Topic

This is why climbing Everest is stupid.


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums General Forums General Lightweight Backpacking Discussion This is why climbing Everest is stupid.

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1305928
    Kevin Burton
    BPL Member

    @burtonator

    Locale: norcal
    #2010312
    Stephen M
    BPL Member

    @stephen-m

    Locale: Way up North

    Wow, and I thought the amount of people I saw on last night trip was bad :-)

    #2010322
    Kevin B
    Spectator

    @kedward

    Locale: Portland, OR

    Seems red is in this year.

    #2010327
    Jim Colten
    BPL Member

    @jcolten

    Locale: MN

    I seem to recall that Yogi Berra had something to say about that kind of situation.

    #2010330
    Brandon M
    Spectator

    @s2bmay

    Locale: DC

    Yeah, no thankseverest

    #2010337
    Jeffs Eleven
    BPL Member

    @woodenwizard

    Locale: NePo

    Everybody conga to the top of the world!!!

    Don't cross the sherpa's ropes!!

    #2010339
    Bob Gross
    BPL Member

    @b-g-2-2

    Locale: Silicon Valley

    The photo that Brandon posted appears to be shot from the bottom of the Hillary Step on the Nepal side.

    Geez, they've made it almost into a staircase. That takes all of the fun out of it.

    –B.G.–

    #2010345
    Brandon M
    Spectator

    @s2bmay

    Locale: DC

    Bob, good eye. I came across that photo while reading an article talking about a potential plan to install a permanent ladder on the Hillary Step. How's that for taking the fun out of it!

    #2010479
    Ian
    BPL Member

    @10-7

    The good news is that they are building a strip mall there so you can get a fair-trade-venti-soy-mocha-latte-crapachino and take care of your dry cleaning while you’re waiting in line.

    #2010482
    Ken Thompson
    BPL Member

    @here

    Locale: Right there

    Put up a tram and be done with it. ADA accessible too.

    #2010485
    Ryan Slack
    Member

    @rwslack

    Locale: Minnesota

    Respect to the guy using the tumpline.

    #2010583
    Trace Richardson
    BPL Member

    @tracedef

    The other good news is that the Everest Conservancy Group has spurned McDonalds and Jack in the Box as their partner in providing a truly enjoyable dining experience atop Everest for the local favorite franchise, Sherpa Taco Shack.

    #2010615
    Misfit Mystic
    Member

    @cooldrip

    Locale: "Grand Canyon of the East"

    The whole idea of waiting around like that scares the crap out of me. I have no idea how the serious climbers NOT buying their way to the summit deal with that. IMO Everest is dead; the days of seeing leading-edge alpinism there are gone, replaced by this commercial "summit shuttle" they've created. That's alright, Alaska and other such places have 100 lifetimes' worth of wilderness alpine climbing. Beats going to the "amusement park" every time…

    #2010626
    Stuart .
    BPL Member

    @lotuseater

    Locale: Colorado

    "The good news is that they are building a strip mall there so you can get a fair-trade-venti-soy-mocha-latte-crapachino and take care of your dry cleaning while you’re waiting in line."

    The bad news is all espresso drinks are made with yak's butter. And it'll be a lukewarm crapochino as the boiling point atop Everest is a mere 71 °C (159.8 °F).

    #2010633
    ROBERT TANGEN
    Spectator

    @robertm2s

    Locale: Lake Tahoe

    No crowds there. Or, climb the south face of Lhotse, drop down to the South Col at 10:00 PM, top out on E, then drop down to the North Col. Or, climb straight up the North Face. If you can't find a challenge on the Big E, you're brain dead.

    #2010634
    Bob Salcedo
    Member

    @baughb

    Locale: So Cal.

    For the barefooted sherpa smoking a cigarette with 75 lbs strapped to his head taking a piss in the distance…

    #2010655
    David Thomas
    BPL Member

    @davidinkenai

    Locale: North Woods. Far North.

    This touches a nerve with me because just as I was getting to bed last night, my Facebook notifications lit up with lots of links to a friend, Marty Schmidt, who grew up across the street (our parents still live there) in Castro Valley, CA and was in my Boy Scout troop. I found my challenges and peace of mind on the trail, but he found his in more technical and harshly beautiful places. He went into the USAF with the intention of going into SAR. By finishing first in his class, he got to pick his assignment, went to Alaska, climbing Denali while on leave and upon discharge, guided Denali in the winter while commuting to New Zealand where he raised his family.

