Oct 25, 2010 at 10:21 am #1264776
I just noticed that Sawyer is now making a clean / dirty bag gravity filter just like the ones from Platty & MSR. I purchased a MSR gravity filter two months ago and this was not on the market then.
There appears to be no advantages over the Platty & MSR version, except the filter does look like it will be much lighter and is not "overbuilt" and armored with rubber the way the Platty & MSR models are.
I have not found just the filter for sale but did find a "gravity filter kit" without the clean/dirty bags which allows you to hook it up to your faucet at home or take it out into the field:
The listed weight of this entire setup with hoses & connectors is only 2 oz and I am thinking about replacing the filter that came with my MSR with this one to reduce it's weight – does anyone have any experience with this filter or know how much it weighs on it's own?
It filters down to .1 micron which is better then the all others and it can be backflushed in the field, it's a hollow-fiber filter just like the others. I really like my MSR gravity filter, it was the only one with a built in pre-filter but it's just a bit to heavy and I think this might bring the total weight of my setup down a few ounces and actually give better performance. Any thoughts on this?Oct 25, 2010 at 10:45 am #1657821
Many people on the forums use the Sawyer filter with a platypus as a MYOG gravity system. I have what appears to be the previous generation of the filter (mine is all black) with a slightly different connection system. Sawyer filters are great and can be backflushed at home after the trip or on the trail as well. The only thing you have to worry about is cold temperatures and the filter freezing. Just pack a zip-lock bag and throw it in the bottom of your sleeping bag/quilt if you thing temps will dip that low.
The advantage over the platypus system for me was the weight and that i already owned the necessary clean/dirty containers.
I think my system using some tubing, Sawyer filter, 2L platypus with bottom cutout as 'dirty' container weighs in at 6oz.Oct 25, 2010 at 11:14 am #1657830
AT some point i am going to make a system as follows:
Cuben water scoop bag -> MSR silt stopper -> Sawyer filter -> platy container.
Hopefully i can get rid of the penalty of using the silt stopper via the cuben bag. Allowing me to get alot more life out of my filter by feeding it cleaner water. In the winter, i will hike with the filter element in a jacket pocket. Be careful putting it in a sleeping bag, as it may leak out and your bag will get wet.Oct 25, 2010 at 11:48 am #1657839
you are cutting the bottom out of on of the platys and using it as a scoop that way? How do you attach a line to the platypus in order to attach it to a tree for filtering? I normally punch holes in the bottom of the platy(the extra plastic), werap ductape around the line so it doesn't cut into the plastic after repeated use.Oct 25, 2010 at 12:06 pm #1657846
Ike, You can cut out only the bottom of the platy 2l, and still keep the sides where you would punch holes through. The bottom is billowed so that it stands upright. The edges of the bottle go past the bottom as well, so its possible to remove the bottom with precision, and have a functional scoop, yet still have the hard plastic laminated sides to string rope throughOct 25, 2010 at 12:10 pm #1657847
This exactly describes my setup. I copied it from my dad because it works so well. I'll post up a photo later to better illustrated what I have going.Oct 25, 2010 at 12:12 pm #1657850
i was just attaching my line to the billowed sides and reinforcing it. Do you have a pic of yours? sounds better.Oct 25, 2010 at 2:02 pm #1657887
I like your idea, what do you plan to use for the hose connection to the bag, have you found a elbow connection with a flat base that could be glued to a hole cut in the cuben bag?
I could cut up my MSR dirty bag and use its elbow connector with the pre-filter attached……Oct 25, 2010 at 2:28 pm #1657894Oct 25, 2010 at 6:13 pm #1657962
As promised , here are some photos of my Sawyer/Platypus Setup – 6oz
Filter package all wrapped up. I use the small cord to hang off of sturdy branches, rocks, or by hand. It works great to wrap back on itself to close the filter package up tight.
I carefully cut out the bottom of a 2L Platypus.
The full setup.
Dirty water bladder.
