Topic

Still going without tp?


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums Gear Forums Gear (General) Still going without tp?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 26 through 50 (of 83 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1968163
    d k
    BPL Member

    @dkramalc

    "they generally don't have any hair down there, or shouldn't…"

    WHAATTTT????

    I hope you're joking.

    #1968165
    Randy Martin
    BPL Member

    @randalmartin

    Locale: Colorado

    I use a product called Gotta Go Waste Bags, however, I don't take the bags themselves just the package of powder they provide that contains enzymes and bacterial agents that speed decomposition of feces into organic soil. After doing your business you can sprinkle some of the powder, cover with soil.

    http://www.greentoilet.net/products-/biodegadable-waste-bags

    #1968166
    Nick Larsen
    Member

    @stingray4540

    Locale: South Bay

    Little bit of a rant there Nate? Or was that sarcasm? Not sure if serious.

    Not sure where you camp, but the outhouses I've used have always been in pretty good shape. Even next to lakes covered with empty worm containers and fishing line.

    If you burn and bury your TP, ain't much litter left.

    Some people where never taught growing up how to clean up with anything other than TP, but if you want to host a skills workshop at REI, I'm sure the classes will sell out.

    #1968168
    EndoftheTrail
    BPL Member

    @ben2world-2

    Yep.

    Do my business, cup the hand and wash with water. Apply a dollop of Purell. No need to dry, unless you are wearing cotton — heaven forbid. Polyester dries in just moments.

    In my view, the best and most thorough cleaning is, of course, a full shower. Following that would be the method I just described. Pushing toilet paper around and around one's asshole cleans even less. But regardless of TP or no TP — wash and/or sanitize your hands before returning to camp. :)

    #1968170
    Kattt
    BPL Member

    @kattt

    #1968173
    David Thomas
    BPL Member

    @davidinkenai

    Locale: North Woods. Far North.

    >"I'm aware that stirring up the soup and mixing in natural material will help the waste break down quicker but I was wondering if adding a pinch of septic tank pro biotics would help speed the process along."

    This comes rather close to my day job – the clean up of contaminated waste sites. Various practitioners and vendors offer their propriety bacteria that are supposedly optimized for different contaminants. The thing is, at least a dozen species of soil bacteria can metabolize gasoline and diesel-range hydrocarbons, amazing though that may seem. What you deposit is even easier for them to digest and is already loaded with bacteria.

    If you want to help the process, here are things that universally help aerobic bacterial action: atmospheric air (poop in loose soil, not tight clay), water (pee in the same hole), fertilizer (pee in the same hole), and warmth (a south-facing, exposed-to-the-sun patch of soil will be >10C warmer in the summer at a 6" depth than a shaded area).

    I don't suggest the following for several reasons, but if you (1) added a pinch of Scott lawn fertilizer, (2) stirred well, and (3) dusted the replaced surface with carbon-black soot (to increase solar heating); you'd increase the degradation rate at least 10-fold. Sewer treatment plants, with active management of oxygen and nutrients, can degrade human waste in about a day. In more controlled settings, I can take toxic-waste-containing water to drinking water standards in less than an hour.

    An afterthought: for how helpful peeing in the hole is (especially in the dry summer Sierra), and to avoid peeing on the shorts around your ankles, how about this: Dig the hole. Pee on the spoils pile. Do #2 in the cat hole. Stir in the wettest soils. Finish filling hole. Cover with leaf litter.

    #1968176
    Kattt
    BPL Member

    @kattt

    "I notice a lot more women have an easier time going without TP"
    Huh? I think some anatomy lessons are due here…

    #1968179
    Ian
    BPL Member

    @10-7

    "Please post when you find baby wipes that decompose."

    http://www.target.com/p/attitude-eco-baby-biodegradable-baby-wipes-216-count/-/A-13313851

    http://www.coolmompicks.com/2009/04/biodegradable_baby_wipes_that.php

    http://ecosalon.com/reduce-your-childs-carbon-bumprint/

    Because I won't be able to sleep unless I know that my pooping will meet Nate's approval, I will return to using marmots. You people with your pocket calculators and VCRs….

    #1968180
    David Thomas
    BPL Member

    @davidinkenai

    Locale: North Woods. Far North.

    >"It's number one that I need to figure out what to do…"

    Jennifer: using grass or a twig to flick pubic hair back and forth removes most all of the urine.

    >"not surprising since they generally don't have any hair down there, or shouldn't…"

    Nick: Quite true for a Brownie troop or anyone posing as a prepubescent girl. But adult women are mammals, too.

    #1968182
    Nick Larsen
    Member

    @stingray4540

    Locale: South Bay

    "Huh? I think some anatomy lessons are due here…"

    My comment was in regards to #2.

    I'd have less qualms about other cleaning methods if I was just dealing with urine.

    #1968190
    Peter S
    BPL Member

    @prse

    Locale: Denmark

    Yes

    Faster, lighter and cleaner for me and mother nature….and the next guy!

    It's a basic skill. Learn it and don't look back.

    #1968192
    Angus A.
    BPL Member

    @mangus7175

    Locale: http://theshadedtrail.blogspot.com

    For those that can't squat there is the Loop N' Poop or Strap N' Crap

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vf2OwIcgEDw

    #1968201
    Ian
    BPL Member

    @10-7

    All joking and snarkiness aside, you people have convinced me to adopt a natural cleaning regimen. I will turn over a new leaf this season…. literally.

    (editor's note – no marmots were harmed in the trolling of this thread)

    #1968202
    David Thomas
    BPL Member

    @davidinkenai

    Locale: North Woods. Far North.

    >"(editor's note – no marmots were harmed in the trolling of this thread)"

    The bear asks the rabbit: "Don't you hate how the crap sticks to your fur?"

