together a lot they might wear out a little quicker."

    THAT WAS DIRECTED AT ME WASN'T IT?!?! Sorry…. little sensitive today.

    Carry on.

    #2053504
    Nick Gatel
    BPL Member

    @ngatel

    Locale: Southern California

    "The threads along the seat and the center stitch in the crotch are wearing thin in rows, and there's a 1 x 1 inch hole along the center seam."

    Use the hole as a fly and continue using them.

    #2053511
    Max Dilthey
    Spectator

    @mdilthey

    Locale: MaxTheCyclist.com

    I thought about replacing them outright, but I think I'm going to wear them into the ground underneath regular clothes while not on trips. I'll be wearing them this weekend while waiting outside of an arena for a Queens of the Stone Age concert.

    That's been a secret of mine for years; Merino Wool is the only fabric I know of that keeps you warm while you're waiting outside a rock show and then keeps you cool and comfy when the Lord of the Dance overtakes you in a crowd of warm bodies. Ha!

    I'm interested in seeing how Ibex compares in durability, though, so the Smartwools will be gradually phased out completely.

    #2053513
    Jerry Adams
    BPL Member

    @retiredjerry

    Locale: Oregon and Washington

    Nick, why are you fixated on flies? : )

    #2053526
    Max Dilthey
    Spectator

    @mdilthey

    Locale: MaxTheCyclist.com

    Katharina, since I'm a cyclist, my thighs keep getting wider and wider, so someday I might reach a singularity and start rubbing. Most of the bulk seems to be going straight out, though; between my knee and my hip, there's a "hill" sticking like two inches out…

    #2053533
    And E
    Spectator

    @lunchandynner

    Locale: Pacific Northwest

    I have the midweight tights too, and they're great.

    My only "issue" is that my crotch seems to run hotter than the rest of my body. I could benefit from some midweight tights with like, a wool mesh or lighter fabric for the crotch area.

    But, as far as durability, I agree. I've worn mine quite a bit hiking, sleeping in, and around town under my jeans when the mercury drops and they don't look any worse for wear.

    #2053535
    Nick Gatel
    BPL Member

    @ngatel

    Locale: Southern California

    "Nick, why are you fixated on flies?"

    Because it was the funniest thread ever. I should have posted a link to it.

    #2053542
    Jon Leibowitz
    BPL Member

    @jleeb

    Locale: New England

    Hey max,

    Have you ever given IceBreakers a try? I used to be huge smartwool junkie. After a few of my socks and a pair of boxer briefs developed holes rather quickly, I switched to IceBreakers. I've been exclusively wearing the same Icebreakers 150 weight long sleeve shirt on practically every hike (day hikes and backpacking trips) for the last 2.5 years. If you looked at it, you would think it was brand new.

    I have some friends that work at Ibex in Vermont. Great company and incredible products, but they tend to be more expensive for, what I can tell, is similar quality as Icebreakers. They do make fancier stuff though…I'm talking really about baselayers here.

    As a fellow lover of all things wool….my winter jacket is 100% wool along with almost of all of my layers for winter and summer….I can relate to your fondness of the best fabric ever created by nature! :)

    #2053554
    James holden
    BPL Member

    @bearbreeder-2

    as a reference point …

    i bought the MEC T2 boot cut logn johns old version 5 years ago …

    i wear em every 100+ days a year, 500-600 days total … and i sleep in em every one of those days … i wash em with regular detergent in a top loading washing machine with everything else … and i throw em in the dryer at normal heat … i climb in em under softshell pants .. etc …

    im wearing em right now

    and theres simply no wear … not a single hole or worn area yet …

    they cost me 20$ back then

    what weight is yr smartwool max?

    ;)

    #2053558
    Max Dilthey
    Spectator

    @mdilthey

    Locale: MaxTheCyclist.com

    The Smartwool longs were a medium weight, which I believe is the heaviest they make for long johns. Ibex is more expensive than Icebreaker, but not by much; the Ibex long johns are $10 less than Smartwool at full price (I paid $85). I actually owned a pair for a few days, but reverted back to my Smartwool ones because there was nom reason to own two. Ibex is rib-knit, so I think they'll be a little stronger than the single-weave Smartwool tights.

    I would like to get a longer life on the period of 600 days/nights, but realistically, $63 for that much longevity beats out every pair of cotton pants I've ever owned, and most of my socks/shirts as well.

    We will see if Ibex is the saving grace.

    #2053566
    Jerry Adams
    BPL Member

    @retiredjerry

    Locale: Oregon and Washington

    "I should have posted a link to it."

    Maybe better to be more obscure : )

    Trying to ruin this thread…

    #2053599
    Jon Leibowitz
    BPL Member

    @jleeb

    Locale: New England

    I'm wearing wool socks, wool underwear, and have my wool jacket with me. And I'm at work. I need wool dress shirts.

    Just sayin…. :)

    #2053602
    Max Dilthey
    Spectator

    @mdilthey

    Locale: MaxTheCyclist.com

    Wool socks, wool tights, wool shirt, wool hoodie right now.

    My pants pocket has an Icebreaker merino wool handkerchief. BOOM!

    Ibex made some wool dress shirts last year and I missed them. Always expensive.

    Edit: They're on Backcountry for like 15-25% off, neat!

    #2053675
    Rick M
    BPL Member

    @yamaguy

    del

    #2053678
    Max Dilthey
    Spectator

    @mdilthey

    Locale: MaxTheCyclist.com

    NEAT, will do. Dang, I did not know that!

    #2053760
    Eric Blumensaadt
    BPL Member

    @danepacker

    Locale: Mojave Desert

    Well, I have two pair of Cabela's polyester long john tops and bottoms that I have had for 18 years. Wore tehm XC ski patrolling, XC racing, hunting ans winter camping and now alpine ski patrolling for the past 6 years.

    Top THAT one.

    (And the elastic in the waist bands is still good!)

    #2053791
    Nick Gatel
    BPL Member

    @ngatel

    Locale: Southern California

    Nah, just a worsted wool suit. Silk is better for the rest of the ensemble at work.

    #2053847
    Kattt
    BPL Member

    @kattt

    ""I would think that if one's thighs rub together a lot they might wear out a little quicker."

    THAT WAS DIRECTED AT ME WASN'T IT?!?! Sorry…. little sensitive today.

    Carry on."

    Nah Ian…..my thighs get bigger in winter too….we need a little xtra padding when it's cold :)

    #2053848
    Kattt
    BPL Member

    @kattt

    "Katharina, since I'm a cyclist, my thighs keep getting wider and wider, so someday I might reach a singularity and start rubbing. Most of the bulk seems to be going straight out, though; between my knee and my hip, there's a "hill" sticking like two inches out…"

    Nice! I used to have biker legs years ago….Ahhh! I want that again. I want to do it all really. At 46 I have days with a lot of energy and not much seems impossible, then Iy catches up and I get tired and have to recoup a bit..

    #2054059
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Howdy Max,

    The Wooly long johns, are they 100 % wool, or a blend, and if the latter, what is the other fiber(s) and percentages?

    Wool with a good percentage of nylon, can be tougher and more durable when thinner and lighter.

Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...