Topic

More durable hiking poles?


Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Home Forums Gear Forums Gear (General) More durable hiking poles?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1280721
    Brett Peugh
    BPL Member

    @bpeugh

    Locale: Midwest

    I was wondering if anyone had a pair of ligthweight hiking poles they could suggest as it seems some of the carbon fiber ones are snapping when people are falling or putting too much wieght on them. Thanks.

    #1791544
    Ryan C
    BPL Member

    @radio_guy

    Locale: United States

    Carbon fiber poles concerned me as well. Picked up a pair of Black Diamond Trail Ergo Cork with Flick Locks and am overall happy with them, they are just pretty heavy. They have been used in places reliably where I feel a carbon fiber pole would have snapped for sure but that is mostly due to carrying a 35-40lb pack for off-trail bushwhacking along with tricky scree fields.

    If I were to do it all over though, I would get a pair of Gossamer Gear LT4s and just take it easy on them.

    #1791557
    drowning in spam
    Member

    @leaftye

    Locale: SoCal

    GG's should be fine as long as you're not using it in the snow. That's how I broke mine. I've also used Black Diamond carbon poles and they look and feel much stronger, but I have not used them in the same conditions that I broke my GG pole. I'm not really sure that any pole would hold up though since I saw MANY bent aluminum trekking poles out there.

    #1791559
    Dale Wambaugh
    BPL Member

    @dwambaugh

    Locale: Pacific Northwest

    I'm using Black Diamond Trail poles and light they are not, but they *work*. I see that REI got out of the carbon pole business and I wouldn't be surprised to hear that it was because of returns. They get plenty of returns on damaged aluminum poles let alone the carbon models.

    IMHO, it is like SUL packs: you are willing to put up with the compromises or not. You do trust poles with your well being in some situations, so you want them to work ALL the time. I would just get an aluminum non-shock absorbing flick-lock design in the 16oz-19oz range and be done with it.

    #1791560
    Tyler Fisher
    Member

    @qtrlbrwchs

    Locale: northern california

    I have a pair of the REI UL peak poles they are carbon fiber and have twist locks. The poles are made by komperdell and weigh 12.3 oz. on my scale. IMO they are plenty sturdy, I have had the tips wedge in between rocks and such as my body continued to move forward many times and surprisingly they havent snapped. I recommended them to a friend but she hasn't been able to find them, maybe try REI Outlet.

    I also use them as my snowshoeing and skiing poles.

    #1791566
    Sumi Wada
    Spectator

    @detroittigerfan

    Locale: Ann Arbor

    The REI UL Peaks, as much as I liked them, are the only poles that have ever failed on me. The twist locks wouldn't tighten, first one then the other. I couldn't even pull them apart to fiddle with the mechanism (nor could anyone at REI.) They were 5 months old.

    I was willing to exchange them for a new pair but they've been discontinued and, as far as I know, are completely gone and no longer available, even at the Outlet.

    I do really notice the weight differences, more than I thought I would. I've replaced the Peaks with the Black Diamond Distance; the aluminum version instead of the CF ones. Comparable weight as the Peaks, folds up super small (much easier to fly with) and have great straps (hand-specific.) They feel solid to me. Also ended up getting a pair of the Fizans for tarp-setups. Also aluminum at comparable low weights but not sure I'm confident about their twist-locks yet.

    #1791569
    Andy F
    Spectator

    @andyf

    Locale: Midwest/Midatlantic

    Another Black Diamond Trail user here. They're nearly 20 oz/pair. I only use them in rougher/slippery/snow conditions, and I want a durable pole to match the conditions. Otherwise, I use the lightest poles: none.

    #1791710
    Paul Ashton
    Member

    @pda123

    Locale: Eastern Mass

    1/2" bamboo will make poles of whatever length suits you, very strong, very inexpensive, and weighing about 10 oz. – which is lighter than any carbon poles. Cost about $1 each and you won't cry when you fall over them and break them. However, they are amazingly strong, so it is unlikely that you will break them.

    #1791722
    Bob Gross
    BPL Member

    @b-g-2-2

    Locale: Silicon Valley

    Bamboo was commonly used for cross-country ski poles about 35 years ago, and there were simple ways of making it stronger to reduce breakage. Then fiberglas or aluminum poles took over the market, and it is hard to find bamboo poles anymore (except possibly stored in my garage).

    –B.G.–

    #1791731
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    "1/2" bamboo will make poles of whatever length suits you, very strong, very inexpensive, and weighing about 10 oz. – which is lighter than any carbon poles."

    Except the Gossamer Gear LT's and Titanium Goat poles. That I know of.

    #1791741
    spelt with a t
    BPL Member

    @spelt

    Locale: Rangeley, ME

    Where do you find bamboo locally? I have been unable to source it except via internet.

    #1791777
    Nick Gatel
    BPL Member

    @ngatel

    Locale: Southern California

    They wear down pretty quickly. So if you do find some, need some sort of a cup on the bottom. We used to use them for staffs back in the day.