    Rabbit, "Crap doesn't stick to my fur."

    Bear: "Good." Visual: bear grabs rabbit and wipes himself.

    #1968204
    Ian
    BPL Member

    @10-7

    David,

    Thanks for your input on this topic. I enjoy reading your comments and appreciate your technical expertise.

    I'm going to use your suggestions to improve my cat hole technique but I understand that you don't suggest pro biotics or fertilizer? Is this for environmental reasons or for weight? If only a pinch of fertilizer is needed, it would seem that an oz per movement would cover it and I'd be willing to carry it if it would appreciably reduce the impact.

    #1968208
    Tony Ronco
    BPL Member

    @tr-browsing

    LOL !! funniest thing I've seen in a long time. Thanks Mangus for posting!

    #1968209
    spelt with a t
    BPL Member

    @spelt

    Locale: Rangeley, ME

    As usual, a thread about poop is enlightening, entertaining, and horrifying by turns (Purell, Ben?!?! Alcohol-based gel anywhere near a mucus membrane or orifice sounds like a recipe for regret).

    #1968210
    Angus A.
    BPL Member

    @mangus7175

    Locale: http://theshadedtrail.blogspot.com

    Here's another video posted by Andrew Skurka a few years back

    -Backcountry Poo-Poo Clinic-

    YouTube video

    #1968211
    Bean
    BPL Member

    @stupendous-2

    Locale: California

    "Bear: "Good." Visual: bear grabs rabbit and wipes himself."

    Heard that joke as a kid, and immediately it didn't make sense to me, because a rabbit would make very poor toilet paper if crap didn't actually stick to his fur.

    #1968216
    HkNewman
    BPL Member

    @hknewman

    Locale: The West is (still) the Best

    If only a pinch of fertilizer is needed,

    The "deposit" itself is actually fertilizer, though modern man bags it from cows and markets it as manure through ye olde' big box home improvement store. Depends on the microenvironment of the "deposit" is how fast it and any accompanying tissue decays (your own conscious and the land manager rules/regs). Leaves and stones work with hand sanitation and it's a good practice because there comes a time when one finds themselves tp-less … but it's always good to have a "reserve" of tp/blue towel squares/etc.. in the pack just in case.

    Think we can all find common sense solution but also check your land management office if "deposits" are even allowed. That would be an embarrassing ticket from a ranger…

    (ed: add)

    #1968220
    David Thomas
    BPL Member

    @davidinkenai

    Locale: North Woods. Far North.

    Ian: The pro-biotics are unnecessary. If the topsoils can support life, it is already there. Even in a sand dune, you're depositing trillions of bacteria with every dump.

    I wouldn't suggest carrying fertilizer. There's a fair bit of biologically available NPK (nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium – the building blocks of DNA, proteins and enzymes) in poop and pee. If you were burying something without built-in fertilizer (paper only, clothing, gasoline in my work), then added fertilizer can make a big difference in kicking off development of a large bio mass.

    Adding excess fertilizer would be a bad thing. Nitrates and nitrites are groundwater and surface water pollutants (they can lead to algae blooms in warm waters). Dissolved fertilizers can travel much further than bacteria – a well functioning septic leach field does all it's work with 2 feet of the perforated pipe, leaving no bacteria percolating deeper into the ground.

    I was giving a pull-out-all-the-stops approach. Stuff I do to clean up a decades-old toxic waste site in months. For me, best backpacking practices would be:

    Do it in a warm spot, mix with soil, add some water if easy. Those steps will result in many-fold faster degradation. And they weigh nothing.

    #1968223
    David Thomas
    BPL Member

    @davidinkenai

    Locale: North Woods. Far North.

    >"because a rabbit would make very poor toilet paper if crap didn't actually stick to his fur."

    Explaining a joke kills it, but:

    It's not that rabbit fur is teflon. It's that vegan rabbit pellets aren't sticky. Omnivore bears, on the other hand. . . . Therein lies the humor, such as it was.

    #1968226
    Bean
    BPL Member

    @stupendous-2

    Locale: California

    "Anyone still going w/o tp?"

    Did my first few TP free trips last year, previous years I'd use Corn Lily leaves and rocks most the time, but would take a little TP for the final clean up. It was very liberating to get beyond that and not have to deal with dirty paper anymore.

    My girlfriend is fighting it though, and even though I've suggested she pack it out, she only brings back paper after peeing. After pooping she comes back and says, "don't look at me like that!". I think I somewhat enabled her by mentioning in her company to backpacking friends, that if people were going to be obstinate and leave their TP in the woods, they should at least dig a separate hole for the TP and stir it up with water and dirt so it doesn't end up being recognizable if dug up.

    I think she needs is a good "how to" video with a woman instructor, in order to take away all her objections that women are somehow so different to men that pooping without TP is a life threatening practice.

    #1968232
    Bean
    BPL Member

    @stupendous-2

    Locale: California

    "Explaining a joke kills it,"

    When I was a kid my dad's response was, "and bears and rabbits don't talk either".

    #1968234
    EndoftheTrail
    BPL Member

    @ben2world-2

    " It was very liberating"

    Indeed. Heck, when I was a newbie back in 2004 — my virgin overnight trip — I wasn't scared of getting lost or getting eaten by lions — no — my big concern was how to do business without modern plumbing! I decided to try by going the full nine yards — and indeed, it was most liberating. And since that trip, I've never carried TP for Business No. 2 out in the wilds. Still use TP at home though — but followed by a wash as well.

    Although in truth, this most natural of acts shouldn't be any kind of a big deal at all. Just shows how much we are prisoners of our own culture — for better and for worse.

Viewing 25 posts - 26 through 50 (of 83 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...