    Then he went on to guiding Everest, doing alpine style, self-supported trips for more capable clients while doing his own more cutting edge climbs. He was last on Everest with clients last month. His 25-year-old son met up afterwards and they were on K2 hoping to be the first father-son team to summit. They remained in Camp 3 after a storm and, all signs indicate, were swept away in an avalanche yesterday (or maybe the word got out yesterday?).

    There are consolations – the things you tell yourself which are perfectly true like, "They were doing what they loved.", "Marty was so active, alive and enthusiastic about everything he did, he fit many lifetimes into his 53 years." and "We've each lost a son, but his pain and awareness of that was for seconds or less." Still, I didn't sleep very well last night.

    Is "trying to the first xxxxx" akin to "hey, guys, watch this?" as potentially one's last words? The other person I knew who died in the Himalayas, Marty Hoey, was trying to be the first US woman to summit Everest.

    Not my cup of tea, precisely because of the danger and that there are such significant risks you can minimize only so much. But I'll queue up for the cables on Half Dome or walk past hundreds of people on the Bright Angel in GCNP, so I'm not going to fault someone for doing that at 25,000 feet.

    #2010657
    Bob Gross
    BPL Member

    @b-g-2-2

    Locale: Silicon Valley

    "If you can't find a challenge on the Big E, you're brain dead."

    The Kangshung Face is more than a challenge. It is more of a death wish.

    –B.G.–

    #2010696
    Misfit Mystic
    Member

    @cooldrip

    Locale: "Grand Canyon of the East"

    Gotta agree with Bob here; the Kangshung Face is a deathtrap with those hanging glaciers. The North Face looks to be worse. What I really lament is the permit system; the only way to make an attempt is to pony up huge money, or find a sponsor willing to do the same. I'll never be a sponsored alpinist, but I'll bet my abilities, though declining with age and infrequent use, exceed the vast majority of "clients" on Everest. The cost of an Everest trip would be a financial impossibility for me or most of the climbers I've ever known. Whereas Czech Direct on Denali, or the Polish Route on Anconcagua, would be something doable, at least financially. Of course, you gotta have the skills; nobody's fixing ropes and ladders up those routes for you.

    This isn't a knock on the responsible guide services on Everest, they seem to be the last remnant of sanity on the mountain. But there are irresponsible guides as well, ones who are more than willing to take under-prepared, inexperienced clients. It's all about money for these folks, regardless of the potential consequences. And the permit system does nothing to regulate this, it's merely a revenue-generating scheme. This needs to change, or things will get a lot worse. The crowds have gotten bigger since 1996, and I bet the skill level and experience of the average climber has gone down with so many services in operation now. It's only a matter of time before the crowding contributes to another major incident.

    #2010706
    Scott Bentz
    BPL Member

    @scottbentz

    Locale: Southern California

    First of all David, I am sorry for your loss. Even though people are killed "doing what they love", it still is a loss. Climbers like that are really wired differently.

    On my trip home from Lake Powell last month we listened to "Into Thin Air". I have read it before but it was interesting to go through it again. Everest is still quite the risky endeavor, especially, with all the guided groups. I think if Jon Krakauer had been on his own and not tied to a group he would have summited and been back in camp five hours earlier missing the storm by even more time.

    Those that did lose their lives, and they were some of the best, did so probably because the margin for error is so low up there. Those few hours made all the difference. Also, they did not turn back when they knew it was getting too late. Once again, probably due to the need to get a client to the top. It is something I will leave to others.

    So far, I've only been to 14,500 on a hiking trail. I'm pretty happy with that.

    #2010710
    Misfit Mystic
    Member

    @cooldrip

    Locale: "Grand Canyon of the East"

    Just saw your post concerning your friend. I'm sorry for your loss. A climber willing to test himself against K2 is one of the greats in my book. I imagine he was like the truly great alpinists I've met: an amazing person regardless of his climbing exploits. While it's no consolation I know, I'm glad he was with his son, and in a place so remarkable, when his time came.

    #2010751
    James holden
    BPL Member

    @bearbreeder-2

    how many people here have done the gongshow on half dome?

    most climbers think that hiking up halfdome is "stupid" … if you dont have the skills to do the easy 5.7 (one move wonder route) you shouldnt go up it at all

    what people do is up to them … if they want to wait in line thats their choice … if they want to spend $$$$$, thats also their choice … better than wasting it on blo n hookahs IMO …

    almost everyone here havent been and will never go up everest … almost everyone here will armchair general those with the drive to be up there though

    ;)

    is this you ??????

    #2010761
    Jeffs Eleven
    BPL Member

    @woodenwizard

    Locale: NePo

    I bet there's a pic of the AT like that too

Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...