Topic

Another Data Point for Those Considering SPOT (vs PLB)


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums Gear Forums Gear (General) Another Data Point for Those Considering SPOT (vs PLB)

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1291452
    NoCO-Jim
    BPL Member

    @noco-jim

    Locale: NoCO

    "Neverthless, a GPS-enabled 406 EPIRB is still Practical Sailor's first choice for satellite-based distress signaling."

    http://www.practical-sailor.com/blog/-10824-1.html?ET=practicalsailor:e1571:171589a:&st=email

    SPOT

    #1890630
    Randy Martin
    BPL Member

    @randalmartin

    Locale: Colorado

    Good report.

    Conclusion

    SPOT = Send I am OK and tracking messages to family/friends.
    PLB = When life saving response is required

    #1890632
    Brett Ayer
    Spectator

    @bfayer

    Locale: Virginia

    It sounds like SPOT did just what they said they would do.

    From their web site:

    "IMPORTANT NOTE:
    Even if SPOT cannot acquire its location from the GPS network it will still attempt to send a distress signal – without exact location – to GEOS, which will still notify your contacts of the signal and continue to monitor the network for further messages."

    The story makes it sound like SPOT did something wrong, when they did exactly what they said they would do. It also sounds like a case of someone picking the wrong emergency contact (calls going to voice mail when sleeping).

    I would suggest that if you are going to hire a company to call an emergency contact when you need help, you should pick one that will actually take the call.

    The SPOT is not an ELT or EPIRB and should not be used to replace one. U.S. Sailing requires competitors to carry 406 water activated EPIRBs. SPOT messengers are used for tracking by competitors, not emergency purposes. There is obviously more to this story we don't know, but the writer for some reason is trying to make SPOT look bad without knowing all the facts.

    #1890656
    Larry De La Briandais
    BPL Member

    @hitech

    Locale: SF Bay Area

    Spot tracking recently allowed investigators to determine what happened to a sailboat that sank killing everyone onboard. It ran into an island at night. The spot track showed that it traveled straight into the island.

    #1890721
    Mike W
    BPL Member

    @skopeo

    Locale: British Columbia

    I agree that there is more to this story than what has been reported here.

    I know that boaters often carry Spots for the instant tracking feature (especially in races) but they should also have a PLB on-board. So did this guy only have a Spot?

    I'd be interested in knowing why the Spot didn't get a GPS fix when it was on the open ocean? I know mine is really poor under tree cover but on the water I expect it to acquire a signal.

    I am really surprised that Spot's team didn't notify Search and Rescue but I have to admit, that having a third party involved in the notification process really does worry me as well. If I was an adventurer that was getting into high risk situations, I'd probably carry both a PLB and a Spot (for the tracking) or at the very least a PLB.

    For me, I consider the Spot an "I'm OK" check-in gadget that "might" work for my OK messages and I will prey that the SOS button works on the off chance that something actually does happen to me (kind of a better than nothing rationale with me…). At least I would have a shot a getting rescued which is much better than past years when I carried nothing (OK maybe a mirror).

    I will add one thing that is often over-looked when discussing the Spot Connect (vs a regular Spot). The Spot Connect can work with a smart phone and can send custom messages, so if you are "with it" and physically capable, you can pull GPS coordinates from your handheld GPS or your GPS enabled phone and send a custom SOS distress message from your Spot Connect that includes your coordinates. Nice to have the ability to add your own coordinates to the message just in case the Spot can't pick up a GPS position (and IME, Spots don't seem very good at getting satellite locks). After that, I'd have to hope the Spot team would know what to do with the coordinates that I sent in my message… but at least I'd have a shot at a rescue!

    #1890727
    Jeremy and Angela
    BPL Member

    @requiem

    Locale: Northern California

    This:

    "IMPORTANT NOTE:
    Even if SPOT cannot acquire its location from the GPS network it will still attempt to send a distress signal – without exact location – to GEOS, which will still notify your contacts of the signal and continue to monitor the network for further messages."

    I'm wondering if someone at GEOS dropped the ball on this, as the article gives the impression that a only single call was made. (No additional calls to the wife, no calls to Coast Guard, etc). If they were just following their policy, I would hope they revise it immediately as that sort of response is completely inappropriate for an SOS signal.

    #1890744
    M B
    BPL Member

    @livingontheroad

    Satellite based distress signals are a luxury we have today. Unfortunately they replace common sense and discretion too often.

    It is important to remember that NOBODY has any obligation to come and rescue your sorry ass. It is only done generally because we care about other people.

    Spot sells distress notification service, they dont sell rescue service. No guarantees come with ANY distress signal.

    Anyone on a boat depending on a spot would be a damned fool. Boats venturing offshore need EPIRB's. In Australia they are REQUIRED for any boat going more that 2 miles offshore.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...