Clean water end, w/ repurposed Camelbak hose.
By using the screw lids it prevents the 'clean' water to overfill and loose the rest of the water. I haven't had the need but I imagine I could rig up a shower with this same setup. As opposed to Aqua Mira I don't have to wait to drink the water and the filter takes less than 10 minutes (2L) if you're doing it trailside.Oct 26, 2010 at 8:46 am #1658123
i have decided to revise my plan for a filter. i will no longer be using the siltstopper, biodisel micron filter bags are much cheaper. bought in bulk they are something like a dollar a bag. the only thing i am unsure about is what size micron bag i shoukd order:1, .5, 5? if i order too small the flow rate will be affected, too big and i lessen the life of the sawyer.
the bag will be sewn to my cuben collection bag. i believe the bag will allow me to use the sawyer purifier instead of the filter, giving me a totally effective system. i will also not be slowing the gravitational filtering force by sticking a siltstopper in the middle of the process-slowing down the flow.
ken larson has reported good results with this setup: 9 days no change in flow rate or stoppages.
so the final setup will be like:
biodiesel bag-cuben bag-sawyer-hydration drinking platy.Oct 26, 2010 at 11:32 am #1658181
I too was considering a pre-filter- the Siltstopper, at $10 a filter – but the light went back on when I remembered my reason for going with the Saywer in the first place.
You can backflush in the field to restore functionality. So if most water is "pretty good" anyway, why bother with a pre-filter? IF things get slow in the field I can deal with it. At home I'll backflush as part of the cleanup and PM routine.
It comes back to "Don't pack your fears".Oct 26, 2010 at 12:10 pm #1658193
im not a making a prefilter setup because im afraid of dirty water or device failure, im making it to prolong the lifespan of my mainfilter, thats the purpose of prefilters. before i buy anything i do research for a long time. i"ve been considering updating my filter setup for a year. i was considering the siltstopper.", but micron fuel prefilter bags do the same thing way cheaper and dont slow down flow rate. its about making the right purchase first so you dont have to end up eith a gear closet full of useless gear and an empty wallet. i want to make this setup as easy to use, reliable, long lasting, cost effective, and light(as long as im not sacrificing any of the previously mentioned aspects).
will a prefilter reduce the amount of backflushes required in the life of the filter and make it last longer? without a doubt. for a 1-2oz penalty it seems like a good investment.
btw most of the water i encounter is not good water.Oct 26, 2010 at 12:24 pm #1658197
Sawyer claims 1 million gallons over the life of the filter. I don't see the need to prolong it's life in such terms. It's guaranteed to filter 1 million gallons, difficult to prove I'm sure but I would assume they'd be happy to replace a faulty unit.Oct 26, 2010 at 12:26 pm #1658199
they may gurantee a million, but do you really expect this filter to last the rest of your hiking life or do you see yourself purchasing anothet at some point in the future?Oct 26, 2010 at 12:32 pm #1658200
You CAN field backflush, but I've found that the best way is to rig a second hose w/quick connect &, basically, decided it's instead easier to just run the prefilter. I forget exactly how far I got last time before the flow rate got annoyingly slow, but I think it was around 6 days filtering for 2.
My field backflush set-up used another hydration hose/fitting, quick connects, second platy. Hook up for reverse flow, sometimes stand on platy to generate enough pressure for backflush. Usually not needed. Or I could eliminate the extra components.