    #1791791
    Rick Dreher
    BPL Member

    @halfturbo

    Locale: Northernish California

    I've been using Komperdell and Leki CF 3-piece poles for six and five years, respectively. They've taken all the abuse I can throw at them, have doubled as shelter supports (including siamesed as a pyramid pole). They're scraped, scratched and nicked up, as one might expect, and are still fine.

    My conclusion is it's not the material, it's how the material is spec'd and the overall pole design. A properly designed and made CF pole should not fail.

    (FWIW I've used aluminum and yes, bamboo poles too. CF for me, thanks.)

    Cheers,

    Rick

    #1791817
    Scott S
    Member

    @sschloss1

    Locale: New England

    I've got the Leki CF poles, and I love them. Mine have well over 3000 miles on them now, including plenty of slips/falls, and they're still in great shape.

    One nice thing about the Lekis is that they come with a 1-year full replacement guarantee, even if you break the shaft.

    #1791838
    Tyler Fisher
    Member

    @qtrlbrwchs

    Locale: northern california

    I've had the same issue with the twist-locks on my REI poles (not tightening) if you just loosen them enough to adjust and then tighten it's not a problem and they do come apart, at least mine do, fairly easily. But it seems they are hard to find. I do have quite a bit of bamboo in my yard if anyone really wants some bamboo trekking poles.

    or ski poles.

    #1791848
    James holden
    BPL Member

    @bearbreeder-2

    CF Komperdell poles for me … havent snapped yet

    IMO though whatever poles you get you should get flick locks if youd desire adjustables … twist locks IMO can be unreliable and hard to repair in the field …

    #1791916
    Mark Dijkstra
    Member

    @markacd

    I'm a big fan of the Fizan Compact poles. Fizan claims they're the lightest aluminium collapsable poles in the world (slightly under 12 oz/pair if I remember correctly). They can take quite a bit of punnishment too. During a trip last summer I fell during a slippery descent. I landed with all my weight on one of my poles. I'm pretty sure any carbon pole would've snapped, but this pole was just a little bent. It still functions perfectly. I also like the price, which is about half of what most other ligtweigt poles cost. I think I paid about $80 for mine.

    #1791920
    spelt with a t
    BPL Member

    @spelt

    Locale: Rangeley, ME

    >> They wear down pretty quickly. So if you do find some, need some sort of a cup on the bottom. We used to use them for staffs back in the day.

    The one I use now has a 12 ga. shell on the bottom. :)

    #1792168
    Paul Ashton
    Member

    @pda123

    Locale: Eastern Mass

    Bamboo poles can usually be found at any garden center. I found a whole bunch at a decorating accessory store called "Home Goods". They cost just about 25 cents each.
    Thanks for pointing out that Gossamer Gear poles are even lighter. However, I hike on a budget, so I'll stick with my bamboo and take the 4 or 5 oz penalty.

    #1792498
    Brett Peugh
    BPL Member

    @bpeugh

    Locale: Midwest

    Currently I have a pair of the Leki Super Makalu Tour Cor-tec from about 5 years ago. They are solid but do weigh a bunch and I was just looking for something that might weigh less and preform just as well.

    #1792747
    James Klein
    BPL Member

    @jnklein21

    Locale: Southeast

    I replaced the stock handle on a pair fliplock "outdoor products" poles with eva foam grips. End result was just under 14oz/pr (were probably 20-21oz stock), 3 section, very rugged feeling poles for $40.

    http://www.backpackinglight.com/cgi-bin/backpackinglight/forums/thread_display.html?forum_thread_id=50320&skip_to_post=426839#426839

    #1792843
    Eric Blumensaadt
    BPL Member

    @danepacker

    Locale: Mojave Desert

    Does anyone make a hybrid hiking pole with an aluminum lower section and carbon fiber in the upper section(s)?

    Please post if you know of any.

    In my experience with CF cross country racing ski poles it's the bottom 1/3 that's most vulnerable to lateral damage, the most common cause of CF pole breakage.
    Having dealt with an (expensive) broken CF racing pole I shy away from
    ('spensive)CF hiking poles.

    #1793193
    Rick M
    BPL Member

    @yamaguy

    del

    #1793196
    Rick Dreher
    BPL Member

    @halfturbo

    Locale: Northernish California

    Yes, Black Diamond Contour Elliptic Carbons are one such pole.

    Cheers,

    Rick

    #1793201
    Mike M
    BPL Member

    @mtwarden

    Locale: Montana

    my BD carbon corks while not the lightest set of poles out there (16 oz for the pair) have proven very sturdy- I've taken a couple of good spills (hiking and snowshoeing) and they are no worse for the wear. The Flicklock setup is also as solid of an adjuster as I've seen

    I probably look at the G4's weekly :), but I don't really want to give up the sturdiness of the BD's

Viewing 25 posts - 1 through 25 (of 25 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Forum Posting

A Membership is required to post in the forums. Login or become a member to post in the member forums!

Get the Newsletter

Get our free Handbook and Receive our weekly newsletter to see what's new at Backpacking Light!

Gear Research & Discovery Tools


Loading...