For shorter trips could probably do away w/backflush and prefilter, BUT since my water source is filled straight from the river and has all the included floaties (leaf detritus, etc) I figure the prefilter is easy, not a big weight issue, & might save me a little headache.Oct 26, 2010 at 12:35 pm #1658201
It may very well last the rest of my hiking life. Although, as ULer I'm always looking to reduce my base weight and at 6oz total I'm sure they'll come up with something else that will serve the same function at a lighter weight in the coming years. For now I feel that this is one of the better systems out there and is relatively cheap when you compare the other options. If it broke due to my negligence I would promptly go out and buy a duplicate model without reservations.Oct 26, 2010 at 12:37 pm #1658202
Are you guys using sawyer filters or purifiers?Oct 26, 2010 at 12:42 pm #1658205
I'm using a Sawyer In-line Water Filter which is an older model than was mentioned in the OP and sold at REI.Oct 28, 2010 at 7:42 am #1658868
So here is the final mockup of what I want my filter to look like once its completed. I stole the off-center fitting idea from the platypus(or is it some other brand?) that I saw. The combination off-center fitting + 1 micron pre-filter bag + carbon filter, should squeeze as much life out of the sawyer as possible without slowing down the flow too much. I saw a video of the biodiesel bags in action on youtube, they literally let the water flow through as if it was not there.
I like the system because the parts that wear out are easily replaceable. Replacement biodiesel fuel filter bags are cheap, especially if bought big and cut down to size($1 or so), im sure they will last quite awhile(2 weeks maybe). Activated carbon is cheap in bulk as well. I would just stick an aquamira frontier pro in there and ditch the micron bag and casing with activated carbon, but I’ve used them for 2 years now and usually have to replace them fairly quickly. They are more prone to clogging because of their design.
On a related note. Where would is store such a prefilter bag when im done with it? Im thinking a zip lock would promote the growth of all kinds of things. Maybe on the outsize of a pack in slightly opened ziplock to allow moisture to evaporate?Nov 6, 2010 at 5:55 am #1661654
@powell1njLocale: North Carolina
I'd be interested to see more specifics on the 'inline fuel filter casing with activated carbon' when you get that all finished. I believe I saw on another post that you're still trying out different carbon, filters, etc. Let us know what you finally come up with. It would be great to the final weight (obviously), cost, assembly/construction as well as how it affects flow rate. I'm looking to modify my current sawyer filter-based gravity system over the winter to get ready for next season. Thanks and have a good one.
NateNov 6, 2010 at 7:09 am #1661661
I currently use the frontier pro in conjunction with bleach drops. I went with this due to the activated carbon already being in the filter. To those of you using the sawyer, does it still make the water clear, just not improve taste? Is it really that different from a filter with carbon? I have heard the sawyer has better flow rates, but if it does not improve taste I would assume that would be a deal breaker for me.Nov 6, 2010 at 8:40 am #1661671
I am still waiting for my Sawyer and my charcoal to come in. Once that comes in I will make the rig and begin the test. Although in the beginning I will not be able to use the cuben bag as the hysol takes a day or so to dry. I will sub in a Platy. I am also making an ac filter out of any energy drink mini bottle as seen on YouTube. My biggest concern is contact time. I feel likethe design of the energy drink bottle would give me more contact time and I think the downfall of the inline fuel filter casing will be contact time as well. I may try using cotton balls to slow the flow in both. I will not be doing testing at my local water supplier, I simply don't hav time. I will filter one sample with the Sawyer alone, then another with the same water with one of the filterig devices included. I will visually and by taste compare the 2 samples. If this high quality ac I got is getting enough contact time, there should be a big difference. I suspect a big difference because I will be using a poor source of water.Nov 6, 2010 at 9:57 am #1661680
@dlcrandallLocale: North Cascades
Here in the Northwest, we have many little trickles of water coming across the trails, and I generally don't carry much water because of the weight. With a Sawyer filter, I carry a "clean" straw tube in a snack-size zip-lock to plug onto the output end, and a section of a toothbrush package as a collector. I hold the collector, closed end at the bottom, under a trickle of water with the input tube in it, on the uphill side of the trail to suck through the straw (you don't even need to take your pack off). You can also turn the open end of the tooth brush package collector downhill under the trickle to channel water into a water bottle, and of course use the straw rig to drink directly from small clear pools.
DaleNov 6, 2010 at 10:49 am #1661689
My stuff came in, i'm making the system now. Will probably get to test it tommorow, i have a party to goto tonight.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.